Toolbox

Dear Editor,

Recently, I had a discussion with a friend in which the essence of  democracy was discussed and where he believed that it all started with the American Revolution and the articles of the new American constitution. I agreed with his assessment if it was qualified to state that modern democracy was initiated by the American Revolution but the essence of democracy was discovered by the Greeks and actually practised in Athens and other Greek city states. I pointed out that the Federalist Papers are some of the most amazing and comprehensive expressions of the birth of a new state which one could imagine, with the particular expressions of Alexander Hamilton’s brilliant treatises (he wrote the most articles in the  Federalist Papers).

But the birth of a modern democracy in the United States of America was only achieved by the hard work, shared dreams, creative entreprenurship and superlative leadership provided by its first government, led by its greatest president, George Washington. My friend reminded me about the fact that President Washington was able to run a new country with only three ministers – Knox in Defence, Thomas Jefferson in Foreign Affairs and Alexander Hamilton in Finance, and I responded that in fact Hamilton’s brilliance in dealing with the finances of this new state of America, secured the well-being of that country’s future generations by creating the foundation for the birth and survival of a successful free enterprise system and a real democracy.

Hamilton’s treatises on customs duties and tariffs; on federalism (a success story in the American saga); on international banking and the creation of a central bank; on keeping taxation low to encourage investment and spending; on the role of government and its responsibility to the people, all reflect a vision fully supported by President Washington himself.

My friend reminded me that in fact, it was Hamilton who led the final charge at Yorktown in the final British defeat at the hands of the American revolutionaries. I pointed out that a lot of ‘revolution’ scholars like to say that Mao was the man who invented modern guerrilla warfare, but if we look at history honestly, then George Washington was the man who invented guerrilla warfare when fighting the British army, then the best in the world. I further pointed out the terrible struggle against the British for eight long years endowed the American Revolution with resolute fighters like Hamilton who were dedicated to new concepts of democracy.

We both agreed that the American Revolution was a success as opposed to the French, Russian or Chinese revolutions, because in the latter three the essence of democracy was not only lost, but transformed into an excuse for class confrontation which imploded into tyranny. We both agreed that the essence of success in running a country, as proven by the success of the USA, is leadership with a vision for the future, and President Washington along with his three brilliant ministers made sure that the essence of democratic norms remained intact.

But it was not only in talk but in action where Washington set down new standards for democracy for the world to see; he chose to serve only two terms as president even though he could have died in office, thus setting a precedent for democracy in America. As a matter of fact, with the surrender of British forces in New York, Washington as head of all continental forces could have seized military power, but again he made sure that to preserve democracy, all military forces were strictly under civilian control in the name of the Continental Congress. Washington’s administration was the first in the world to push for separate branches of government with each having independence of thought and action: the Executive (President), the Legislative (Congress) and the Judiciary; this separation of powers has made America a much stronger democracy.

The great deeds of President Washington, I assured my friend, from his frontier days as a surveyor to his brilliant generalship during the revolution and finally as the head of state, without a doubt place him in the company of the greatest leaders the world has seen.My friend did not realize the influence which the Greeks had on concepts of democracy, and he was amazed at the following passage by which all governments should abide, especially this government which muzzles the freedom of the press. The following passage is actually from a speech by Perikles, Athens’ greatest orator in 450 bc:

“In our political life we do not emulate the customs of our neighbours; no, rather than imitating anyone else, it is more the case that we are an example for others to follow. Our constitution is called a democracy because government is in the hands not of a few but of the majority; where private disputes are concerned everyone is equal under the law, and men are preferred for public office not because of their rank but because of their excellent qualities, according to their merits and their distinction in some field. On the other hand, no one is prevented by poverty or public obscurity from benefiting the city [Athens] in any way he can…”The Greeks had an amazing civilization with commerce and trade using maritime innovations the world had never seen; great philosophers and historians; and democratic city states which could teach lessons in democracy to some of the rulers of this country.

Yours faithfully,
Cheddi (Joey) Jagan (Jr)

Related Articles


You can follow responses to this article through its RSS feed.

Subscribe to our electronic edition or get home delivery!


Reader Comments

You can discuss this and other articles in our new community forums!


  1. rdman UNITED KINGDOM says:

    Now that the 2011 elections are fast approaching.I want you to come together with the other political parties, and pressure this government to make changes for better Guyana.

  2. cochore UNITED STATES says:

    Great research and scholarship in the piece above…very impressive Banna… Sometimes I wonder if anybody, in Guyana today, knows this stuff other than the academics at UG. Change will come when more young Guyanese are exposed to the history of good governance and participatory democracy.

    You and your friend need to write more newspaper columns on these topics, but please keep it simple and at high school reading level. The AFC or some other political party need to engage the Guyanese electerate in ‘bottom house lectures’ explaining why the American style democracy is applicable to them in their local community.

  3. Joe Coxall UNITED STATES says:

    Democracy in America was highjacked shortly after, when a small group of European bankers sent by the Rothschilds, sneaked in a law into congress that made the Federal Reserve Bank the controlling entity responsible for the distribution and control of the American currency.
    America and Americans have been swimming in dept ever since. The way it is done is that if America or it’s businesses need money, the treasury would print the notes, the government would then give the Federal Reserve a promise of payment of interest to use those printed currencies.

    Enormous profits goes to the Federal Reserve Banks for doing nothing, the US tax payers are left to foot the bill.

    President Kennedy while in office, passed law amendment 111110, to remove this control from the Federal Reserve. The law was passed that would remove control from the Feds and tie the US dollar to American silver reserves. Five weeks later, he was assinated.

    That law still remains in force, but no other president since has ever called for its reinstatement. The Federal Reserve continues to loot America blind by recovering interest on every dollar that the US treasury prints.

    No sooner had slavery in America been abolished than servitude to the world bankers by all Persons living in America began.

    No person or nation ever gets rich on spending borrowed money, Today we are seeing the beginnings of the crumbling of an empire, that has been looted bare by a small group of greedy bankers.

    Joe.

  4. bgsbny UNITED STATES says:

    …….how many people know/knew of what you .. SIr,, so precisely articulated here in precis ,, i can say for sure that the reserve machine is merely a printing press that prints money ,, when people like l’il bush need to show the might of America ,, here’s an example in abc of how this works, the govt need money , to fight a war,, the federal reserve bank ,, is notified to print ,, printing costs 20,000 USD to print X dollars ,,( more like a trillion ),, its then given to the govt who now has to pay interest on the money printed by this unscrupulous and unconscionable gang of jews ,, this is the very same thing Christ was against when they handed him over to pilate to be disposed of !!!!!!!!

    • Joe Coxall UNITED STATES says:

      bgsbny,
      I get get a sense of your anger once you found out how this system works. I along with many others living in America always thought that the Federal Reserve Bank was a government institution. I was shocked to find out that they are actually 12 privately owned banks, that the American government and all businesses that borrow money from the treasury, must pay back that money to them with interest.

      That interest is now so hugh that every child born in America today already owes $160,000.00 to the IRS. They get interest from every credit card, every dollar loaned out by the IMF or the EU, this small group of elite families own all of us by drowning us in credit and mortgages, they also own the rest of the world by this scam of usery.

      Joe.

    • Joe Coxall UNITED STATES says:

      bgsbny,
      If you google around somemore you will find that this “gang” especially loves to finance wars, both sides of the war too. they have no care who wins, after the war, the more destruction to more money is needs to be borrowed to bebuild, it is a win/win situation.

      The Iraqi war is costing American Taxpayers over a million dollars a minute. It is again KACHING KACHING straight into the gangs pockets.
      I envy these guys, what a great way to make a living.

      Joe.



Leave a Reply

About Comments



The Comments section of this website is intended to provide a forum for reasoned and reasonable debate on the newspaper's content and is an extension of the newspaper and what it has become well known for over its history: accuracy, balance and fairness.

We reserve the right to edit/delete comments which contain attacks on other users, slander, coarse language and profanity, and gratuitous and incendiary references to race and ethnicity.

Curious about the little images next to each commenter's name ? Go here and sign up using the same email address you used to register for Stabroeknews.com then upload your image and confirm it.

More articles in Letters