The Primacy of Hope

In years past, hearing outside about my country’s difficulties, I would come home to Guyana with Tradewinds to play music, or just to visit, always concerned that I would find a joyless, dispirited people. Instead, I would find Guyanese, certainly complaining, but also upbeat, showing exuberance, finding things to laugh at.  It would always surprise me. I would be away for a year or so, hear about some other traumas – devaluation; items banned; shortages; etc. – and I would come home thinking, “Okay, this time I will see them down in the dumps”, and again I would be wrong. In all those years, on every trip, I never saw a downtrodden, hopeless people.

In that context, when a letter writer, complaining about our various societal problems, recently made reference to “a paucity of hope” in Guyana, the phrase pulled me up short.  Paucity of hope?  In Guyana?

Although I had never thought about the subject before in those terms, that letter writer’s clear statement made me realise, almost as I read it, that I had the completely opposite view. Guyanese, it seems to me, are redolent with hope. And in case you’re about to say it’s a kind of blindness to reality, I disagree. Our ability to deal with our difficulties is predicated on understanding the realities, but also on having a reservoir of hope; hope that things will change; hope that whatever the present distress may be, it is not permanent (history shows that); hope that whatever bad apples we see generating wrong will not be there forever. Hope is the fuel that keeps the engine going, although obstacles abound.

I can see how someone caught up in a particular vexing scenario might be inclined to see things as “hopeless”, but to interact across the board in this society is to see example after example of people who haven’t given up hope at all.  People like the two policemen who stopped traffic to help an old lady across the street; or the coconut vendor on Irving Street, laughing at two Guyanese arguing, and saying “I ain’t wan’ live nowhere else.”; or the people investing in new infrastructure; or the young couple slaving over a backyard garden to make ends meet – I’ve seen all those things here.

I’m not formally religious, but I regard hope, in effect, as the presence of God in us. It is the abiding knowledge that “better will come”.  It may take time (look how long it took for Papa Doc to be sent packing; look how long before the Berlin Wall fell; look how long it took for a cure for polio) but it will come.  The strength to endure comes from hope. Think of the travail of black people in the United States, with dogs and fire hoses turned against them, powerless; think of Little Rock, in 1957, with 11 young children facing hundreds of rabid rednecks in order to go to school; those black people were fortified by the conviction of hope. The phrase Barack Obama uses is “the audacity of hope”; it is a relentless power. It eventually prevails.

The singular story of  Nelson Mandela, of his lifetime in prison, is known around the world.  How could one keep facing a totalitarian, unrelenting regime, determined to deny you your rights, every day, year round, for 27 years? Talk about hopelessness – that would be it. Mandela says he never gave up hope. It is mankind’s nature to hope. We know from the Bible about faith, hope and charity, and I may get some arguments about this, but I think hope is the most powerful of the three because it is the fuel for the life force that keeps us going when everything is breaking loose around us.  History is replete with examples of it.

Consider the tangled history of Europe with entire nationalities being subjugated, displaced from their homelands, and even in the depths of those horrors, those people kept their vision of nationhood and persevered to see its revival.  Hope never deserted them.

Ironically, even the media voices in Guyana who are constantly regaling us with the litany of things going wrong; it could be argued they constitute an expression of hope. Yes, the constant diet of bad news can be draining, but by their very actions these people, if they are genuine, are operating also on the premise of a hope that change can come, that improvements can take place; that irregularities can be repaired. By the very fact that they are still here – and not in New York, or Toronto, or Trinidad – these people are agitating for change because they believe it can occur.  Freddie and Adam and Fenty, et al, may not be inclined to say so publicly, but I expect if you press them they will tell you that they have not given up hope; on the contrary, it is their fuel.

When I was commissioned to write an emancipation musical by the Guyana Commemoration Commission in 1984, I spent many research hours in the Caribbean Reference Library at UG and I remember, in those hours of reading, how totally surprised I was to learn that the slaves, in the midst of that degrading existence, were somehow able to retain their dignity, their resolve and even their sense of humour.  It had to be hope operating there, not allowing them to fold up like a pack of cards in what appeared to be a dead end situation. In the story of the Haitian earthquake unfolding around us now, we see it again.  In those conditions, appalling beyond belief, people don’t give up hope.  It keeps them going, even to the point of lying trapped in rubble for over a week, simply refusing to let go. The people I referred to earlier – the ones in Guyana I would meet on my trips back here – are evidence of it.  The quotation “hope springs eternal in the human breast” sentence is more than great writing; it is also great truth.

From the Crusades, to slavery, to the Holocaust, to Pol Pot, to pre-Castro Cuba, even in early America itself, mankind, in infinitely worse conditions than Guyana, doesn’t give up hope.  In fact, all the people who choose to stay in this country, or the ones who return, are doing so precisely because they are full of hope for better days; the time line may be uncertain, but the hope is not.   Hope in a person dies only when they’re dead.