Challenges and threats to economic stability Part 2

Thus far in this series of columns dealing with the 2012 National Budget I have catalogued two of four challenges and/or threats to near to medium-term macroeconomic stability in Guyana, under the caption of ‘global developments.’ The remaining two will be addressed today. These are 1) the deterioration of export marketing conditions for GuySuCo’s sugar consequent to the European Community’s (EC) denunciation of the EC-ACP Sugar Protocol (SP) in 2009; and 2) the uncertainty surrounding funding for forest services provided under the Guyana-Norway Memorandum of Understanding (MoU). Afterwards, I will continue to catalogue items under the second caption.

Sugar marketing disruptions
At the core of item 1 listed above are the lingering complications caused by the EC’s denunciation of the SP and the coming into force of the related Cariforum-EC, Economic Partnership Agreement (EPA). Writing on this topic in September 11, 2011 I had reminded readers that, during the 1990s and up to 2005, the SP had provided annual income transfers from Europe to Guyana, which averaged roughly 7.5 per cent of our GDP. These transfers are calculated as the gap between the prevailing world price for sugar and the SP price in force multiplied by the quantity of sugar Guyana supplied under the SP. The SP quota had provided for 160,000 tonnes of annual sugar sales to the EC.

Starting in 2006, the SP price paid by the EC was reduced in stages from 523.7 euros per tonne of raw sugar to 335 euros by October 2009. Between the latter date and the end of this year (2012) a price floor (or minimum reference price) of 301.5 euros per tonne remains in force; however, if the prevailing world price exceeds the floor price, the former would be paid by the EC. Additionally, the EPA now provides for ‘duty free quota free’ sugar sales from Guyana to the EC, subject to transitional provisions that come into force if the marketing of sugar is seriously disrupted during the first six years of the EPA.

Forest services sales
I have repeatedly observed in previous columns that Guyana’s sale of forest services is advanced by the authorities as both a low carbon development strategy (LCDS) designed to secure the country’s sustainable development and a vehicle to secure external funding in return for ensuring its rainforests are not destroyed. This latter is being pursued through the avoided deforestation provisions of the United Nations’ REDD + arrangements.

Over the past six years a great deal of the country’s governmental resources have been tied up in these pursuits; first, in securing the Guyana-Norway MoU, 2009 and second, through strong participation in international efforts aimed at securing public and private funding in return for the contribution of poor countries to the fight against global warming and climate change. So far, the financial returns for these efforts have been, to say the least, disappointing.

Thus for example, under the 2009 MoU Norway had pledged over the next five years a total of US$250 million as payment for validated forest services, which are to be provided by Guyana. For several reasons this pledge has not materialized. Indeed the 2012 National Budget reported that, at the end of 2011, two tranches of the pledge had been transferred by Norway to the Guyana REDD+ Investment Fund (GRIF) totalling US$70 million. GRIF is the agreed institution for disbursing these funds to approved projects. The 2012 Budget indicates approved projects representing only about 10 per cent of the total funds paid into GRIF.

The brief description above highlights the challenges and threats to economic stability due to uncertainty over the materialization of payments for providing forest services.

National economic management
I shall turn now to consider a second grouping of challenges and threats to economic stability, which I term national economic management. This captures three items, namely: the HIPC legacy, statistical delusion, and big government.

HIPC legacy
Previously in this series of columns on the 2012 National Budget I have observed that Guyana’s earlier designation as a highly indebted poor country (HIPC), marked one of the world’s most brutal peace time policy-driven assaults on the livelihoods of citizens of a country. As a consequence I believe our country requires economic managers who will keep this sombre experience always at the forefront of their deliberations and actions. Based on the HIPC legacy I urge that we do not embark on a path which requires in any way running the risk of slippage in the government debt to GDP ratio, whether through deliberate actions or inattention. In other words the HIPC legacy permits no retreat from strict containment of sovereign indebtedness.

This leads directly to the second item, which is economic managers should also be cognizant of the risk of statistical illusion inherent in the recent official adoption of the new rebased 2006 price series national accounts data. For years Guyana was a poster-child for unexplained real value added (GDP) stagnation. Many studies ‘explaining’ this phenomenon were conducted by the IMF and World Bank. With the adoption of the rebased GDP series, stagnating real value added instantly disappeared, as not only has the GDP growth rate increased but its total value and components have also increased in size by about two-thirds to three-quarters! The jury remains out on whether this has been a true occurrence or statistical illusion. In this sort of situation economic managers are invariably unsure of the reality on the ground and are prone to make policy miscalculations.

Next week I shall deal with the third item, big government, and then continue with cataloguing the other challenges and threats to economic stability.

Latest in Features, Sunday

default placeholder

Passport application blues

I was dreading the process of getting my passport renewed since the beginning of this year. I do not know if there are other countries where folks feel anxiety at getting such a task done because of the fear of the long wait.

20160623Stabroek News Cartoon June 23 2016

Thursday’s Cartoon

Thursday’s Cartoon

default placeholder

Government and GPSU: politics without vision

About a week ago, with ‘tears in their eyes’, some of the executive members of the Guyana Public Service Union (GPSU) shared with the Stabroek News ‘their bewilderment at the lack of movement on the part of the administration to begin the collective bargaining process despite making several public statements about its importance’ (GPSU alarmed at gov’t lack of engagement on public service wage talks).

Saieed Khalil

An Ounce of Prevention: Nipping Domestic Violence in the Bud

By Saieed Khalil   Author’s note: On Saturday June 25th, the University of Guyana’s Diploma of Social Work Class of 2014-2016 in collaboration with the Ministry of Social Protection, will be hosting a walk to raise awareness of domestic violence.

default placeholder

Pope Francis losing support in Argentina

Pope Francis is very popular around the world, but there are growing signs that his popularity is dwindling in his own country, Argentina.

default placeholder

Public financial management: 1966 to present (Part IV)

This is the fourth in a series of articles on public financial management in Guyana’s post-Independence period. The three previous articles covered developments from 1966 to 2001.

default placeholder

Bryan Hunt

Bryan Hunt has proven that you don’t have to dress like a diplomat to excel at being one. During the period that he has been here, particularly over the fourteen months that he performed the functions of the head of the US Mission, his steady and deft hand has helped to monitor both Guyana’s general and local government elections and stabilize relations with Guyana after accusations by the previous government against Ambassador Brent Hardt of interfering in Guyana’s internal affairs.

default placeholder

The anguish of each belongs to us all

Recently I read two poems which I want to share without much commentary – partly because they speak for themselves. The first is by Primo Levi, the Italian chemist and resistance fighter, who survived the Auschwitz death camp and thereafter wrote books of astonishing grace and hope about agonizing tragedy and ultimate evil.


About these comments

The comments section is intended to provide a forum for reasoned and reasonable debate on the newspaper's content and is an extension of the newspaper and what it has become well known for over its history: accuracy, balance and fairness. We reserve the right to edit or delete comments which contain attacks on other users, slander, coarse language and profanity, and gratuitous and incendiary references to race and ethnicity.

Stay updated! Follow Stabroek News on Facebook or Twitter.

Get the day's headlines from SN in your inbox every morning: