Argentina hurts itself in Falklands/Malvinas

On the 30th anniversary of Argentina’s ill-fated invasion of the Falklands/Malvinas islands, one thing seems clear: Argentina’s government is pursuing the worst possible course to recover the British-controlled South Atlantic islands.

Before we get into President Cristina Fernández de Kirchner’s disastrous policy regarding the islands, let’s state that Argentina’s historical claims to the Falklands-Malvinas are legitimate.

Great Britain’s position that there can be no negotiations on sovereignty as long as the estimated 3,200 islanders wish to remain British doesn’t hold up, most international law experts say.

Columbia University law professor Julius Goebel’s 1927 book The Struggle for the Falklands, and a 1983 sequel by Yale University international law professor Michael W. Reisman leave little doubt that Great Britain’s occupation of the islands is illegal.

To make a long story short, the only negotiated transfer of the Falklands/Malvinas sovereignty took place in 1767, when the French ceded them to the Spanish Crown. When Argentina became independent, it legally inherited all formerly Spanish territories.

So when the British occupied the islands in 1833 and called them the Falklands, it was basically a land grab.

The Falkland/Malvinas made headlines world-wide on April 2, 1982, when Argentina’s military dictatorship, in an obvious effort to boost its sagging popularity at home, invaded the islands.

Former British Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher sent the British armada, and Britain regained the islands, after a war that left nearly 1,000 dead.

The fact that much of the world’s public opinion sided with the British because of a generalized revulsion over Argentina’s military junta’s actions, does not change the basic premise that the islands belong to Argentina, Reisman wrote. In most legal systems, title goes to the proper owner, not to the nicest person, he argued.

Cristina Fernández de Kirchner

Now, with Fernández de Kirchner’s populist government facing growing public discontent at home, and with reports of huge oil and gas discoveries off the islands, the Argentine government is once again putting the Falkland/Malvinas dispute on the front burner.

Whether it’s because it wants to divert attention from Argentina’s rising inflation or because it is anticipating an oil bonanza in the South Atlantic, Fernández de Kirchner has launched a diplomatic offensive throughout Latin America to prevent ships flying Falkland Islands flags from stopping in their ports.

According to press reports, this is already causing shortages of fresh fruits on the islands.

In addition, Argentina is threatening legal action against firms drilling gas and oil off the Falkland/Malvinas, which the islanders fear may keep the islands from substantially increasing their income.

Nigel Haywood, the British governor of the islands, told Argentina’s daily El Cronista recently that “Argentina is constantly threatening to make our lives increasingly complicated.” He added, “Every week brings new threats” from Argentina’s government.

An Argentine friend who has just visited the islands confirmed to me this week that the Kelpers, as the islanders are known, are not angry at the Argentine people, but they see the Fernández de Kirchner government as the enemy.

The Kelpers are, among other things, worried about the Argentine president’s recent request to Chile to take over the Lan Chile airline-operated flights to the mainland, the only ones connecting the islands with South America. The islanders fear that if these flights are taken over by Argentina, they will be left at the mercy of the Argentine government‘s whims, he said.

One of the few voices of reason in this dispute has come from a group of 17 Argentine intellectuals who recently signed a document called ‘An alternative vision.‘ They stated that Argentina can’t keep ignoring the islanders’ wishes. Argentina’s current policy of demanding sovereignty over the islands without taking into account the islanders’ desires weakens Argentina’s justified demands for a negotiated solution, they said.

My opinion: Instead of scaring off the islanders with constant threats, Argentina should try to seduce them. It should offer them free medical airlifts and first-class medical treatment in Argentina for islanders with health emergencies, free shipments of whatever they need, and whatever cultural and sports exchanges they are willing to accept.

Given the islanders’ misgivings about the Argentine authorities, it won’t be easy. The wounds will take time to heal.

But the Argentine government’s current hard-line policy is more designed to win quick applause at home than to recover the islands. It may help shore up support for the government, but it hurts Argentina’s own national interests.

© The Miami Herald, 2012. Distributed by Knight Ridder/Tribune Media Services.

(Editor’s note: We regret that there will be no column by David Jessop this week or next.)

Latest in Features, Sunday

default placeholder

Can Guyana afford parking meters?

‘Cities love meters – they are a “captive” income source. … unless you know someone or are a “public figure”, the city will tow your car if you have too many tickets.

20160629Development Watch29

Government spending and the economy

Last week the Private Sector Commission (PSC) urged the government to increase its spending to stimulate the needed aggregate demand to sustain business activity.

default placeholder

Peru’s president-elect demands freedoms in Venezuela

Peru’s pro-business President-elect Pedro Pablo Kuczynski won his country’s elections by a hair with the last-minute help of a leftist party, but — judging from what he told me in an interview — he won’t budge on his criticism of Venezuela and other repressive regimes.

default placeholder

Public financial management: 1966 – present (Final)

This is the fifth and final in a series of articles on the above aimed at highlighting the extent of our achievements in the post-Independence period.

LUCAS STOCK INDEXThe Lucas Stock Index (LSI) rose 0.54 per cent during the third period of trading in June 2016. The stocks of six companies were traded with 79,573 shares changing hands. There were three Climbers and one Tumbler. The stocks of Banks DIH (DIH) rose 1.98 per cent on the sale of 18,757 while the stocks of Demerara Distillers Limited (DDL) rose 5.26 per cent on the sale of 41,667 shares. In addition, the stocks of Demerara Tobacco Company (DTC) rose 1.51 per cent on the sale of 13,603 shares. In contrast, the stocks of Demerara Bank Limited (DBL) fell 5.26 per cent on the sale of 4,324 shares.  In the meanwhile, the stocks of Guyana Bank for Trade and Industry (BTI) and Republic Bank Limited (RBL) remained unchanged on the sale of 222 and 1,000 shares respectively.

Massy and Guyana (Part 1)

Steadfast Last year, this writer looked at the Massy Group of Companies formerly Neal and Massy to gain an understanding of the operations of this company which has been doing business in Guyana for the past 48 years. 


Value-added performance of the forest sub-sector: Erratic, weak, declining

Erratic Last week’s column highlighted what I consider to be a most distinctive feature of the extractive forest sub-sector’s performance in Guyana’s economy, during the past decade.

default placeholder

The UK bids Europe farewell

On June 23 by a small majority, the British people voted to remove themselves from the European Union (EU). The decision has consequences for the Caribbean.

default placeholder

What would life be without sport?

I wonder what it would be like to exclude sport completely from one’s life for, say, one year? No playing sport, no watching it, no reading it no discussing it no thinking about it even.


About these comments

The comments section is intended to provide a forum for reasoned and reasonable debate on the newspaper's content and is an extension of the newspaper and what it has become well known for over its history: accuracy, balance and fairness. We reserve the right to edit or delete comments which contain attacks on other users, slander, coarse language and profanity, and gratuitous and incendiary references to race and ethnicity.

Stay updated! Follow Stabroek News on Facebook or Twitter.

Get the day's headlines from SN in your inbox every morning: