Andres Oppenheimer: BRICS’ emerging world bank: good idea, bad timing

This week’s announcement by the presidents of Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa — the so-called BRICS countries — that they will create their own international financial institution was greeted with polite scepticism and some criticism in Washington DC. But on this issue, the BRICS are doing the right thing.

At the BRICS summit in Fortaleza, Brazil, the leaders of the world’s biggest emerging markets — a mixed bag of dictatorships and democracies — announced the creation of a development bank and a lending bank with $100 billion in capital each, that will be used as alternatives to the Washington-based World Bank and International Monetary Fund.

The BRICS’ New Development Bank (NDB) will be based in Shanghai, China. After a diplomatic struggle between China — as the biggest economy, it wanted to run the bank — and the rest, it was agreed that the institution’s top executives will be from Russia, India and Brazil.

latin viewChinese President Xi Jinping and his colleagues emphasized that the BRICS don’t want to replace the World Bank and the IMF, but the Chinese president made it clear that the idea will be to “improve the world’s governing system” and to “widen” emerging countries’ representation in key international decisions.

In fact, they have a point; despite a lot of talk about expanding emerging markets’ voting rights at the World Bank and the IMF, these institutions have not changed substantially since they were created at Bretton Woods in 1944. The United States and European countries retain a much greater representation in both institutions than their current share of the world economy.

In addition to being frustrated by their smaller representation, the BRICS argue that their New Development Bank may be better suited to help developing countries than the IMF or the World Bank.

Brazil and India, for instance, desperately need to improve their infrastructure, an area in which China has great expertise (although we should hope that China’s infrastructure experts don’t recommend their fellow BRICS members to eradicate villagers at gunpoint to build roads and bridges). And they add that the World Bank has been constrained by its environmental rules to make major loans for infrastructure in emerging countries. The new Shanghai-based bank will be able to make more loans for infrastructure with more realistic environmental standards, they say.

The big question, however, is whether the BRICS new financial institutions will materialize.

First, the BRICS are doing this at a time when their economies are heading down. China, which was growing at 10 per cent annually over the last decade, is projected to grow at 7.5 per cent this year, while India’s growth has slowed to 5.4 per cent, and Russia and Brazil are expected to grow by a pitiful 1 per cent each this year.

Second, it won’t be easy to solve internal differences between the BRICS. Despite their warm embraces at the Fortaleza summit, the leaders of China and Brazil are locked in a bitter dispute about bilateral trade. China complains about Brazil’s growing protectionism, while Brazil complains that China is only buying raw materials, while invading it with manufactured goods.

In addition, there will be disputes over who runs the new institutions. China’s economy — the world’s second-largest — is bigger than that of the four remaining BRICS members together, and the Chinese don’t have a tradition of putting money into projects in which they don’t run the show.

Third, the recent history of similar — although somewhat smaller — efforts to launch alternative development banks doesn’t bode well for the newly created institutions. In 2009, the presidents of Brazil, Venezuela, Argentina, Bolivia, Ecuador, Paraguay and Uruguay announced with great fanfare the creation of a Bank of the South. The bank was supposed to have an initial capital of $20 billion and to replace Washington-based financial institutions, but it never took off. It made big headlines when it was announced, and it vanished shortly thereafter.

Fourth, even if the BRICS banks take off, they will be limited in size. The group’s lending institution’s $100 billion capital would be much smaller than the IMF’s $837 billion.

My opinion: The idea of creating new international financial institutions to make additional loans to those made by the World Bank and the IMF is good. The more, the merrier. And if the proposed Shanghai-based bank will help China become a better world citizen, and contribute more in development aid to developing countries, so much the better.

Whether it will happen, and whether it won’t follow the steps of the ill-fated Bank of the South, is a different story.

© The Miami Herald, 2014. Distributed by Tribune Media Services.

More in Features, Sunday

future notes1

Unifying general and technical education

I argued last week that the physical and institutional infrastructure and processes within the education system have changed significantly in recent times.

Latin View

Trump’s coronation was like that of a ‘maximum leader’

I learned in journalism school that what you see often is more important than what you hear, so I decided to turn off the television volume during much of the Republican National Convention that proclaimed Donald Trump as the Republican’s presidential candidate, and to take notes.

default placeholder

Three welcome developments: The appointment of the Tax Chief, the Head of FIU, and the Bid Protest Committee

Three important appointments were recently announced, namely the Commissioner-General of the Guyana Revenue Authority (GRA), the Director of the Financial Intelligence Unit (FIU) and members of the three-person Bid Protest Committee.

20160725Dave Chadee

Caribbean chases Zika preparedness, after death of mosquito expert

By Gerard Best   Gerard Best is a researcher and writer covering social issues across the Caribbean and Latin America. Based in Trinidad and Tobago, he is the former New Media Editor at Guardian Media Limited and the Caribbean Communications Network, the country’s largest media companies.

These children enjoyed being pushed home by a cousin


Riverstown, a village on the Essequibo Coast, is pressed between Pomona and Airy Hall. Once you cross the railway-like bridge over a black water creek, you’re in Riverstown, where there are more than 700 residents.


Mobile money: a technological fad or serious economic business?

No one knows Imagine talking to a friend on the phone while thousands of dollars are pressed to your ears and no one knows it. 


About these comments

The comments section is intended to provide a forum for reasoned and reasonable debate on the newspaper's content and is an extension of the newspaper and what it has become well known for over its history: accuracy, balance and fairness. We reserve the right to edit or delete comments which contain attacks on other users, slander, coarse language and profanity, and gratuitous and incendiary references to race and ethnicity.

Stay updated! Follow Stabroek News on Facebook or Twitter.

Get the day's headlines from SN in your inbox every morning: