Gov’t to recognise judiciary’s financial autonomy

Finance Minister Dr Ashni Singh on Wednesday agreed to a framework that would see the judiciary gaining full financial independence.

The minister’s decision came in response to a proposed motion by A Partnership for National Unity (APNU) to postpone the consideration of the 2014 budgetary estimates until the agencies specified under the Third Section of the Constitution were given their financial independence. Only when these agencies control their own finances, APNU MP Carl Greenidge had said, will they be able to dispense their responsibilities effectively.

In an effort to mitigate the postponement the consideration of the estimates, Singh on Wednesday said, “I will be moving at the appropriate time in the Committee of Supply a motion in relation to the estimates of the expenditure of the judiciary to bring those estimates in line with the estimates of the other entities listed in the Third Schedule and which entities already receive a lump sum proposed by government.” He noted that government, again recognising the stipulations of the Constitution, has already reflected budget allocations for the various rights commissions and the office of the Auditor General.

House Speaker Raphael Trotman noted on Wednesday that history had been made as the judiciary would now, in accordance with Singh’s promise, control its own affairs, financial and otherwise. Singh’s decision is a major development and a major deviation from the position government has taken in the past.

In 2012 the opposition parties tabled a motion – the Service Commissions Motion – aimed at moving four service commissions – the Judicial, Public, Teaching, and Police service commissions – towards financial independence, thereby allowing them to draw finances directly from the Consolidated Fund, as opposed to having their allocations provided through the budget by government.

The latter, Greenidge and Alliance for Change (AFC) MP Khemraj Ramjattan had said, compromises the independent functioning of the agencies.

The motion called on government to take steps to modify the Third Schedule specified by Article 222 (a) of the constitution, which does not include the service commissions among those institutions with financial autonomy. While Prime Minister Samuel Hinds said that government would not contest giving the commissions autonomy, he argued that there was nothing unlawful about leaving them as budget agencies. To attain what was being proposed by the opposition, he had said, would require constitutional reform.

And so the opposition attempted to amend the constitution.

Last year, APNU through Greenidge tabled the Constitution (Amend-ment) Bill 2013. The provision of the bill sought to make the Chambers of the Director of Public Prosecutions, the Judicial Service Commission, the Public Service Commis-sion, the Police Service Commission, the Teaching Service Commission, Public Service Appellate Tribunal, the Public Procurement Commission, Office of the Ombudsman and the Guyana Elections Commission all financial independent and therefore autonomous. Although the bill was passed by the House, Legal Affairs Minister Anil Nandlall said that a two-thirds vote, not a simple majority, was needed to amend the constitution, and he said he would advise the President to withhold his assent from the bill. As such, the provisions of neither the bill nor the motion were implemented.

On Wednesday, both Greenidge and Singh announced to the House that meetings between the various political parties of the National Assembly had seen progress. Greenidge said that Singh had indicated his willingness to grant the Judiciary the same financial autonomy as the other agencies under the Third Section, and Singh said he hoped his agreement would prompt the opposition to withdraw their motion, thereby avoiding the postponement of the consideration of the estimates.

Despite Singh’s announcement though, Nandlall is threatening litigation if APNU’s motion for the Finance Minister to reconsider and resubmit the estimates of the public sector is not deemed inadmissible

In a letter sent to Trotman yesterday, and seen by this newspaper, Nandlall makes the case that the motion would “cause the minister to embark upon a course of action which will, ineluctably, collide with Article 218 of the Constitution by requesting, at this late hour, that the minister withdraw and re-submit the estimates, the re-submission of which will manifestly be outside of the constitutionally mandated timeframe of ninety days from the beginning of the financial year.”

Nandlall also wrote: “In the circumstance, I respectfully request that you deem this motion inadmissible and accordingly, restrain its tabling. It is with profound regret that I inform you that if my request is not heeded, another bout of litigation shall be the consequence.”

The purpose of Nandlall’s letter in the light of Singh’s decision is uncertain.

Latest in Local News

default placeholder

Proposed law bans smoking in public places

Proposed tobacco control legislation will see a ban on smoking in public places while cigarette advertising will no longer be allowed and pictorial and text health warnings will have to be displayed on at least 75% of the packaging on tobacco products.

default placeholder

$800M in specialty hospital steel ‘awarded’ to BK

Government needs to explain why about $800 million worth of steel and other equipment that were earmarked for the now-frozen specialty hospital project, went solely to businessman Brian Tiwarie, former President Donald Ramotar says.

Ezekiel Murray

Truck driver jailed for three years for crash causing child’s death

Clyde Barker, the truck driver who was accused of running over 12-year-old Ezekiel Murray along the Friendship Public Road last year and causing his death, was yesterday sentenced to 3 years imprisonment.

default placeholder

Businessman jailed and fined over gun, ammo possession

A businessman was yesterday sentenced to two years imprisonment and fined $100,000 after being found guilty of illegal possession of a firearm and ammunition.

default placeholder

Business minister ‘in denial’ over economic ‘crisis’

Opposition Leader Bharrat Jagdeo yesterday said that Minister of Business Dominic Gaskin is in denial about Guyana not being in an economic crisis.

Kevin Joshua

Man found guilty of disfiguring teen in acid attack

Kevin Joshua, who doused a schoolboy with acid and left him disfigured, was on Tuesday found guilty by a jury of inflicting grievous bodily harm on the youth.

default placeholder

Conflicting evidence by police sees man freed of gun, ammo charge

Accused earlier this year of having in his possession a .32 firearm and matching rounds Mark Calvan was yesterday found not guilty.

default placeholder

Judge unable to hand down sentences due to probation report delays

The absence of probation reports prevented Justice Brassington Reynolds from handing down sentences in two cases at the Berbice Assizes on Tuesday.


About these comments

The comments section is intended to provide a forum for reasoned and reasonable debate on the newspaper's content and is an extension of the newspaper and what it has become well known for over its history: accuracy, balance and fairness. We reserve the right to edit or delete comments which contain attacks on other users, slander, coarse language and profanity, and gratuitous and incendiary references to race and ethnicity.

Stay updated! Follow Stabroek News on Facebook or Twitter.

Get the day's headlines from SN in your inbox every morning: