All children in a school should be treated, not just a particular group

Dear Editor,

On November 15, 2012, Muslims celebrated their New Year and many people are not aware of that.  Jadid may not be as well known as other Muslim holidays such as the Eid-ul-Fitr and Eid-ul-Adha, but it is greeted with great hope and optimism. Editor, we are living in a multicultural society and I must admit I am always interested in and admire the efforts of the various religions to keep up their traditions. There is a lot to be learnt, and schools help a lot but they will not teach you everything.

On November 15, I went to collect my daughter from an East Bank Essequibo primary school (name supplied) at lunch time (I was late) and she was not in her class. I was directed to visit a classroom upstairs (Grade Six B) by one of the many parents I see there whenever I go. Upon entering, I saw a lot of children, some of them wearing Muslim clothing all sitting and eating food and drink in the class, whilst the majority of the children were in the compound playing.

I got concerned and enquired from one of the parents who said that because of the Muslim New Year the Muslim children attending the school were being giving a treat. Right away I got angry and started to ask questions, and I learnt the following:

A) The head teacher who was nowhere to be found had asked some Muslim parents to donate food, drinks, cakes or whatever they could for the Muslim children of the school for the Islamic New Year.

B) She tried to get a half day for the school so that the non-Muslim children could go home and the Muslim children could be treated.

C) Children were asked to wear their Muslim clothes for the afternoon session (some believed that was the only way for them to be treated) and I see a few who did that (more than one feeding session).

Editor, when it’s a Hindu holiday almost all the children in any school take part in celebrating; likewise if it’s a Christian or Muslim holiday. My five-year-old daughter could not understand why they were only treating some children and not all. These are primary school children and one would not have to assume what the children would think of those who got fêted or what they will say to them when they go to play or vice versa. I told a few people about this (some of them are Muslims) and they all expressed disgust at what took place.

Editor, I would like to know if the Ministry of Education is aware of this and why they allow it.
Look at where we are today in Guyana (culturally and racially) and I would have expected better from a head teacher. I am asking that the head teacher write an apology to all the parents of the school. I would have been happy if all of the children of the school were educated about the Islamic New Year and how that comes about.

Yours faithfully,
Sahadeo Bates           

Editor’s note
We sent a copy of this letter to the Region 3 Deputy Regional Education Officer Ms Douglas (her superior  was on leave) for any comment she might have wished to make and received no response. We then sent it to Regional Education Officer Ms Marlyn Jones Donaghue on her return from leave, and have likewise received no response.

More in Letters

default placeholder

GRA employees are not public servants

Dear Editor, According to the media there appears to be a misconstruction of roles, respectively of the Chairman and Board of the Guyana Revenue Authority, and that of the President, GPSU; probably because in one instance the authors are uninformed of the Revenue Authority Act 13 of 1996, amended by 16 of 2003, Clause 2 (1) which reads as follows: “Functions of Governing Board (16 of 2003) “(1) The Governing Board shall be responsible for – “a)   subject to subsection (2) the approval and review of the policy of the Authority; “b)   the monitoring of the performance of the Authority in carrying out functions; and “(c)  the discipline and control of all members of staff of the Authority appointed under this Act.” In an apparent rush to personalise a difference of positions between the two parties much ado has been made of the quoted expressions of the Chairman, as distinct from the statutory authority of that office and the Board.

default placeholder

Fishermen from Guyana and Suriname are the ones most affected by piracy

Dear Editor, I write on behalf of the Caribbean Network of Fisherfolk Organisation, the Guyana National Fisherfolk Organisation and the Suriname Fisherfolk Organisation ‒ Visserscollectief.

default placeholder

SOCU and SARU wield a political hatchet but masquerade as law enforcement agencies

Dear Editor, Just last week, I examined the causal connection between taxation and fear and economic decline in the context of the Guyanese economy.

default placeholder

To hang or not to hang

Dear Editor, To hang or not to hang has been a topic in Guyana, the Caribbean and much of the free world for several decades.

default placeholder

Working at grass-roots level more effective than Candlelight Vigils

Dear Editor, I wish to express my appreciation for the complimentary remarks and invitation extended by Mr Annan Boodram of Caribbean Voice in his letter of 21st July in the Stabroek News, in the context of the ‘debate’ on rum and alcoholism, etc (‘Letter on alcoholism referred to all alcoholic drinks, not just rum’).

default placeholder

Thoughts on the second day of the Test

Dear Editor, Lunch-time second day of the first Test India v West Indies: I watched half of the morning session on TV and listened carefully to the comments of Bishop and Dujon about the handling of the bowlers.


About these comments

The comments section is intended to provide a forum for reasoned and reasonable debate on the newspaper's content and is an extension of the newspaper and what it has become well known for over its history: accuracy, balance and fairness. We reserve the right to edit or delete comments which contain attacks on other users, slander, coarse language and profanity, and gratuitous and incendiary references to race and ethnicity.

Stay updated! Follow Stabroek News on Facebook or Twitter.

Get the day's headlines from SN in your inbox every morning: