The Europeans came to the Caribbean in search of wealth, the various people they exploited were fro

Dear Editor,

I refer to a letter which appeared under the caption “Britain was unable to hold its empire, there was no real struggle for Independence,” dated 01/01/07. This letter written by one Leah Lawrence, who claims to offer a few correctives to my letter captioned, “Black nationalism did not inspire violence against Indians.” Lawrence’s letter is littered with historical fallacies. Yet Ms. Lawrence writes with finality about Caribbean history which deserves a response, lest young students reading her letter may come away with a distorted view of history.

I take it that Ms. Lawrence did not properly read my letter and in her reply has not only misconstrued the premise of my argument but has misconstrued history; here is what she wrote. Ms. Lawrence: “European peoples came to the Caribbean, suffered great hardships, invested their money over the centuries, peopled the place with Africans, Indians and others, created the economy of the territories, gave the territories their law, languages, political institutions, administration, education and to a large extent their culture. Europe even gave the territories their thought-process and world-view.”

Reply: This is clearly a callous and poor analysis of history. Europeans came to the Caribbean in search of wealth, found existing civilizations of indigenous peoples (Amerindians) and subsequently murdered entire generations and tribes of Indigenous peoples before embarking on the slave trade and the political economy of slavery, which is arguably the most inhumane venture in the history of humankind. At the end of slavery in 1834, indentured servants were invited to work under the most sub-human conditions. It is important that Ms. Lawrence knows that every non European group of people who came or were forcibly brought to the Caribbean came with language and culture, existed in prior civilizations (with exception of the Indigenous peoples, who it is believed crossed the Bering Straits 50,000 years ago) older than the Europeans. Africans, the original people, are known to have the oldest civilizations on earth. Therefore the Europeans did not give the people whom they brought here anything, what Europeans did was force upon people their way of life in order to control and subjugate them. In a book I am currently working on “Toward Reconciliation, a Case for Guyana” I deal in part with the impact Europeans have had on ethnic formation and subjugation in Guyana.

Ms. Lawrence: “Mr. Wiggins is being deceived into taking the line propagated by Burnham and Jagan and other Caribbean politicians that they were the strugglers for and achievers of national independence. The truth is different

Latest in Letters

default placeholder

Surendra containers held far less than claimed, Specialty Hospital project was mismanaged by Ramotar administration

Dear Editor, I crave your indulgence in a matter of grave concern to me and of potentially having  damaging effects to me, my family and company that I have worked honestly and hard to build.

default placeholder

The CLICO/HCU Commission of Enquiry report should be published

Dear Editor, “Is nuttten but bobbol again!” Here was the concluding comment of an animated conversation I couldn’t but overhear. Two gentlemen – apparently working class Trinidadians, not business moguls – were discussing the business news last Thursday while awaiting their flight.

default placeholder

Constitutional reform needs a decisive President as its champion

Dear Editor, The President said that if constitutional reform means that the executive powers have to be reduced, so be it.

default placeholder

Is Brexit the beginning of a wave?

Dear Editor, The Brexit result was close enough to indicate that there are still a huge number of voters who perceive the advantages of union and globalization. 

default placeholder

Pensioners to be provided with shelter outside Blairmont Post Office

Dear Editor, As you know, the lack of proper accommodation for our senior citizens who must go to the various post offices every month-end to collect their old age pensions and NIS benefits, etc, has been featured in the media quite a lot recently, especially since a pensioner fainted in the line in which he was standing for many hours in the hot sun at the Blairmont Post Office last month.

default placeholder

The government is repeating the mis-steps of the PPP/C

Dear Editor, Those who suffered under the PPP/C and/or were disturbed over that party’s mismanagement of the nation’s business want this government to succeed, for the sake of Guyana and her people.

default placeholder

David Sookram progressed from being a barefooted boy to an eminent professional

Dear Editor, I wish to pay tribute to my father, David Horace Sookram, who died a week ago, aged 86. He was a lawyer and a Fellow of the Royal Society of Economics.

default placeholder

Wishing the Vice Chancellor well in his attempt to depoliticize UG

Dear Editor, The new Vice Chancellor of the University of Guyana has reportedly said that he is prepared to walk away from the job if there is any political interference by government in the management and administration of the university.

Comments

About these comments

The comments section is intended to provide a forum for reasoned and reasonable debate on the newspaper's content and is an extension of the newspaper and what it has become well known for over its history: accuracy, balance and fairness. We reserve the right to edit or delete comments which contain attacks on other users, slander, coarse language and profanity, and gratuitous and incendiary references to race and ethnicity.

Stay updated! Follow Stabroek News on Facebook or Twitter.

Get the day's headlines from SN in your inbox every morning: