Romney should heed Payá’s message

It’s very nice of US politicians to express their grief over the death of Cuban dissident leader Oswaldo Payá, but if they really want to honour his memory, they should stop making aggressive statements that play directly into the hands of the Castro brothers’ dictatorship.

I had the honour of interviewing Payá nearly a dozen times over the past two decades, and as I reread my notes this week following his tragic death in a still mysterious car accident in Cuba, there is one thing that stands out: Payá consistently maintained that Washington’s tough talk or actions against Cuba are counter-productive.

Payá, a Cuban Mahatma Gandhi who was a frequent Nobel Peace Prize nominee, advocated non-violent action against Cuba’s dictatorship within the country’s existing laws. In 2002, he gathered 24,000 signatures within the island asking for a referendum to allow fundamental freedoms. The regime dismissed the petition, but a seed was planted.

In our conversations over the years, Payá said repeatedly that Washington’s harsh rhetoric on Cuba helps the Castro regime perpetuate the myth that the United States is preparing to invade the island, and that Miami’s Cuban exiles want to evict Cubans from the properties they left behind.

Such fears may sound outdated for most informed people outside Cuba, but are deeply ingrained in an island where there is no free press, and where government propaganda has bombarded the population with that message for five decades, he used to say.

Oswaldo Payá

In May, 2004, days after former President George W Bush announced new restrictions on US travel and family remittances to the island, Payá told me — as I reported in The Herald at the time — that the new sanctions were a bad idea.

They were counter-productive, because they shifted the focus of attention away from the confrontation between Cuba’s dictatorship and the Cuban people, and into a confrontation between the Cuban regime and the United States, which was exactly what the Castro brothers wanted, he said.

“Now, once again, all of Cuba’s media will be flooded with stories about Cuba versus the United States,” Payá said.

What should the United States do? I asked him. Payá, who opposed the US embargo on the island, responded that Washington should give peaceful dissidents “political and moral support,” but without imposing sanctions on the island.

Referring to the Bush travel and remittances restrictions, he said, “I think that those who brought forward these measures did so for their own reasons, and not looking at Cuba and the peaceful opposition movement.”

In October 2007, hours before Bush gave a major speech on Cuba, Payá told me that “Bush, or whoever succeeds him, should draw a line in his rhetoric on Cuba: step up the defence of human rights on one hand, and leave aside statements about new US ‘programmes’ and ‘commissions’ for Cuba’s transition, which smack of US interventionism.”

In January 2008, when I asked him about visits by leaders of Brazil, Mexico and other Latin American countries to Cuba, Payá said that such trips were “palace visits” that — far from helping to accelerate Cuba’s transition to democracy — helped strengthen the Cuban regime.”

“We are not asking for intervention in Cuba’s internal affairs, but we are asking for solidarity with the cause of human rights, of dialogue and of peaceful change in Cuba,” he said. By visiting the island and meeting with the regime but not with opposition leaders, visiting leaders “are helping to further harden this regime, and to discourage the Cuban people,” he said.

My opinion: Now that Governor Mitt Romney is accusing the Obama administration of being soft on Cuba, and that the Romney campaign is promising to reinstate travel and remittances’ restrictions on the island if the presumptive Republican candidate wins the November elections, it’s a good time to remember Payá’s words.

Toughening up US measures against Cuba at a time when the island’s octogenarian military dictators are at the end of their lives would only give them political oxygen to continue playing the David v Goliath game.

If Romney and his followers are really sincere in their desires for a free Cuba — and not just talking tough to win votes at home — they should heed Payá’s advice and give moral and political support to Cuba’s peaceful opposition, but without getting the United States into the conflict.

© The Miami Herald, 2012. Distributed by Knight Ridder/Tribune Media Services.

More in Features, Sunday

Latin View

Trump’s coronation was like that of a ‘maximum leader’

I learned in journalism school that what you see often is more important than what you hear, so I decided to turn off the television volume during much of the Republican National Convention that proclaimed Donald Trump as the Republican’s presidential candidate, and to take notes.

default placeholder

Three welcome developments: The appointment of the Tax Chief, the Head of FIU, and the Bid Protest Committee

Three important appointments were recently announced, namely the Commissioner-General of the Guyana Revenue Authority (GRA), the Director of the Financial Intelligence Unit (FIU) and members of the three-person Bid Protest Committee.

20160725Dave Chadee

Caribbean chases Zika preparedness, after death of mosquito expert

By Gerard Best   Gerard Best is a researcher and writer covering social issues across the Caribbean and Latin America. Based in Trinidad and Tobago, he is the former New Media Editor at Guardian Media Limited and the Caribbean Communications Network, the country’s largest media companies.

These children enjoyed being pushed home by a cousin


Riverstown, a village on the Essequibo Coast, is pressed between Pomona and Airy Hall. Once you cross the railway-like bridge over a black water creek, you’re in Riverstown, where there are more than 700 residents.


Mobile money: a technological fad or serious economic business?

No one knows Imagine talking to a friend on the phone while thousands of dollars are pressed to your ears and no one knows it. 

default placeholder

Development imperatives for the extractive forest sub-sector

Regrettable underperformance Readers would have no doubt readily gleaned from the subject matter which was addressed in last Sunday’s column, whether it was a boon for Guyana or a regrettable loss as I had represented it, for a country of its size, vulnerability, and poverty, which was also exceptionally well endowed with forest resources, to be seemingly boastful of its historically comparative low deforestation rate.


About these comments

The comments section is intended to provide a forum for reasoned and reasonable debate on the newspaper's content and is an extension of the newspaper and what it has become well known for over its history: accuracy, balance and fairness. We reserve the right to edit or delete comments which contain attacks on other users, slander, coarse language and profanity, and gratuitous and incendiary references to race and ethnicity.

Stay updated! Follow Stabroek News on Facebook or Twitter.

Get the day's headlines from SN in your inbox every morning: