US judge orders Marcus Bisram be extradited

Marcus Brian Bisram

US Judge Peggy Kuo has ordered that Guyanese murder accused Marcus Bisram be extradited to Guyana to face the charge here, effectively thwarting his defence team’s bid to stay her hands as they seek to have the murder charge dismissed in the High Court here.

Justice Kuo made the ruling yesterday and committed Bisram to the custody of the United States Marshal pending a further decision on extradition and surrender by the Secretary of State in keeping with US laws.

In the order, seen by this newspaper, the judge said after reviewing the evidence presented in the case, in particular, the certified and authenticated documents submitted by the Government of Guyana, she found that the court had jurisdiction in the case and that the extradition treaty between the US and Guyana (entered into between the United Kingdom and the United States on December 22nd, 1931) was in full force and effect.

She found that the individual before her is the same individual charged with murder in Guyana and that the Government of Guyana submitted documents that were properly authenticated and certified.

“The evidence before this Court is sufficient to justify the Fugitive’s committal for trial, on felony charges, had the offence which he is accused of having committed occurred in the United States…” the Judge said in the order, which was proposed by the prosecution last week.

On Tuesday, Bisram’s New York lawyer Mario F. Gallucci had sought to stall the ruling on his extradition proceedings on the basis of his challenge in the Guyana High Court against the charge.

The move was immediately opposed by the US Government.

In a letter to Justice Kuo, Gallucci had said his client’s Guyanese lawyer, Sanjeev Datadin had informed that a ruling on the dismissal of the murder charge has been reserved until October 30th.

“I still believe that this ruling is substantially critical and essential to the probable cause element of extradition. I am asking Your Honour to refrain from issuing an opinion until such time as the Guyanese court makes a final decision,” the lawyer stated in the letter, seen by this newspaper.

Datadin approached the High Court here to have the murder charge against Bisram quashed. He argued before Justice Gino Persaud that the charge is “without legal foundation, null, void, unreasonable and unfair.”

He had also submitted that the only evidence which the state purports to have against his client is a statement of its key witness, Chaman Chunilall, alleging to have heard Bisram saying words to the effect “kill him.”

During the preliminary inquiry (PI) into the charge against Bisram’s five co-accused, before Magistrate Charlyn Artiga at the Springlands Magistrate’s Court, however, Chunilall, under cross-examination, purportedly recanted his story by saying that he knows nothing about the incident. As a result, Datadin argued that the recantation is sufficient to warrant the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) withdrawing the charge levelled against Bisram.

Bisram and five others have been charged with the killing of Number 70 Village carpenter Faiyaz Narinedatt. Bisram was nabbed in the US on July 16th. Bisram, local police have alleged, procured and commanded Orlando Dickie, Radesh Motie, Diodath Datt, Harri Paul Parsram, and Niran Yacoob to murder Narinedatt between October 31 and November 1, 2016, at Number 70 Village, Berbice.

Comments  

PNC Georgetown District calls on Public Security Ministry, Judiciary for tougher action on crime

The Georgetown District of the People’s National Congress Reform (PNCR) today called for tougher action by the Ministry of Public Security and the Judiciary against crime in the wake of the murder of two elderly women.

Rain hits Divali celebrations in T&T

Moruga/Tableland MP Dr Lovell Francis chats with two of his constituents whose yard was flooded following heavy overnight rains into yesterday.

FBI opens investigation into South Africa’s Guptas – FT

India-born South African businessmen brothers, Atul, Rajesh and Ajay Rajesh Gupta. The Gupta family, one of South Africa’s wealthiest, has been accused of wielding undue influence behind the scenes.

Long term interests should guide award of oil exploration leases -Greenidge

Although government’s advisor on oil and gas, Jan Mangal, has argued that competitive bidding should be employed in the award of future oil exploration leases, Minister of Foreign Affairs Carl Greenidge says such an approach may not benefit Guyana’s interests in the long term.

Cops not focusing on M&CC officials’ failure to report sexual abuse of boy

Police investigators will be focusing on the alleged sexual abuse of a 15-year-old boy committed by a city constabulary officer two months ago and not on the failure of the Mayor of City Council (M&CC) of Georgetown to report the case in a timely manner, ‘A’ Division Commander Marlon Chapman said yesterday.

Your browser is out-of-date!

Update your browser to view this website correctly.

We built stabroeknews.com using new technology. This makes our website faster, more feature rich and easier to use for 95% of our readers.
Unfortunately, your browser does not support some of these technologies. Click the button below and choose a modern browser to receive our intended user experience.

Update my browser now

×