Despite a new methodology and scoring system, Transparency International’s Corruption Perceptions Index (CPI) has once again given Guyana an extremely low mark (28 out of 100 points) on its annual report card. As dispiriting as this score is, it will have come as no surprise to most citizens.

Despite early signs that President Donald Ramotar appeared to be concerned about corruption in the country, he has done little, apart from condemning corruption in the Police Force at the Annual Police Officers’ Conference in March, to tackle vigorously the perceptions of corruption tainting the public service and his party’s record in office.

In his insightful analysis of the People’s Progressive Party (PPP) and the challenges facing it, former PPP grandee Ralph Ramkarran states categorically that “[T]he allegations of corruption and lack of transparency in the country remain one of the major weaknesses that the Party has failed to confront. There is now some reluctant admission that corruption exists. Unless institutional and legal measures follow these admissions, this would be a major, continuing source of disappointment among Party supporters.” He could just as easily have said that the government’s failure to confront corruption has been a major, continuing source of disappointment among Guyanese as a whole.

The 2012 CPI has Guyana one place up from last year’s ranking, at joint 133rd out of 176 countries, alongside Comoros, Honduras, Iran, Kazakhstan and Russia, and just below Nicaragua with a score of 29. Among Latin American and Caribbean countries, Guyana bettered only Paraguay, with a score of 25, Haiti – seemingly perpetually on the brink of failure as a state – and Venezuela, both registering 19 and coming 165th. We are at the bottom of the rankings of the English-speaking Caribbean and in very poor company generally.

On the other hand, our sister Caricom state Barbados scored a hugely impressive 76, placing 15th, while Chile and Uruguay were joint 20th, and The Bahamas, St Lucia, Puerto Rico, St Vincent, Dominica and Costa Rica were all in the top 50. For these regional countries, perceived to be among the most transparent and accountable in the world, there must be a measure of satisfaction, even as, one imagines, there is a determination on the part of their governments, private sector and civil society, to build on the positive assessments to improve their profiles as trading partners and as destinations for investment and tourism.

For other countries in the region with major developmental ambitions, which scored less than 50 though still ranking above Guyana, such as Trinidad and Tobago (score: 39; rank 80th), El Salvador, Jamaica and Panama (all 38 and joint 83rd), Suriname (37 and 88th) and the Dominican Republic (32 and 118th),  the CPI ought to be something of a wake-up call. For where corruption is perceived to be a serious problem, it is an inhibitor of development and society pays a high cost.

The Transparency Institute Guyana Inc (TIGI) has accordingly called for action in key areas, including, “the urgent appointment of an Integrity Commission, with members who are competent and independent enough to scrutinize the financial disclosures of politicians and bureaucrats and with adequate staffing and resources”; “the urgent appointment of members of the Public Procurement Commission to provide independent oversight of public procurement and to minimize government’s involvement in the process”; the strengthening of existing anti-corruption institutions, such as the Guyana Police Force and the Financial Intelligence Unit established under the anti-money laundering legislation; and the appointment of an Ombudsman to address grievances from members of the public.

TIGI has also urged the implementation of modern anti-corruption and whistle-blowing legislation, as well as laws to regulate election campaign financing, and has also called for all public moneys to be placed in the Consolidated Fund and for no public expenditure to be incurred without parliamentary approval. In addition, appointments to public office should be advertised and made with due regard to technical competence, and the Access to Information Act should be made operational.

Politics is, to a certain extent, about listening to the various voices in a country and seeking to act in the best interests of all with a view to moving the country forward. Leadership is, by and large, about being courageous enough to face up to the greatest challenges in order to take decisions, often unpalatable to some, and to ensure their enforcement. Combating corruption in Guyana requires political leadership of the highest calibre and we look to the President and the Parliament to show their mettle.

More in Editorial

default placeholder

Postfactual politics

“Everyone is entitled to his own opinion,” said US Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan a generation ago, “but not his own facts.”  What would Moynihan say if he were alive to witness an election in which so many facts have disappeared into the unfathomable data stream of social media?

default placeholder

Emergency Medical Service

Last month when he announced government’s plan to expand our emergency medical services Minister Joe Harmon stopped short of acknowledging that the emergency response here is downright poor, and that it fails to provide timely and life-saving assistance to citizens.

default placeholder

Show us the money

Something seems to be not quite right with the accounting at City Hall, or if it is, there is a huge misunderstanding that needs to be cleared up.

default placeholder

Jamaica-Trinidad & Tobago relations

It might have been surprising to observers that so soon after the 37th Caricom Heads of Government meeting from the 4th to 6th of this month, the Trinidad & Tobago Prime Minister Dr Keith Rowley should have chosen to make an official visit to Jamaica to discuss bilateral relations between the two countries.

default placeholder

Same old, same old

Sunday’s comprehensive defeat suffered by the West Indies cricket team in the first of four Test matches against a clearly superior Indian outfit provided a poignant reminder that the road back from ignominy to international cricketing respectability in Test cricket will be long and difficult, and that it may well take a generation or more ‒ if indeed those days do return even that quickly.

default placeholder

Disruption of Region Five council

It’s now been over six months since the meetings of the Region Five council have been disrupted by APNU+AFC councillors over a perceived slight to President Granger by the Chairman of the Region, Vickchand Ramphal who happens to represent the opposition PPP/C.


About these comments

The comments section is intended to provide a forum for reasoned and reasonable debate on the newspaper's content and is an extension of the newspaper and what it has become well known for over its history: accuracy, balance and fairness. We reserve the right to edit or delete comments which contain attacks on other users, slander, coarse language and profanity, and gratuitous and incendiary references to race and ethnicity.

Stay updated! Follow Stabroek News on Facebook or Twitter.

Get the day's headlines from SN in your inbox every morning: