Dear Editor,
In an article, ‘Ever so welcome, wait for a call,’ by Mr Arif Bulkan in Stabroek News of December 1, 2008, he stated that “a recent news report revealed contamination in the ground water supply of Barbados, attributing this to the unhygienic habits of squatters in certain districts.” He implied in his article that the squatters were all illegal immigrants from Guyana. The type of contamination of the ground water supply was not stated, but again it entailed that the contamination originated from human faeces and otherwise.
Barbados ground water supply comes from freshwater lenses trapped between layers of salt water below and coral rocks above. The fresh water originates from rainfall percolating through the coral rocks and is trapped as freshwater lenses and in the interstices of the rock whose thickness varies from a few inches to several feet.
Bridgetown, the capital of Barbados has a central sewage system but the other towns and villages use septic tanks and open drains as their major means of liquid human waste disposal. It is therefore inconceivable that squatters were pinpointed as the originators for contaminating the ground water supply when no tracer elements were used to identify the source and elements contaminating the ground water.
Contamination could have originated from several possible sources, such as human waste from faulty septic tanks, chemicals, pesticides and most important, the mixing of the freshwater lens with the heavier salt water due to over pumping.
I believe Barbadians have to be more specific and identify beyond any reasonable doubt the source and type of toxic elements contaminating their underground water supply rather than drumming up flimsy, unfounded, xenophobic hysteria about hard-working Guyanese helping to develop their country in key economic sectors.
Finally, it is worth noting that many of the people in Barbados of East Indian extraction are from Trinidad. Many hotels, condominiums and businesses there are owned and managed by them, but for reasons still undetermined, much of the visceral prejudice is directed towards the Guyanese.
Yours faithfully,
Charles Sohan
The Comments section of this website is intended to provide a forum for reasoned and reasonable debate on the newspaper's content and is an extension of the newspaper and what it has become well known for over its history: accuracy, balance and fairness.
We reserve the right to edit/delete comments which contain attacks on other users, slander, coarse language and profanity, and gratuitous and incendiary references to race and ethnicity.
Curious about the little images next to each commenter's name ? Go here and sign up using the same email address you used to register for Stabroeknews.com then upload your image and confirm it.
The Caribbean sees us through the Guyana prism, and the respective ethnic groups by the action of respective individuals arising from an anthropological dictum have not made things better.
Invariably all Guyanese are viewed under a blanket perception which will always remain difficult to erase.
I therefore posit that Indo-Guyanese should stop kicking the ball down the road, by ending race base voting, likewise afro-Guyanese should end same through blind allegiance to the PNC in preference to the holistic benefit of Guyana.
As one people of a developed nation we would bring much to the table.
Any one leaving Guyana, would not therefore be viewed with such negativity, rather would be seen as contributing a wealth of skills which would have contributed to Guyana development.
The reason for this is plain and simple. The Ruling Cabal has decided to recreate hell on earth and they choose Guyana. In the light of this development everyone is trying to get to heaven via various routes. Barbados is only one of the conduits for this mass escape.
did not like the ” Indian man as they called them ” and nothing seems to have changed now except they are more vocal about that now This present government has not help during there campaign they stirred up strong feelings on this issue’s
That place is called Turks and Caicos Islands, where hundreds of Guyanese reside and that other nationality - Haitians.
In TCI, the Haitians are blamed for every thing that could go wrong in that little group of islands. In most instances they are accused unhygenic conditions in the squatter settlements, the crimes committed, the overcrowding in schools and the burden on the health sector.
Well, would Guyanese in BIM soon be tarnished with the same brush?
From my perspective,it has nothing to do with race,just respect.When you go to someone’s country you should respect their laws & customs.When you don’t do that you can always expect there to be a hostile welcome,especially when certain nationals choose to overstay in Barbados.The former BLP Prime Minister was also notorious for not enforcing Barbados immigration laws even though Bajans were demanding it,instead he chose to flout his stature hence why his party & him lost the election.The current DLP Government is now currently now enforcing the law as it was before the BLP took office & will most likely remain that way.
When I first visited Barbados, in 2001, I certainly detected some “anti-Indian” feeling, but this wasn’t as strong as some of the “anti-African” feeling that I have experienced in both Trinidad and Guyana.
Perhaps this is because both Guyana and Trinidad & Tobago have been governed by parties perceived as “African” - PNC in Guyana and PNM in Trinidad & Tobago - whereas the number of people of East Indian descent in Barbados is negligible and there is no prospect of an “Indian” party coming to power in that island.
I’d be interested to know if the anti-Guyanese sentiments of Afro-Barbadians are shared by Indo-Barbadians (there must be a few), and Indo-Trinidadians resident in Barbados. Is most of the anti-Guyanese feeling in Barbados anti-Guyanese rather than “anti-Indian”, and is it partly as a result of Barbadians’ perceived superiority to other West Indians?
In Jamaica, where East Indians make up about 2% of the population, there is far less “anti-Indian” feeling than in either Guyana or Trinidad. The same is true of countries such as Grenada, St Lucia, St Vincent & the Grenadines and St Kitts & Nevis, all of which have East Indian populations of roughly 2 - 5%. It seems that when “Indians” are a tiny minority, they are not seen as a threat.
When other West Indians refer to Barbados as “little England”, I don’t think that they mean it as a compliment!
It seems that wherever you go, the foreigners at “the bottom of the pile” get the roughest treatment from the indigenous population.
You talk of Jamaican Indians, they have been completely integrated into a jamaican caribbean culture not a hard core hindu ‘no mixing’ culture…that’s the big difference. And mind you, they are two groups of Indians: Indians who recently migrated from India and Indo-Jamaicans. My wife would have been mad to marry out side of her Indian group in Trinidad; her father says that atleast I am half Indian and was doing well financially and that we were both in canada so he didn’t have to put up with the shame in trinidad…..we usually laugh at this when we talk about our progress in life as a family with an Indian son-in-law, a white daughter-in-law and two half black half chinese daughters-in-law.
Its just sad to see that a country with such natural resources has been mismanaged over the years, which has caused undue hardship on the average citizen.
Guyanese in Barbados provide a valuable service especially in the construction industry. With the many projects we have going here, it would be impossible to find the manpower to complete them otherwise. It is true that some may be scrutinized due mostly to illegal entry or crime and this in turn create an atmosphere of mistrust by some Bajans but I would say that these people are in the minority. The untruths about a bench at the airport for guyanese can only filter back making evryone belief that Barbados is a bad place….this is so far from reality. We have law and order here and everyone must comply so if you enter a soverign country illegally you must expect that if caught the laws of the land will be applied. I think what has happen here, is that a few bad apples has created a bad situation for hard working, law abiding Guyanese. I have many Guyanese friends and I’ll go on record saying that we do have some ignorant people in Barbados but they are in the minority but most intelligent Bajans can see the good in our neighbours and friends.
BAJANS-THE YOUNG ONES ESPECIALLY WILL NOT KNOW THAT GUYANA WAS A SANCTUARY FOR THEIR FOREPARENTS IN THE 50s.THE BAJANS ARE INDEED TREATHENED BY FOREIGNERS TAKING AWAY THEIR JOBS AND LIKE MOST ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS THE WORLD OVER WILL WORK FOR LESS THAN THE CITIZENS OF THE COUNTRY-HENCE ONE MUST EXPEXT RESENTMENT–ITS HAPPENING ALL OVER THE WORLD.THE BAJANS I BELIEVE THOUGH ARE TAKING IT TOOO FAR FOR THE LONGEST WHILE TREATING GUYANESE LIKE GARBAGE–.THE BLAME FOR THIS REST SOLELY ON THE FEET OF BOTH GOVERNMENT OF THIS COUNTRY WHO CAUSED AAND IS CAUSING THIS EYEPASS TO HAPPEN.
MY FELLOW GUYANESE-THE BAJANS WILL COME AGAIN-LETS TREAT THEM AS CARICOM BROTHERS WHEN THEY DO COME FOR THATS WHO THEY ARE.
ERIC WILLIAM SAID OIL DONT SPOIL
WE IN GUYANA SAY WE HAVE AN ABUNDANCE OF LAND TO GIVE YOU FOOD AND OUR FOREST IS THE LUNGS FOR THE WORLD.
No one in the govt of Barbados have ever said that guyanese are squatting in zone 1 water areas . I have guyanese friends living in this country , so why do people keep saying that we are xenophobic . There are some guyanese living in Barbados who are increasing our crime rate , recently , a guyanese and a barbadian have been charge for murdering a 16 year old school girl .In addittion , they were also charged for arson . The girl’s boby was found after the fire was extinguished by the Barbados Fire Service ; she was tied up and had bruises to her on her body .A few month ago , a guyanese worker shot a guyanese contractor and after he committed suicide .
Barbados is 166 sq. miles with a population of approximately 279,300 ; about 1,682 people per sq mile .Guyana is 83,000 sq. miles with a population of approximate 765,000 ; about 9 people per sq. mile . Why can’t the govt & people of Guyana develope their country ?
Our social services are under pressure and we are being called xenophobic for removing people from our country all of whom have broken the laws of Barbados .
Recently , the Guyanese authorities held a barbadian for over staying his time in Guyanese , eventhough , he was a regular visitor , a ticket was sent for him o return to Barbados .
I therefore , am in full support of the immigration policy/policies of the govt of Barbados .
Unlike Guyana, Barbados don’t have an abundance of natural resources. Our natural resources are our people and beaches. We depend of tourism to fuel this country that is why we can’t afford to let people ran rampant. We must protect our fragile economy.
What has made Barbados the envy of the Caribbean,is our stable political system. Over the years,we’ve had sound management of this island from both political parties which has lead to enormous foreign investment. This along with our tourism product has driven our economy and development. Under these circumstances, with no natural resources; who can blame us for protecting our values and maintaining law and order.
I picked up some Guyanese friends at the Airport last August who were here for a race meet and their experience was anything but horible as most Guyanese would have you belief. I also witness scores of other Guyanese nationals who came in legitimately without any problems.
The whole relationship for the bjans is hide the people who cant say sir or madame. The english love it there because bajans are obiedient in playing up to centrys of it. I know bajans to be educated people but i am seriously annoyed at the recent and consistent bad mouthing of guyana.
its a thin line between love and hate. So i hope the positive will prevail.
President of the Maldives wants to relocate — his entire country
Sinking island’s nationals seek new home
http://edition.cnn.com/2008/WORLD/asiapcf/11/11/maldives.president/index.html
was flooded with bajans working and living
in the country just like us no problem, but that was
then when Guyana was the bread basket of the Caribbean.
You may recall a song by the Mighty Sparrow
name:- ONE B.G PLANTAIN does full-up de pot.
I have witness Guyanese returning home and given a hard time by your own immigration officers and I, a visitor had no issues clearing. This made me feel sad to see victimization by your own.
From what I’ve seen, I think Guyana need to clean up its own backyard and respect its citizens instead of complaining and finger pointing. Provide safety and security for the average person, attract foreign investment which would create jobs and opportunity for its citizens. With all your natural resources, you can be the power house of the Caribbean. With the right investment, Guyana can produce enough Hydro Electricity to supply most of the its neighbours but no foreign concern will invest if you don’t clean up your image and put in place a government who is willing to manage your country effectively, devoid of corruption and greed.
In summation, respect your own first, adhear to law and order and you will gain the respect of others.