Toolbox

Jagdeo pardons Bynoe

President Bharrat Jagdeo yesterday announced a pardon for treason accused Phillip Bynoe, almost six years after he allegedly led a violent protest march on the Office of the President (OP) that resulted in the death of two people.

Phillip BynoeBynoe, who has been on the run since the July 3, 2002 incident, had been writing to the President over the last year, expressing remorse while appealing for clemency. The former leader of the People’s Solidarity Move-ment was charged in absentia with the capital offence, while his co-accused Mark Benschop, who turned himself over to authorities, received a presidential pardon last year while awaiting a retrial.

A statement released by the OP last evening said that acting in accordance with the powers granted to him under Article 188 of the Consti-tution, President Jagdeo has “granted a free pardon to Mr Phillip Bynoe.” The statement added that Bynoe has been writing to the President since 2007, applying to him for a pardon. “In his appeals, Mr Bynoe informed the President about his remorse over the incident; the invasion of the [OP], and the destruction of public property. He also recognised that the event was an attack on a democratic institution of the state and not directed at the President.”

Under Article 188 1 (A) the President has the power to grant any person concerned in or convicted of any offence under the law of Guyana a pardon either free or subject to lawful condition.

Yesterday, President Jagdeo met Opposition leader Robert Corbin to provide a briefing on climate change. Corbin, who promised a fuller statement on the meeting, when asked whether the Bynoe pardon had been discussed, said he had not heard of the announcement and had no comment to make on it.

Last August, President Jagdeo had granted a pardon to Benschop, who had been in prison while awaiting a second trial after the first ended in a hung-jury. He had been imprisoned for five years. Although Bynoe has successfully eluded law enforcement authorities, there have been numerous reports over the years of sightings in Linden and other locations.

At the announcement of the Benschop pardon, Presi-dent Jagdeo was asked whether he would extend a pardon to Bynoe. He replied in the negative, saying he would have to face due process of the courts.

Benschop had also written to Jagdeo, who said he felt the former talk show host had learned his lesson. The President described the decision to free Benschop unconditionally as a personal one, admitting that he still believed that both men were involved in the invasion of the OP. He said: “He [Benschop] was involved. I think he was and I have always said that they [Bynoe and Benschop] led those people here and caused two of them to lose their lives.”

He added of Benschop: “It has nothing to do with the judicial process. I feel he was guilty of misleading those people and bringing them here. I am exercising the presidential pardon and not a judicial pardon. The judiciary has the right to say he is guilty or not guilty but personally, I feel that he had a significant role to play.”

According to the particulars of the treason charge, contrary to Section 318 (a) of the Criminal Law Offences Act (CLOA), Bynoe between June 1 and July 3, 2003, being a citizen of Guyana and owing allegiance to the state of Guyana, formed an intention to overthrow the lawfully elected Government of Guyana by force. During the said period, in furtherance of the aforesaid intention, he allegedly: (A) Conspired together with persons to forcibly and unlawfully enter into the compound and premises of the OP; (B) Was present at and encouraged others by words and conduct, to unlawfully overtake and storm the OP compound and premises.



You can follow responses to this article through its RSS feed.

Subscribe to our electronic edition or get home delivery!


Reader Comments

You can discuss this and other articles in our new community forums!


  1. M. Xiu Quan-Balgobind-Hackett UNITED KINGDOM says:

    I haven’t the faintest idea to what you’re referring.

  2. quibian CANADA says:

    carl veecock, two people are dead because of the actions of bynoe and benschop and you are calling it “proper protest which unfortunately went awry”. what about the victims and their families? now you are saying that hinckson should be “pardoned” too. hinckson who was jointly charged with a recently deceased criminal for weapons possesion. a criminal whose gang had a stolen army weapon that might have been used to kill a policeman and a citizen.

    • decanadianCarlVeecock CANADA says:

      quibian….you probably new to this issue:

      1. the people were killed by the police while they were swarming the
      Office of the President.
      Did you know that?
      It was police killing of unarmed people ! Did you know that ?

      2. Hinckson was charged with sedition and that is the matter under trial.

      3. You refer to a recent charge but that I have not followed but if that be so,
      it would be further attempts by the government ‘to get their man’ regardless.
      It did not work with Benschop for they had him locked up so long and
      harassed his wife and family unconscionably. He also lost his son in the
      murder and arson activity in Queens. Did you know that?

      4. bear in mind that charges of treason in Guyana is an untested area and
      it would appear that the government is bent on a new legal regime to go
      after any opponents on the ground that if you say anything against the
      government in a public forum, it is unpatriotic and treasonious.
      They desperately tried to lasso Hammine in this Hinckson case
      but they failed. Hinckson’s comments were made at Hammie’s
      press conference !! …Did you know that?

      C’est tassez de moi.

  3. balo UNITED STATES says:

    Article l88 of the Guyana Constitution states that the president may grant pardon to anyone who is convicted. In the eyes of law one is innocent until found guiltyBynoe and Benschop were only charged ;never convicted. I think the DPP is the person who has the power to withdraw charges. Is there anyone there who supports this.

  4. ultimate w CANADA says:

    Oh crap ! everybody is so fired up . But cool , i’m enjoying the name calling , the yelling , the political history and the finger pointing . Canadian Politics just turned like joke too but you people beat them !

    If Bynoe reading this , he might be laughing his head off too.
    You all should argue like this everyday !
    I’m having fun reading this !!

  5. JUAN GABRIEL BAHAMAS says:

    When will the charade end? I am tired of this circus! When will the clowns get some much deserved rest?

  6. JUAN GABRIEL BAHAMAS says:

    The people who lost their lives were there voluntarily, they were there because they believed in a cause. Their lives were not lost in vain the miscreants will soon have to atone for their sins.

  7. BIG D, UNITED KINGDOM says:

    Quibian,I endorse your comments.Weapons are still missing,and I suspect that there are still more gang members out there.

  8. Mme Defarge GUYANA says:

    Smoke and mirrors, illusions, plentiful in Guyana. A lot of what we think we know, we don’t know at all. A healthy dose of scepticism is needed.

  9. BOND 005 CANADA says:

    The president should look at how the PPP is using public office for personal and political gain



Comments Page 6 of 6« First...« Prev456

Leave a Reply

About Comments



The Comments section of this website is intended to provide a forum for reasoned and reasonable debate on the newspaper's content and is an extension of the newspaper and what it has become well known for over its history: accuracy, balance and fairness.

We reserve the right to edit/delete comments which contain attacks on other users, slander, coarse language and profanity, and gratuitous and incendiary references to race and ethnicity.

Curious about the little images next to each commenter's name ? Go here and sign up using the same email address you used to register for Stabroeknews.com then upload your image and confirm it.

More articles in Local News