Opposition raps TUC over ‘uncompromising’ stance

The opposition yesterday struck back at the “uncompromising” Trades Union Congress (TUC) for its rejection of the terms for the restoration of the subvention to the Critchlow Labour College (CLC) saying that its stance was unfortunate.

“It’s a pity,” chairman of APNU Dr. Rupert Roopnaraine told Stabroek News pointing out that there was complete unanimity in the National Assembly on the matter. “I am sorry that they are taking it the way they are.”

The TUC on Friday repudiated the terms of a consensus agreement in the National Assembly for the restoration of the annual subvention to the CLC, which had been cut by the government eight years ago over accountability concerns. Contending that the opposition had been duped by the government, GTUC General Secretary Lincoln Lewis told reporters that the union movement was “not prepared to sell its rights to the government or to any other.”

Following a heated debate on Thursday in Parliament on a motion for the restoration of the CLC subvention, the opposition agreed with a government proposal for the TUC’s rival, the Federation of Independent Trade Unions of Guyana (FITUG) to have the same number of members as the TUC on the board.  The rejection of this agreement by the TUC reopens old labour divisions with the government-allied FITUG and is seen as deeply embarrassing to the opposition.

Khemraj Ramjattan
Khemraj Ramjattan

Lewis had stressed that while the motion to restore the funds was a timely one the National Assembly cannot dictate who should sit on the CLC’s Board as it was a private institution.  He called the move by the House a violation of the constitution, by-laws of CLC and disregard for the right to freedom of association.

However, Roopnaraine said yesterday that it was not correct to say that Parliament tampered with the structure of the college. “We have not tampered with the structure of the board,” he said while noting that according to the statutes, the trade unions can have eight representatives on the board.

He emphasized that the principle that they wanted to ensure is that the board would be representative of the entire trade union movement. He was hopeful that the TUC would come around. “I’m hoping we can have a discussion with the TUC or meet and forge some kind of compromise with them,” Roopnaraine said.

Leader of the AFC Khemraj Ramjattan slated the TUC for its rejection of the terms. He said that he was extremely disappointed by the cavalier response of the body and said that the AFC committed to the terms thinking that the TUC was going to compromise on governance before they could accept taxpayers’ money.

Government, which is usually hardline over such issues made a huge compromise, Ramjattan said, while adding that given its track record, the PPP’s stance was a “progressive development.” Like Roopnaraine, he said that the AFC was not changing the governance structure of the CLC. “We were saying if CLC wants taxpayers’ dollars then they will have to make the change,” he said, adding that the AFC was not demanding that it be done. “If the government did not want to support (the motion) that was the end of the matter,” he pointed out.

Rupert Roopnaraine
Rupert Roopnaraine

Ramjattan said that he personally asked trade unionist Norris Witter who was present at Parliament about the terms and he said “it seems a forward motion.” The AFC leader said that this was his sentiment too and the stance of the TUC is “most unfortunate.”

The AFC leader added that the TUC’s position is another example of the uncompromising nature of local politics and if the body does not want to change the governance structure of the CLC to the extent of accommodating representatives of FITUG, it was the poor who are going to suffer. He said that he would have preferred that the government restore the subvention without any conditions but this was the deal they got. He added that he cannot see how the TUC “can so cavalierly throw that out the window.”

Ramjattan said that he is not at this stage, prepared to engage the TUC on the matter.

“They have totally trashed us and embarrassed us,” he said while noting that AFC parliamentarian Trevor Williams in whose name the motion was tabled and who piloted it though the House, was a product of the institution and was looking at its interest. “I thought at least the TUC should have been a lot more reasonable in their response,” the AFC leader said. “They themselves don’t want to compromise.”

During the debate, Williams, said that the CLC had been struggling financially since its subvention was cut eight years ago.

On the other hand, members of the government stressed that it was not feasible giving state funds to the institution that they said had problems with financial management. They then floated a compromise, saying that if there was an agreement to share its board representation equally with its historic rival FITUG, they would support the motion.

The opposition  gave in to a government request for Williams’ motion to be amended and  to cater for a 4-4 representation on the board in return for the restoration of an annual subvention, a figure  last stated at some $32 million plus.

When Williams’ amended resolution was put to the vote, it was approved by 61 parliamentarians. The remaining four others were not in the House at the time of the vote.

In addition to the proposed 4-4 membership for the TUC and FITUG, Lewis had pointed out that the board also has a representative each from the ministries of Education and Labour, which would effectively give the government six seats on the board to the TUC’s four.

The Critchlow Labour College
The Critchlow Labour College

Latest in Local News

default placeholder

Cases being built against drug kingpins

Outgoing Deputy Chief of Mission at the US Embassy here, Bryan Hunt has urged patience as it relates to indictments of local drug barons saying that cases are being built in the background that can guarantee convictions.

St Paul’s Anglican Church in Aurora

Aurora Village (Part 2)

Things in Aurora Village are much livelier than in Aurora Estate. Women walk in and out of the health centre with babies hanging from their hips; policemen stand outside the police station bracing against a wooden rail as they talk amongst themselves and shouts of chatter from children playing fill the air.

A Cessna 206 – the model of the planes flown out of Eugene F Correia International Airport, at Ogle yesterday

Probe launched into illegal Cessna flights from Ogle

The Guyana Civil Aviation Authority (GCAA) yesterday launched an investigation into the illegal flights of two aircraft from the Eugene F Correia International Airport, at Ogle, East Coast Demerara.

default placeholder

Broke City Hall seeks gov’t bailout

Debt-ridden City Hall has approached the government for a bailout after undertaking several Golden Jubilee projects it did not budget for.

Trevon Thomas

Youth of Guyanese parentage dies in BVI boat accident

A young man of Guyanese parentage died tragically in Tortola, British Virgin Islands around 10:00 hrs yesterday when the speedboat he was in hit rough waters and capsized.

Two of the better appointed stands at D’Urban Park (Stabroek News file photo/Keno George)

D’Urban Park bleachers to remain

The bleachers at D’Urban Park will not be dismantled as originally intended as government intends to preserve and improve the area and turn it into a facility for public events, President David Granger has said.

default placeholder

Funerals held for Kamarang sisters crushed by tree

Post-mortem examinations were performed yesterday on the two children who were crushed to death on Thursday in Kamarang, Region Seven and they were buried with the village council assisting with funeral expenses.

default placeholder

Plug leakages to prevent state resources from bleeding out

Revenues from ExxonMobil’s oil find here could be at least four times Guyana’s national budget at current market prices, and a top US Embassy official here has urged government to move swiftly to implement measures to ensure transparency and accountability.


About these comments

The comments section is intended to provide a forum for reasoned and reasonable debate on the newspaper's content and is an extension of the newspaper and what it has become well known for over its history: accuracy, balance and fairness. We reserve the right to edit or delete comments which contain attacks on other users, slander, coarse language and profanity, and gratuitous and incendiary references to race and ethnicity.

Stay updated! Follow Stabroek News on Facebook or Twitter.

Get the day's headlines from SN in your inbox every morning: