Foreign workers must also train locals but none at Marriott

Dear Editor,

I have read in the various print media of the outrageous statements made by head of the Privatisation Unit, Mr. Winston Brassington in defence of the hiring of Chinese workers instead of Guyanese workers for the Marriott Hotel Project.

Mr. Brassington has cited the language barrier and that Guyanese workers do not have the skills for that type of construction.

It appears that Mr. Brassington is not living in Guyana or he is not a Guyanese or he has no respect for the Guyanese work force.

Guyanese construction workers are well renowned for their expertise in Guyana, the Caribbean and North America. The previous Prime Minister of Barbados Mr. Owen Arthur publicly praised the Guyanese construction workers in Barbados. All the hotels, houses and large buildings in Guyana were built by Guyanese workers, some under the supervision of foreign professionals.

I cannot see why Mr. Brassington must ridicule the intelligence of the Guyanese nation by stating that Guyanese does not have the skills to work on the Marriott Hotel project. I smell a rat here because this whole Marriott Project is clouded with secrecy and controversies.

On January 28, 2013, the Globe and Mail newspaper in Canada reported a similar situation in Canada.

A Chinese company, HD Mining Company had  to send back sixteen temporary Chinese foreign workers to China who had been hired to work on the company’s Murray River Coal Project in Vancouver saying a high- profile court case has resulted in too much uncertainty to keep the workers in Canada.

Two labour groups, that is, trade unions filed a court action challenging the work permits.

HD Mining has said it sought foreign workers because it was not able to find the skilled workers it needed in Canada. The labour groups have challenged those claims, saying the company didn’t do enough to try to hire Canadian workers and advertised positions at lower than going rates.

The unions that brought the court case questioned the company’s decision to send the workers back to China, saying the move followed a court order that resulted in HD Mining reluctantly agreeing to turn over résumés of Canadian workers who applied for, but didn’t get, jobs at the Murray River project.

“The B.C. Building Trades questions why HD Mining would decide to pull out of its B.C. coal mine project just days after we received the résumés of 300 Canadian workers who were rejected for jobs that were then filled by Chinese temporary foreign workers,” Brian Cochrane, business manager of IUOE Local 115 (one of the unions), said in a statement.

HD Mining agreed to supply the  résumés after a Federal Court judge ordered Ms. Finley, who has responsibility for Temporary Foreign Workers in Canada to “further consider” her compliance with a court order to compel disclosure of documents – including  résumés of Canadian workers – the unions had sought in court.

That case remains before the Federal Court.

In order to get work permits in most countries, the employer have to satisfy the authorities that the skills are not available in the country and when the foreign worker arrives he must train the local workers, that is, the skills must be transferred to the local workers but in the Marriott Case no skills would be transferred because there are no local employees.

Finally, trade unionism is a dying breed in Guyana and those unions that remain are like empty vessels making the most noise.

Yours faithfully,
BalwantPersaud
Immigration Consultant

More in Letters

default placeholder

Baishanlin’s take-overs of local logging concessions is illegal and Long Jiang Forest Industries’ partial shares acquisition in Baishanlin is illegal

Dear Editor, I am concerned that President Granger may not be receiving adequate briefings over the Chinese transnational logger Baishanlin and the possible replacement Long Jiang Forest Industries Group (also a Chinese state-owned enterprise), with reference to the article ‘Four months on, Harmon’s China trip has produced no results’ (SN, July 25).

default placeholder

Buxton Emancipation activities start this week

Dear Editor, The Buxton First of August Movement (BFAM) kicks off its Emancipation activities this week with a Film Festival and a Symposium.

default placeholder

There is an equally silly dress code for access to GuySuCo offices

Dear Editor, Recent comments in the media on the silliness of the dress codes being enforced at government offices must not be seen as applicable only to the latter; they are also applicable to GuySuCo offices where their enforcement appears even more ridiculous.

default placeholder

The Caribbean Voice has a holistic, collaborative approach to addressing social pathologies

Dear Editor, In response to our invitation to become part of the solution to social pathologies such as alcoholism, suicide, rape, drug use, child abuse, domestic violence and the like, Mr Nowrang Persaud stated, “While I unconditionally applaud all efforts to minimize the negative fallout from alcoholism, suicide, domestic and other forms of violence, I firmly believe that the chances of success in remedial or corrective actions are greater, if we work at the grass-roots level where we can more effectively ‒ as indeed I have been trying to do for the longest while ‒ help to minimize the incidence and the problems”.

default placeholder

Guyana should retain the death penalty

Dear Editor It is palpable that the majority of Guyanese prefer the retention of the death penalty as the best deterrent against capital crime.

default placeholder

There is no militarization of the government

Dear Editor, There seems to be a big concern that the Granger administration is militarizing the government. Well, I am not the least bit concerned about that.

Comments

About these comments

The comments section is intended to provide a forum for reasoned and reasonable debate on the newspaper's content and is an extension of the newspaper and what it has become well known for over its history: accuracy, balance and fairness. We reserve the right to edit or delete comments which contain attacks on other users, slander, coarse language and profanity, and gratuitous and incendiary references to race and ethnicity.

Stay updated! Follow Stabroek News on Facebook or Twitter.

Get the day's headlines from SN in your inbox every morning: