Toolbox

Dear Editor,

Will we ever know how prisoner, Edwin Niles, now deceased, was able to secure seven .22 rounds of ammunition, while he was out working at Camp Ayanganna under the supervision of the prison authorities?

Is the Guyana Police Force in a position to inform the nation as to the status of the investigations into the beating to death of this prisoner?

Luckily, we are aware of the medical reports regarding the cause of death, so the obvious questions must be answered without delay. Who instituted the deadly beating on Niles?

Was it the police, the prison authorities, or army persons? Since the medical evidence revealed that Niles had been severely burnt, and had sustained broken bones and other injuries about the body, we must ask if this is not a clear case of torture? The government must, therefore, advise the nation as to whether this form of interrogation is acceptable to the regime, and whether such cruel treatment of human beings by the disciplined services does not amount to torture. I would be appalled if the government does not answer the latter question in the affirmative, and since they should agree that it is torture the President should then further advise Guyanese whether his government sanctions torture. If the President claims that the administration does not sanction such treatment, he would then need to explain why these acts are perpetrated seemingly without fear of reprimand.

It is unthinkable that in the wake of allegations of torture by Sumner and others that members of the disciplined services would be brazen enough to beat a prisoner to death. If there are any actions on the part of the executive which suggest it has some level of tolerance for torture, then members within the disciplined services might be more inclined to commit such acts.

The current delay in the release of the much anticipated torture report is another example of how people may be led to believe that the government does not regard the torture of Guyanese as a serious issue. The government must therefore act with dispatch to remove all doubt from the public’s mind regarding its position on torture. I believe clear and unequivocal statements must be made and the torture report should not be further delayed. Those guilty of committing these cruel acts against Guyanese must be brought before the courts. We cannot allow another person to be beaten to death, whether in custody or otherwise.

Yours faithfully,
Lurlene Nestor

Related Articles


You can follow responses to this article through its RSS feed.

Subscribe to our electronic edition or get home delivery!


Reader Comments

You can discuss this and other articles in our new community forums!


  1. de canadianCarl Veecock CANADA says:

    Lurlene Nestor…please read the blogs on this issue.

    You are lucky that your letter was published for there was nothing therein that the bloggers did not cover (especially mine if I may dare to so say).

    Power is in the hands of the Government and when one has power,
    one does as one pleases.
    No appeal to do what others see as appropriate will succeed.

    We do as we wish.

    Caput! Finis!.

  2. bbuckman UNITED STATES says:

    me tink you read too much us paypa.

  3. bbuckman UNITED STATES says:

    we nneed to learn from isarel or south africa how create law and order

  4. vijaysingh UNITED STATES says:

    The Govt. supports torture. That is very clear, the reason why Guyanese will do anything to leave for greener pastures. The lack of proper drinking water, regular electricity, no security, living in fear and I can go on. If this is not torture, then tell me what it is.

    • wahdap UNITED STATES says:

      agree with you vijay, if dey didn’t supporting torture they would ah done publish da report, but dey hiding it. Guyanese betta wake up, and smell the lemon.

  5. birds CANADA says:

    For those in authority should answer the question made by Lurlene Nestor.
    In the first who is the Office leave 22 rounds of ammunition? Secondly, who was the Supervising Officer with Niles at the time while working at Camp Ayanganna? Now with those two questions who’s fault it is–Edwin Niles or those responsible for not doing their duty. Then to beat the prisoner for their naglance. Indeed, the Guyanese nation should be updated on the status on the torture report. The Government owe this to the people of Guyana. The editors asking for answers, the Opposition Leaders are asking for answers’ and you owe the Nation an explanation to the question of torture.



Leave a Reply

About Comments



The Comments section of this website is intended to provide a forum for reasoned and reasonable debate on the newspaper's content and is an extension of the newspaper and what it has become well known for over its history: accuracy, balance and fairness.

We reserve the right to edit/delete comments which contain attacks on other users, slander, coarse language and profanity, and gratuitous and incendiary references to race and ethnicity.

Curious about the little images next to each commenter's name ? Go here and sign up using the same email address you used to register for Stabroeknews.com then upload your image and confirm it.

More articles in Letters