Circumstantial evidence links suspect to Pomeroon woman’s murder

A strong trail of circumstantial evidence is pointing to the killer of Pomeroon businesswoman Judith D’Oliviera, according to her distraught relatives, who are criticising what they see as the “poor” police investigation so far.

“There is a trail of strong circumstantial evidence which could build a case against the main suspect but we have seen no sign of any interest in this information. We have been on the ground gathering information since Judith disappeared and we need the police to help us out here,” a relative of the dead woman told Stabroek News on Friday.

But a source knowledgeable about the investigation has disclosed that the information gathered

Judith D’Oliviera
Judith D’Oliviera

so far by investigators has been forwarded to the city for advice on how to proceed. At the same time, the main suspect, who was held twice, is reporting to police daily after being released on his own recognisance.

D’Oliviera had been reported missing on December 26, 2013 and her decomposing body was found in a clump of bushes near Dredge Creek Health Centre, Upper Pomeroon River on January 6. Relatives formed a search party after she had disappeared and following days of gruelling searches her body was located in the remote area.

She had been stabbed in the chest, her hands and feet were broken, her eyes had been gouged out, and her body bore marks of a vicious beating. An autopsy revealed that she died from the stab wound.

“This was no ordinary murder. This was a brutal murder, and it seemed very personal. We know she suffered a lot before she died and we will not rest until the person responsible is placed before the courts,” the relative said.

The last week has been frustrating for D’Oliviera’s relatives who had travelled to Pomeroon to join the search party. They started digging into her life a little closer since she disappeared and stumbled upon what they described as strong circumstantial evidence linking the main suspect to the case. For example, the relatives recalled that they had found her Bible at the home she shared with the suspect in the Pomeroon a few days after she went missing. Yet, when her body was found the Bible was a few inches away.

“How could her Bible be in the home a few days after she went missing and then it turns up next to her body when we find her? How did it get there?” the relative questioned.

She also questioned whether the police made any attempt to take statements from persons in the Charity area who saw D’Oliviera being dragged through the streets of Charity by the suspect on the day she disappeared. The woman had gone to the Charity Police Station to report a domestic issue but was reportedly locked out of the station because the officers believed she was suffering from a mental breakdown.

Relatives had confirmed that D’Oliviera was mentally ill but according to them, she only had occasional episodes; usually after she was beaten by her partner. They said she managed a business in the Charity area and had assets, but was in an abusive relationship.

“People make mistakes… She made a mistake when she got involved with a man who was violent and has a history of violence. We talked to her about it but she struggled to find a way out and now she is dead,” the relative related.

The relative said too that D’Oliveira’s clothing which she was last seen wearing on December 26 was found at her Pomeroon home. In addition, a few days after she went missing sawdust was strewn downstairs of the home and when relatives questioned why this was done they were told it was because of the rains. They have rejected this, saying the home is a potential crime scene and should not have been tampered with.

“We are completely shattered by her death, by the lack of police interest in the case and by how crucial evidence has been disregarded. Women are being murdered every day in this country and families have to wait years for justice,” the relative said.

She said the family has since learnt that the main suspect had been previously arrested on a murder charge but was freed after no body was ever found. According to her, the police insisted that D’Oliviera’s body had to be found before a case could be made out against the suspect. On two occasions, the police led the search party, but after the lead investigating rank journeyed to the city, relatives were forced to keep the search going without them.

“Well we found the body. We searched for days to find her and we did, but is there a case? We even did our own little investigations and still, no case. What more do we have to do before we get justice for Judith?” the relative added.

Police had arrested the main suspect when D’Oliveira went missing and again after her body was found but released him saying there was no hard evidence linking him to the murder and also no eyewitness.

According to the source, the relevant statements were taken and investigators returned to the area last weekend to continue the probe. A team of investigators from the city also travelled to the Pomeroon to assist the Charity police with the case.

More in Local News

Indrawattie Chandradeo and her two remaining sons and her only daughter in tears at their home yesterday

Two men, teen boy found shot to death at Mibicuri Creek

By Bebi Oosman   The bodies of two men and a teenage boy, bearing gunshot wounds, were discovered yesterday at Mibicuri Creek, Black Bush Polder and police had one person in custody up to late last night facing questions about their shocking deaths.

Minister of Public Infrastructure David Patterson and contractors checking out the Guyana Revenue Authority (GRA) booth at the procurement symposium for new entrant contractors, which was held at the Arthur Chung Convention Centre yesterday. (Minister of Public Infrastructure photo)

Patterson underlines need for transparency in public procurement

Speaking at a symposium for new and existing contractors, Minister of Public Infrastructure (MPI) David Patterson yesterday stressed the need for transparency in the huge public procurement sector and added that distrust in the system has to be dispelled.

default placeholder

Granger says evidence of dereliction needed for Lawrence’s removal

Minister of Social Protection Volda Lawrence would be removed from office once evidence is presented supporting her dereliction of duty, according to President David Granger, who has lauded her for her work so far.

Dr Madhu Singh (at right) with the team of doctors during the press conference

Dr. Balwant Singh’s Hospital saves heart patient given 48 hours to live

Dr Balwant Singh’s Hospital Inc recently performed its first ever pericardiectomy on a 27-year-old patient who had been given 48 hours to live while hospitalised at another institution.

default placeholder

Private Sector flays City Hall over ‘unlawful’ container fees

While the Private Sector Commission (PSC) has agreed that the Mayor and City Council (M&CC) needs to collect revenue, it has lambasted the council for doing so without consultation and in an unlawful manner.

default placeholder

Dutch team urges more proactive approach to flood management

A largely reactive approach to flood situations has worked well under the circumstances but the current flood management system is vulnerable and may collapse dramatically under extreme conditions, according to a report from a Dutch risk reduction team, which has urged a more proactive approach.


About these comments

The comments section is intended to provide a forum for reasoned and reasonable debate on the newspaper's content and is an extension of the newspaper and what it has become well known for over its history: accuracy, balance and fairness. We reserve the right to edit or delete comments which contain attacks on other users, slander, coarse language and profanity, and gratuitous and incendiary references to race and ethnicity.

Stay updated! Follow Stabroek News on Facebook or Twitter.

Get the day's headlines from SN in your inbox every morning: