Bahadur did not consider that violence on Indian women has more to do with other contemporary realities of Guyana

Dear Editor,

 

In a recent conversation with one of the reviewers of Ms. Gaiutra Bahadur’s book “Coolie Woman…”, I said that I would not continue my critical analyses of this book, at least not openly in the local Guyanese media. My promise emanated from the thought and expectation that if a constructive dialogue on the book takes place, instead of finger pointing, I will join in with the intent to bring the social as well as political aspects of Indian indentured historiography forward, namely to weed out, not wed, inaccuracies, favouritism, nepotism, stoicism etc. I have to break this promise since this book continues to be peddled as the “Bhagavad-Gita” or the “Sita” of Indian female indentured experience in Guyana. Of course, some areas of Bahadur’s book do make a contribution to the field of indentured servitude. However, a majority of the book, let me repeat, a majority of the book is counterbalanced with a slew of sleazy crackpot analyses. Again, the book is based mainly on the author’s personal experience rather than research. Research techniques are poorly applied.

A lot of interviews are dropped in the book as facts rather than analyses. Take for example, the “Surviving History Guyana, 2010.” In the first three pages of the chapter (191-193), there are forty-three “I” or the personal use of the letter “I”. Come on, is this research? Now, the general thesis of this chapter is that the hardships (wife-chopping, abuse, rape, domestication, double-burden, etc) Indian women experienced during indenture are essentially still around in the contemporary period, mainly in Cumberland, Canje. Notwithstanding the sources, of which some are drawn from newspaper clippings, the author’s narrative purported that Indian women in Guyana, not only in Cumberland, are in a state of continuous brutalization from their alcoholic husbands.

The choice of weapon is the cutlass, a sugar-cane knife used during and after indenture on the sugar plantations. No one denies the violence inflicted on women in Guyana but when reading Ms. Bahadur’s chapter on “Surviving Guyana”, the impression is that Cumberland, Canje, is the murder capital of Indian women in the Indian Caribbean Diaspora. Never has it occurred to the author that violence on Indian women has more to do with other contemporary realties of Guyana. Instead of relying on and extending the colonial cutlass mentality coupled with Indian male jealously, Indian women gender disparity and alcoholism to explain violence against Indian women, why not examine the impact PPP communism has had on Indian males that might have caused them to take out their frustrations on their female counterparts. Here again is a missed opportunity. There is evidence, though more research is needed, to justify that the PPP self-styled indoctrination of communism has had an enormous impact on the minds of Indian males, many of them are now in their 60s and 70s living in North America seeking psychiatric and psychological help. Many of these individuals are still in Guyana and do not even know that their minds have been scarred and scared.

Except for Mr. Freddie Kissoon’s short assessment of Bahadur’s book in one of his daily columns, no one has come out and criticized this book. Mr. Kissoon is correct on the quotes.

Where is the Indian Arrival Committee? Where is the Ethnic Relations Commission? One can only imagine what would have been the repercussions if the book was written by a non-Indian using the “C” word. Finally, I truly believe this book is a draft, and if it was re-viewed carefully, it would have made a contribution to the field of Indian indentured servitude.

Currently, the book remains, if at all, in the basement of Indian indentured historiography. How-ever, the author has a unique opportunity to correct her mistakes. Ask the University of Chicago Press to recall the book and engage in substantive revisions. Dismiss the title, delete the first and last chapters, and ensure that the introduction chapter has a sound explanation of your methodology; right now there is none. Lastly, clean up the references and give credit where due rather than bamboozling and hoodwinking the public into believing with presentations after presentations that the book in an attempt to recover and recapture the lost voices of Indian indentured women. The public is much wiser.

Yours faithfully,
Lomarsh Roopnarine

Latest in Letters

default placeholder

The city council needs to install parking meters to raise money

Dear Editor, We continue to be amazed by the many different stories which are being peddled in certain sections of the media and other places about the installation and operation of parking meters in the city.

default placeholder

It is time the Mayor, Town Clerk, Finance Committee Chairman stop the authoritarianism

Dear Editor, The Youth For Local Government (YFLG) is appalled by the actions and statements coming from the Georgetown municipality, mainly the utterances of the Mayor, Councillor Oscar Clarke and the Town Clerk on the parking meter fiasco.

default placeholder

Statistics do not support the view that abolition of the death penalty does not affect the murder rate

Dear Editor, In societies all over the world when the murder rate is deemed uncomfortably high citizens engage in fierce discourse on the merits and demerits of the death penalty; Guyana has been no different.

default placeholder

Jagan was prepared to offer vice-presidencies to Thomas and Tennassee

Dear Editor,   I noticed that there is debate about the offer of a ministerial position to distinguished Professor Dr Clive Thomas by Dr Jagan.

default placeholder

Is the talk of social cohesion just rhetoric?

Dear Editor, I have a serious question for Guyanese, especially the current Government of Guyana (the APNU+AFC). What exactly is social cohesion and what measurable criteria need to be met for this to be achieved?

default placeholder

The EU will not be the same without Britain

Dear Editor, The British people have voted to exit the European Union after 43 years of membership. This is indeed a historic development which can have far reaching consequences not only for the people of Britain, but for the whole of Europe.

default placeholder

APNU+AFC councillors were not invited to Region Five council meeting

Dear Editor,   As I was watching the LRTVS newscast the night before last, I was shocked to see the Regional Chairman and his PPP councillors at a meeting in the RDC boardroom. 

default placeholder

The parking meter contract should be renegotiated or scrapped

Dear Editor, The parking meter controversy raises many troubling questions for democracy, transparency and accountability. As a newly elected Councillor, I understand that there is a need to generate more revenue in order to manage the City of Georgetown effectively and implement much needed projects to upgrade existing facilities and embark on new developmental projects.

Comments

About these comments

The comments section is intended to provide a forum for reasoned and reasonable debate on the newspaper's content and is an extension of the newspaper and what it has become well known for over its history: accuracy, balance and fairness. We reserve the right to edit or delete comments which contain attacks on other users, slander, coarse language and profanity, and gratuitous and incendiary references to race and ethnicity.

Stay updated! Follow Stabroek News on Facebook or Twitter.

Get the day's headlines from SN in your inbox every morning: