Goolsarran bolsters view that $4.5B spending illegitimate

Former Auditor General Anand Goolsarran has fortified his view that none of the constitutional provisions cited by the government permitted the controversial spending of $4.5B and he warned that the Finance Minister, Dr Ashni Singh would therefore be personally liable for this sum if the National Assembly disapproves of the expenditure.

In his accountability column appearing in today’s Stabroek News Goolsarran said: “The excess expenditure contained in Financial Paper 1/2014 is as a result of a deliberate act on the part of the Minister not catered for under Article 218 (3). It also breaches the fundamental principle of `no expenditure without appropriation’ as contained in Article 217 of the Constitution and Section 16 of the FMA Act. The Minister would therefore be personally liable under Sections 48, 49 and 85 of the FMA Act, should the Assembly disapprove of all or part of the excess expenditure contained in Financial Paper 1/2014.”

Financial Paper 1/2014 has incensed the opposition and triggered steps towards a no-confidence motion against the government which if passed would bring the government down and lead to General Elections. Unusually, the government has not yet proceeded with the consideration of the paper in Parliament, a sign that it is aware that it could have far-reaching repercussions. On the other hand, the Alliance For Change is proceeding full steam ahead with the tabling of its motion of no confidence which will then leave the onus on main opposition coalition, APNU on whether to support it.

Much of the government’s argument for the expenditure centres around the fact that in previous years the opposition had approved such expenditures and the authority of Article 218 (3) of the constitution.

Goolsarran again rejected the notion that Article 218 (3) provided any cover for the Finance Minister.

“The Minister claimed that Article 218 (3) of the Constitution allows him to authorize withdrawals from the Consolidated Fund without parliamentary approval where there has been no appropriation. This is not true, as this article only covers a situation where it is found that expenditure was incurred for which there has been no appropriation. Article 218 (3) contemplates no role by the Minister in proactively authorizing withdrawals from the Consolidated Fund. It is an after the event scenario where during the execution of the budget a discovery of excess expenditure has been made for which there was no provision. The Assembly has to sanction the expenditure first in order to trigger the Minister’s action, not before”, Goolsarran argued.

With the money already spent, the only other option available to the government would be a deal with one of the two parties in Parliament but that hardly seems likely.

 

More in Local News

default placeholder

Alzarri Joseph called up for Test duty

ST.JOHN’s, Antigua, CMC-Promising Antiguan fast bowler Alzarri Joseph is set to make his Test debut after he was drafted into the West Indies side for the current home series against India.

default placeholder

Caribbean series hopes to crack US market with T20 foray

(Reuters) – Chris Gayle and Shane Watson need no introductions in cricket-playing countries but while they are unlikely to become household names in the U.S.

Renee McDonald

Chair of Bid Protest Committee resigns

Chairperson of the recently-established Bid Protest Committee (BPC) Renee McDonald has resigned even as the body’s first case—Cevons Waste Management’s protest against the Ministry of Communities over the award of a $221M Haags Bosch landfill maintenance contract—awaits a decision.

default placeholder

Main suspect in Black Bush triple murder held, owns shotgun

The main suspect in the Black Bush triple murder has been held and he is the owner of the same type of weapon that inflicted the deadly wounds.

Shane Mc Almont

Two charged with killing missing miner

Just two days after severed body parts suspected to belong to Mahdia miner Shawn Clarke were discovered, two men were charged in a city court with his murder.

default placeholder

Ferry collides with Supenaam stelling

The ferry,  Sabanto  suffered extensive damage after it collided with the Supenaam Stelling last evening and will be out of service until further notice.

Comments

About these comments

The comments section is intended to provide a forum for reasoned and reasonable debate on the newspaper's content and is an extension of the newspaper and what it has become well known for over its history: accuracy, balance and fairness. We reserve the right to edit or delete comments which contain attacks on other users, slander, coarse language and profanity, and gratuitous and incendiary references to race and ethnicity.

Stay updated! Follow Stabroek News on Facebook or Twitter.

Get the day's headlines from SN in your inbox every morning: