Hanging is an act of revenge not a deterrent to murder

Dear Editor,

Today (10th October), the Justice Institute Guyana joins with billions in celebrating the World Day Against the Death Penalty and condemns without reservation the use of the death penalty.

This is perhaps the worst possible time to make such a statement. We read repeatedly of atrocities perpetrated against vulnerable and innocent people in Guyana. As fellow human beings we grieve for their families. We feel enraged and helpless in the face of their suffering. And yet this nation will not do what it takes to stop this happening again and again.

The single most effective way to stop murder is to catch, convict and punish the murderer. Knowing that you will be caught is the biggest deterrent. Hanging might be a satisfactory act of revenge but we should not pretend that it has a greater deterrent effect than life imprisonment.

Successive governments have shown that they cannot keep the ordinary citizen safe.  Whenever there is a heinous crime the death penalty rears its ugly head like a jumbie to frighten children. But we are only fooling ourselves if we think that hanging people is going to make this society safer.

No, we need to call this government to account. We need to demand a better police force and a better court system. We need to see the conviction rates for murder going up. We need to see trials that are fair because we all know that if you are poor, you don’t have the same access to justice as the rich and the well-connected. And we need to take care of the victims’ families. Time and again they are forgotten as the media move on to the next sensation.

In 2013 Guyana’s homicide rate was around 20 murders for every 100,000 citizens. That put us in the top twenty of the most homicidal countries on the planet. The most violent societies are those with drugs, guns, oil and a big gap between rich and poor. Which way are we heading?

No state should execute its citizens. Killing another human being is barbaric whether the killing is done by a psychopath or by the state.  Of the 111 countries that have abolished the death penalty in law, not a single one has brought it back.

Our taxes keep the government safe. What are they going to do to keep us safe?


Yours faithfully,

Melinda Janki


Justice Institute Guyana



Judge Shahabuddeen was a jurist of whom the entire Caribbean can be proud

Dear Editor, Judge Mohamed Shahabuddeen, who passed away on 17th February, 2018, was an illustrious son of the Caribbean.

Rupununi students who participated in children’s Mashramani were poorly treated

Dear Editor, I have two sisters who were part of an entourage of eighty-seven students who travelled from the Rupununi to participate in the children’s Mashramani programme in Georgetown.

Do pensioners have an entitlement or does the GRA have discretion?

Dear Editor, From my understanding of a press statement made by the Minister of Finance which was seen by me for the first time in 2017, old age pensioners countrywide were to benefit from a tax exemption on their savings accounts.

Dr Shahabuddeen was responsible for the 1980 Constitution

Dear Editor, Much tribute has been paid to Dr Mohammed Shahabuddeen upon his passing in your media.

Is there a sudden spike in the level of iron in the water?

Dear Editor, Pray, tell what GWI has done to the water. The water is dehydrating the tips of the ‘stand-up’ heliconias, and reducing the shelf-life of these particular cut flowers.

Your browser is out-of-date!

Update your browser to view this website correctly.

We built stabroeknews.com using new technology. This makes our website faster, more feature rich and easier to use for 95% of our readers.
Unfortunately, your browser does not support some of these technologies. Click the button below and choose a modern browser to receive our intended user experience.

Update my browser now