Ramkarran did not acknowledge African feelings of disenfranchisement

Dear Editor,

Former Speaker Mr Ralph Ramkarran’s recent column in the Stabroek News – ‘The PPP’s enduring fears‘ (January 14) is a brilliant reflection, from the inside, on the principal factor that has informed the PPP’s political behaviour since it took office in 1992. Some of us have, perhaps simplistically, referred to this as the ‘politics of revenge.’ The central argument of this column should be digested by all political operatives and non-governmental organizations, especially those who are tasked with interfacing with the PPP on a regular basis.

But even as I laud it I do have a problem with the column. It has to do more with what was omitted than what was said. While the gist of the column was about the PPP’s fears that are rooted in six decades of history, it is, perhaps unfair, to discuss those fears outside of the PNC’s and by extension African Guyanese fears. Mr Ramkarran spends the second half of the column discussing how the PNC could address the PPP’s fears and, although he did not say so explicitly, by extension the Indian Guyanese fears. Very well.

But the PNC’s inability to treat candidly with its stewardship of the state is rooted in the very six-decade history that informs the PPP’s contemporary behaviour. Both parties and their respective ethnic constituencies share that history and have individually and together shaped it. I make bold to say that just as the PPP’s behaviour in office  has been heavily influenced by the perception and reality of  its treatment at the hands of the PNC in office, that the PNC’s behaviour in office was also largely grounded  in similar fears, perceived and real, arising from the PPP’s 1957-64 tenure.

Mr Ramkarran’s reference to the Indian Guyanese and PPP feeling of electoral disenfranchisement is spot on. But he omits the African Guyanese feelings of disenfranchisement. Whereas Indian Guyanese suffered from elections that were rigged against them, African Guyanese suffer from the fact that the electoral system is rigged against them. The PNC stole elections. The PPP has not stolen elections in the same barefaced way, but they have barefacedly stolen the executive government.

The present government is a prime example. The presidency was won by the PPP. But the remainder of the executive branch, the cabinet, was not won by the PPP. The results, accepted by the three political contestants, show that the majority of voters did not vote for the PPP. But those results are not reflected in the executive branch.

I anticipate that the constitutionalists on both sides will tell me that the all-PPP cabinet is a reflection of the presidential system whereby the president can choose his entire cabinet from his party if he wishes. But I wish to remind us that Guyana does not have a pure presidential system. Ours is a hybrid system—part presidential and part Westminster-parliamentary. And our cabinet functions in the parliamentary mode—unlike the pure presidential system where cabinet members do not sit in the legislature, our cabinet members sit in parliament.

From my standpoint, therefore, both the PPP and the PNC have fears born of our shared history of ethno-political insecurity and rivalry. Both parties’ behaviour in government has been largely driven by these fears.  Both parties should make statements of atonement, preferably together.

Yours faithfully,
David Hinds

Latest in Letters

default placeholder

‘I did resign as Ambassador to China’

Dear Editor, Foreign Minister Carl Greenidge may have been inadequately briefed when he made inaccurate statements about me in Kaieteur News (‘Those ambassadorial appointments…’  June 26).

default placeholder

No good reason was given for scrapping the fuel export licence to the Chinese

Dear Editor, The question is: Why the scrapping of the fuel export licence? A government can end a licence for good cause and according to set procedures which seek to assure fair play.

default placeholder

IDB report looks at housing in Guyana, including hinterland

Dear Editor, During a meeting last week of representatives of the Caribbean diaspora with officials of the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB) part of the discussions focused on the findings of a study by the bank entitled ‘The State of Social Housing in Six Caribbean Countries.’ One of the countries is Guyana and one of the report’s authors, Michael Donovan was among the panellists.

default placeholder

Low-cost housing for the poor needs to be available for rental

Dear Editor, Tiger Bay has been an age-old concern since I was born, and now I am an elderly person. This community has had a notorious reputation even though it has produced reputable persons.

default placeholder

Does the Roads Inspection Unit still exist?

Dear Editor, Governments and ministers are servants of the populace and definitely not the other way around, and at a given juncture, they must be able to facilitate visits by concerned citizens and community groups, etc.

default placeholder

Life for senior citizens should be made easier

Dear Editor, Our senior citizens are much more deserving of respect than what is currently meted out to them both in the public and the private sectors This is particularly evident at banks and post offices especially at month ends when salaries and pensions become payable.

default placeholder

Congratulations to the WI team and coach

Dear Editor, Praise to the team, and special congratulations to the coach. Home has not been a significant advantage to West Indies for a long time, so there is obviously something else that explains winning against both Australia and South Africa.

default placeholder

All eyes are on Sherod Duncan

Dear Editor, I am concerned about Mr Sherod Duncan on two fronts. Firstly, his meteoric rise to fame and stardom is dazzling and because of this, he has to be wary.

Comments

About these comments

The comments section is intended to provide a forum for reasoned and reasonable debate on the newspaper's content and is an extension of the newspaper and what it has become well known for over its history: accuracy, balance and fairness. We reserve the right to edit or delete comments which contain attacks on other users, slander, coarse language and profanity, and gratuitous and incendiary references to race and ethnicity.

Stay updated! Follow Stabroek News on Facebook or Twitter.

Get the day's headlines from SN in your inbox every morning: