US credibility on the line in Egypt

Dear Editor,

Your editorial on events in Egypt (SN Jan 30) is on the mark. As  international media reports indicate, every dictator in the Middle East is  feeling worried if their time (to be toppled by a people’s revolution) is  coming soon after what took place in Tunisia and spreading to Egypt, Yemen,  Jordan, etc.

As the editorial noted  America has an interest in political stability in Egypt and the region but  America is also responsible for backing regimes that suppress people’s rights and  she now has a duty to back the people’s demands for democratic change.

There is no place for authoritarian rulers. People have a natural right  to choose their rulers who must abide by their wishes. Failure to do so, they should be removed from office and if it takes street protests to achieve that  goal, so be it.  While SN is right  that the protesters in Egypt are from varied economic class groups, it was  mostly the young who are engaged in pitched battles with security forces as was  the case also in Tunisia and is the case in other Arab countries.  And it was also young Guyanese who took up the mantle in New York in struggling for the restoration of democracy in  their former homeland.

I should note that as a student of international politics, what has been taking place in the Middle East took place in other regions with much success  although it did not work in Guyana to topple our dictatorship because of the unique condition Guyana found itself.

In  fact, the Middle East protests have brought back memories  of the anti-dictatorial struggles in Guyana and New York geared towards bringing  down the Guyanese dictatorship and the restoration of democratic elections.

Similar protests in several countries  —  Philippines, South Korea,  Indonesia, Iran, Thailand, Taiwan, etc. brought down dictatorships and installed  democracies. But in Guyana during the dictatorship era, opposition protests were not successful in toppling the dictatorship because the US did not give a helping hand to the movement fearing the rise of a communist government unlike  in the Asian countries where the US forced the dictators to leave office.  The US is somewhat hesitant in backing  the people’s revolutions in the Middle East fearing the rise of Islamic  governments that may want to return to medieval  practices.

I should note  that the Middle East protests have been successful in spite of a lack of public  support from their nationals in the US, which is quite different from what took  place in Asia during the 1980s. There was effective lobbying by Asian Americans  of American politicians for an end to dictatorial rule in their home countries.  I remember attending several Asian organized protests in New York and even  hosting a lecture (as leader of the student government) for former Philippines  Foreign Minister Raul Manglapus at City College.  Manglapus turned against the dictator  Marcos earning my respect and a lecture at CCNY. The fall of Marcos paved the  way for the fall of other Asian dictators and it is hoped the same will happen  in the Middle East with the fall of Ben Ali in  Tunisia.

With regards  to Guyana, modeled after similar protests and lobbying by nationals of other  countries settled in the US, a handful of us (Guyanese and a few Trinis)  abandoned income and organized protests during the 1970s through 1992 and  lobbied American politicians to use their power to force democratic changes in  Guyana.  This change would not come  about until the fall of communism when the US felt Guyana’s opposition was no  longer a threat to its interests.

Although it  was the US that was largely responsible for the restoration of democracy in  Guyana, we should not forget that it was the US (and Britain) that installed and  propped up the Guyana dictatorship.  And it is the US that has been propping up the Mubarak dictatorship in  Egypt and that has provided military aid to the dictatorships in Algeria,  Tunisia, Yemen, etc and so many others that have been oppressing their people  and blocking their democratic aspirations.

American credibility is on  the line. The US has used diplomatic language urging reforms in Egpyt.  It should do the same relating to the  other dictatorships and don’t wait till protests spread to them. It  would have been much better for the US to encourage and back democratic  movements instead of supporting dictators to suppress democratic aspirations as  happened in Guyana.  Had the US  backed Guyanese early in their struggle against the dictatorship, we would have  avoided many of the problems we face. And the same is true of the Middle  East.

Yours faithfully,
Vishnu  Bisram

More in Letters

default placeholder

GRA employees are not public servants

Dear Editor, According to the media there appears to be a misconstruction of roles, respectively of the Chairman and Board of the Guyana Revenue Authority, and that of the President, GPSU; probably because in one instance the authors are uninformed of the Revenue Authority Act 13 of 1996, amended by 16 of 2003, Clause 2 (1) which reads as follows: “Functions of Governing Board (16 of 2003) “(1) The Governing Board shall be responsible for – “a)   subject to subsection (2) the approval and review of the policy of the Authority; “b)   the monitoring of the performance of the Authority in carrying out functions; and “(c)  the discipline and control of all members of staff of the Authority appointed under this Act.” In an apparent rush to personalise a difference of positions between the two parties much ado has been made of the quoted expressions of the Chairman, as distinct from the statutory authority of that office and the Board.

default placeholder

Fishermen from Guyana and Suriname are the ones most affected by piracy

Dear Editor, I write on behalf of the Caribbean Network of Fisherfolk Organisation, the Guyana National Fisherfolk Organisation and the Suriname Fisherfolk Organisation ‒ Visserscollectief.

default placeholder

SOCU and SARU wield a political hatchet but masquerade as law enforcement agencies

Dear Editor, Just last week, I examined the causal connection between taxation and fear and economic decline in the context of the Guyanese economy.

default placeholder

To hang or not to hang

Dear Editor, To hang or not to hang has been a topic in Guyana, the Caribbean and much of the free world for several decades.

default placeholder

Working at grass-roots level more effective than Candlelight Vigils

Dear Editor, I wish to express my appreciation for the complimentary remarks and invitation extended by Mr Annan Boodram of Caribbean Voice in his letter of 21st July in the Stabroek News, in the context of the ‘debate’ on rum and alcoholism, etc (‘Letter on alcoholism referred to all alcoholic drinks, not just rum’).

default placeholder

Thoughts on the second day of the Test

Dear Editor, Lunch-time second day of the first Test India v West Indies: I watched half of the morning session on TV and listened carefully to the comments of Bishop and Dujon about the handling of the bowlers.


About these comments

The comments section is intended to provide a forum for reasoned and reasonable debate on the newspaper's content and is an extension of the newspaper and what it has become well known for over its history: accuracy, balance and fairness. We reserve the right to edit or delete comments which contain attacks on other users, slander, coarse language and profanity, and gratuitous and incendiary references to race and ethnicity.

Stay updated! Follow Stabroek News on Facebook or Twitter.

Get the day's headlines from SN in your inbox every morning: