The PNC was illegally in office when Jagan was banned from Parliament for being disruptive

Dear Editor,

Is Andaiye of Red Thread for real? What’s her gripe in comparing past PPP non-violent opposition history with the current opposition parliamentary ruckus? In her letter to SN of November 10 titled  ‘When out of office the PPP used civil disobedience while Jagan was banned from Parliament after throwing law books on the floor,’  she nevertheless was accurate that PPP leader Dr Cheddi Jagan was banned for being disruptive by Sase Narine, who was the Speaker. The Speaker terminated Dr Jagan’s right to speak in parliament.  In fact the PPP leader even took away the Speaker’s mace which was a symbol of his authority.  PPP MP Ishak Bashir of Essequibo also pelted a drinking glass at the Speaker which missed him. It was later revealed the miss was deliberate. But the PNC was illegal and undemocratically ‘elected.’  Compare Andaiye’s ambivalence to the ruckus that opposition MPs displayed when Mr Rohee was speaking. Has the Speaker censured anyone in a way similar to Dr Jagan’s punishment?   Somebody must remind Andaiye that a no-confidence motion bill passed in Parliament can have no effect unless the President chooses to act on it. It means the opposition‘s no-confidence motion against Minister Rohee is null and void.

Minister Rohee still continues as the lawful Minister of Home Affairs as he was elected to Parliament and constitutionally appointed minister by the President. The Speaker has been advised that there is no legal way to remove Minister Rohee or deny him the right to speak in Parliament.

He has not been found guilty of wrongdoing.  Any punishment of Minister Rohee therefore would only be violating the highest law of the land which is the Guyana constitution, just to satisfy opposition demands.

Undoubtedly Andaiye was outraged when Dr Walter Rodney was assassinated, but was she also similarly outraged when the WPA teamed up with a party, elements of which were associated with that killing?

Yours faithfully,
Sultan Mohamed

More in Letters

default placeholder

What is the relevance of race? We are all Guyanese

Dear Editor, After 50 years of independence ‘race’ seems as much a divisive construct as it ever was. Whatever political currency race held has been lost, evident in the underdevelopment of our nation these many years later.

default placeholder

This is our opportunity to shine

Dear Editor, Thank you for publishing my last letter on the subject of the Venezuelan refugees. Since then, I have seen Freddie Kissoon pick up the issue and Minister Harmon’s comments on it on TV and as reported in the Chronicle.

default placeholder

Guyana needs a Local Content Law

Dear Editor, Oil has been found in Guyana and optimistically production will begin in 2020. This offers Guyana the incredible opportunity of leapfrogging beyond the annual incremental 3-5 % economic growth to annual growth rates in the double digit range.

default placeholder

The Indigenous people and their land have been highlighted so politicians can become famous

Dear Editor, It’s with interest I read in the news these days about the leaders in Guyana playing the environmental card to the world.

default placeholder

Cancer is one of the greatest public health threats of the 21st century

Dear Editor, First I wish to applaud Mr Annan Boodram for his excellent and timely letter on alcohol and some of its major effects on this society, and the issue of alcohol in our culture.

default placeholder

There should be an investigation into why Thelma Rebeiro of Shulinab has not regained consciousness after four months

Dear Editor, The Amerindian Action Movement of Guyana (TAAMOG) is calling on the Guyana Medical Council (GMC) to conduct an urgent investigation to determine the reason or reasons why patient Thelma Rebeiro of Shulinab Village, south central Rupununi, Region 9 to date has not regained consciousness after four months following two surgeries for gallstones.

Comments

About these comments

The comments section is intended to provide a forum for reasoned and reasonable debate on the newspaper's content and is an extension of the newspaper and what it has become well known for over its history: accuracy, balance and fairness. We reserve the right to edit or delete comments which contain attacks on other users, slander, coarse language and profanity, and gratuitous and incendiary references to race and ethnicity.

Stay updated! Follow Stabroek News on Facebook or Twitter.

Get the day's headlines from SN in your inbox every morning: