Illegal ‘goods not returnable policy’ still fleecing consumers

- corrective measures cumbersome

Several local business houses, including some big traders, are stubbornly refusing to comply with national laws governing the right of consumers to secure refunds for goods purchased from their stores, a practice that continues to leave buyers saddled with items which or are defective and therefore useless.

In the course of the past two months, this newspaper has received at least half a dozen queries regarding the laws governing refunds for goods bought from local businesses in circumstances where efforts to secure such refunds directly from the stores have been rejected.

In one very recent case of which this newspaper is aware a Regent Street store bluntly refused to accept a customer’s request for a refund, despite the fact that the sides of a pair of shoes had come undone just minutes after the purchase had been made. This newspaper saw the receipt recording the place, date and cost of the purchased item.

The Consumer Affairs Act of 2011 compels suppliers to effect refunds for most goods returned within 7 days of purchase along with receipts and packaging. The customer is not obliged to give a specific reason why the item is being returned beyond the fact that it might not be required any longer. In turn, the supplier is authorized under to law to retain ten per cent of the cost of the item as a handling charge to cover, among other things, repackaging and returning the item into stock.

In the case of defective items, the law dictates that the supplier replace, repair or refund.

0f more than 25 consumers with whom this newspaper spoke only four were aware that the issue of restitution for returned goods was enshrined in the law. None of the four were aware of the specifics of the law.

Up until recently, several downtown stores had sought to protect themselves against customer demands for goods to be taken back or exchanged by hanging ‘goods not returnable’ signs on the front of their premises. While the signage appears to have been removed in the face of warnings by the Competition and Consumer Affairs Commission that such signs should not be displayed, many stores have persisted with the practice.

A consumer affairs watcher told Stabroek Business last week that the return and refund laws are “inconvenient to traders” since there may “lots of cases” in which goods have been in stock for a long time and are therefore “quite likely to be defective by the time they reach the consumer.”

Vendors, the source said, are entirely aware of this and are therefore against the idea of refunds.

Stabroek Business is aware of two instances in which downtown stores declined to provide warranties on generators worth in excess of $40,000 on the grounds that they had been in stock for some time and were probably likely to have defects.

While suppliers of goods transgressing the law are liable to be fined up to $1 million and can be jailed for a period of one year, it appears that the cumbersome nature of the corrective procedures which the consumer might have to endure is a deterrent to the effectiveness of the law.

Having had his or her request to the supplier in question for a request or a refund denied the consumer must take the case to the commission’s Sophia office and comply with a request to put the complaint in writing. Thereafter, the Sophia office makes a formal approach to the supplier with a request for a refund based on an investigation of the case. In cases – and this newspaper understands that those are frequent – where the supplier refuses to effect a refund, he or she is summoned to the Sophia office to discuss the matter in another attempt to secure an amicable settlement. The consumer affairs watcher told Stabroek Business that some of the matters are settled at that level but it is not unusual for some suppliers to show up with their attorneys in cases where refunds pertain to high-priced items. The source said that given the nature of the procedures associated with having the law enforced the vast majority of cases involving relatively inexpensive items do not ever reach the commission’s office.

Stabroek Business understands that those cases that are not solved by the commission’s office are referred to the commissioners for examination and decisions regarding legal action but the effectiveness of the process at that level is often stymied by bureaucratic sloth.

Latest in Business

Guyana Metal Recyclers Association President Michael Benjamin

Metal exporters want urgent presidential intervention

– business ministry working on new procedures Piqued over what it says has been the suspension—without either notice or official notification—of the scrap metal trade by the APNU+AFC administration since June last year, the Guyana Metal Recyclers Association (GMRA) the official umbrella body for local exporters has told the Stabroek Business that the protracted inability of businesses to ply their trade is wreaking havoc with the industry and denying legitimate businessmen the right to earn a living.

The Far Rockaway Hotel

Kwakwani $$$M hotel investment seeks to breathe new life into community

Gavin August may well be unique in the extent of his financial investment in Kwakwani: an estimated $50 million to create a 12-room hotel, which he hopes will pay him back down the road, when the fortunes of the community change.

default placeholder

Does crowdfunding have the power to grow Caribbean economies? (Part 2)

By A Cecile Watson   A Cecile Watson is the founder of She is a former senior regional banker, an international speaker, a certified financial education instructor and the Women’s Entrepreneurship Day Ambassador Regional Leader for the Caribbean.

20160624gold prices June24

Kitco Market

Gold Prices for the three day period ending Thursday  June 23, 2016Kitco is a Canadian company that buys and sells precious metals such as gold, copper and silver.

IDB Chief Economist Jose Juan Ruiz

Caribbean facing savings crisis – IDB

A new study released earlier this month by the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB) has put countries in Latin America and the Caribbean on notice that they are confronted with a savings crisis that might do damage to their economies in the years ahead.


Prices Prepared by the Guyana Marketing Corporation

(Prepared by the Guyana Marketing Corporation and published by Stabroek Business as a public service)*Prices only represent the average Wholesale Farmgate and Retail Prices at the above mentioned markets and are NOT prices set by the Guyana Marketing Corporation or Ministry of Agriculture.

Aunty Picky

Placing a premium on education: Annandale businesses support growth of secondary school

As the story goes, the name Annandale is said to honour the two daughters of the proprietor of the tract of land to which the name was given.

Talks underway: The respective delegations from the Guyana Public Service Union and the Government of Guyana face each other on Wednesday at the start of what could be the country’s most important industrial relations encounter since the Armstrong Arbitration Commission.

GPSU, gov’t pay hike talks opening ‘a transformational moment’ – Yarde

The Guyana Public Service Union (GPSU) is treating the current public service wages and salaries negotiations with the Government of Guyana as “the start of a process aimed at bettering the lot of public servants in a manner that goes way beyond the monetary benefits which we expect will derive from the process,” its President Patrick Yarde has said.


About these comments

The comments section is intended to provide a forum for reasoned and reasonable debate on the newspaper's content and is an extension of the newspaper and what it has become well known for over its history: accuracy, balance and fairness. We reserve the right to edit or delete comments which contain attacks on other users, slander, coarse language and profanity, and gratuitous and incendiary references to race and ethnicity.

Stay updated! Follow Stabroek News on Facebook or Twitter.

Get the day's headlines from SN in your inbox every morning: