We need to stop blaming the victims of rape

Dear Editor,

I read yesterday in SN (December 28) that in India the 23-year-old medical student gang raped, beaten and thrown out of a bus has died.  Her injuries were far too extensive for her to survive.  I am not ashamed to say that I cried.  Over the years I have found myself crying too often, immobilized by my own helplessness when I hear or read stories such as this or worse when I am confronted by real women who have suffered similar fates.

I cannot count the number of times the thought has crossed my mind that perhaps women need to be armed whether with pepper spray or guns. Over the past week or so I have been following in SN a discussion centred on the modalities of dress and how it has the potential for leading to rape.  So here is my response.  Take it or leave it.

To say that a woman’s state of dress or rather undress can be a causative factor for rape is probably the most simplistic, unintelligent garbage I have come across in a long time.

It is an old excuse trotted out by some men and women to shift blame from the rapist to the victim.  It has fuelled many debates and controversies over the years.  So I will say what many have said before. Clothes don’t cause rape.  Rapists cause rape.

We need to stop blaming the victims of rape for being raped.  Don’t come to me telling me mini-skirts and low-cuts tops gives a man, any man the room, the space, the right to access a woman’s body.

Are men such savages that the mere sight of a cleavage or stretch of thigh will cause them to lose control to the point of beating, raping, murdering women?

The student in India travelling home on the bus wasn’t dressed provocatively, neither was the 11-year-old girl in the US gang raped by 18 men, nor the elderly woman in the UK raped and murdered outside her home.

What about all the women and children, here in Guyana, in all parts of the world who were raped for reasons that had nothing to do with the clothes they wore.  The list is long, too long of women and children raped because they are physically weaker, vulnerable for reasons of financial, social, cultural and political inferiority or invisibility.  Do any of us really believe that by donning garments that shroud our physical form rapists will stop raping?   I think not.  As one writer pointed out in a recent letter on the subject, women in burqas are also victims of rape.

By its very nature rape is about the domination of the powerless by the powerful.  It empowers the rapist whether he is driven by lust, anger, boredom or any other “cause” that fuels his need.  Any attempt to shift the focus, the blame for this most abhorrent of crimes to the victim is truly despicable.

Yours faithfully,
N Sagar

More in Letters

default placeholder

Local businesses may not be able to afford six months’ maternity leave

Dear Editor, Minister of Public Health, Dr George Norton and the Minister of Social Protection, Ms Volda Lawrence are very happy with the recent pronouncement with regard to the six-months maternity leave benefit for all working mothers which will bring Guyana in line with PAHO’s guidelines.

default placeholder

Venezuelans should be allowed to come under controlled circumstances

Dear Editor, I have relatives resident in Essequibo who located jobs and developed businesses in Venezuela during the hard times here. 

default placeholder

Countless men and women work to make changes in citizens’ lives in their communities

Dear Editor, Once again it is Emancipation time; it is once more the season of introspections, reflections of sorts, reminiscing, and above all cultural and festive activities for people of African descent.

default placeholder

Grateful for removal of sign

Dear Editor, I write to express my gratitude to your newspaper on behalf of Digital Technology for publishing a letter on Friday, July 22, regarding a leaning sign in front of our premises at Diamond.

default placeholder

East Canje Reunion Day in US brought together over 7,000 people

Dear Editor, Large gatherings planned by the Guyanese diaspora in the USA, Canada and the United Kingdom have brought thousands of Guyanese together for one day and in one space, reuniting villagers, families, friends and neighbours.

default placeholder

Bishnodat Persaud was a great economist and teacher

Dear Editor, It is with deep sorrow that I received the news that distinguished Guyanese economist Prof Bishnodat Persaud, a resident of the UK, has passed away.


About these comments

The comments section is intended to provide a forum for reasoned and reasonable debate on the newspaper's content and is an extension of the newspaper and what it has become well known for over its history: accuracy, balance and fairness. We reserve the right to edit or delete comments which contain attacks on other users, slander, coarse language and profanity, and gratuitous and incendiary references to race and ethnicity.

Stay updated! Follow Stabroek News on Facebook or Twitter.

Get the day's headlines from SN in your inbox every morning: