T&T CJ sues to block Law Association probe

Chief Justice Ivor Archie

(Trinidad Guardian) In an historic move, Chief Justice Ivor Archie has initiated legal action against the Law Association, saying it has no authority to investigate him, and has sought to block any further action by the association pending the outcome of High Court action.

But the association says the letter will not stop them from moving ahead and seeking advice on whether the allegations made against the CJ are enough to warrant the start of impeachment proceedings.

Attorneys for Archie sent a pre-action protocol letter to association president Douglas Mendes on Wednesday. The letter told of the CJ’s intention to begin High Court proceedings to challenge the association’s investigation into his alleged conduct and to seek advice of two queen’s counsel to determine whether the allegations warranted the Prime Minister invoking section 137 of the Constitution to begin impeachment proceedings.

The letter came one day after the association sent an email to the CJ’s attorneys indicating they intended to brief Queen’s Counsel Dr. Francis Alexis and Eamon Courtenay and move ahead with set up a tribunal to investigate the CJ.

Chief Justice Ivor Archie

Those allegations include that the CJ used his office to request Housing Development Corporation housing for persons whom he knew and that he discussed the issue of security for judges with someone who was not a judge.

On Tuesday, the committee, headed by Mendes, which investigated the allegations against the CJ, reported to the council that they had made every effort to get the CJ to respond to the allegations. According to a letter sent to members by Secretary Elena Araujo, on January 20 a letter was sent to the CJ inviting him to respond to the list of allegations which in the committee’s view were sufficiently substantiated to justify requesting a response.

She said attorneys for the CJ first took the position the Law Association had no power to conduct the enquiry and then asked to be provided with relevant documents, photographs and Whatsapp messages in the committee’s possession. The information was provided on February 6. However, she said attorneys for the CJ subsequently failed to respond to the allegations.

The council took a decision to submit the committee report to the QCs on February 23 for their advice and the CJ’s attorneys were informed of this by email dated February 20 and invited to submit the CJ’s response if they wished the counsel to consider it.

The association’s council approved the course of action and there was agreement for a Special General Meeting on March 16 to consider the committee’s report and any advice received from counsel.

But the CJ’s attorneys have since sought to stop the action, indicating the Law Association is not empowered under the legal profession act to conduct, ascertain or establish the basis of allegations made against the Chief Justice.

In the pre-action protocol letter, the CJ’s lawyers have asked that no further steps be taken until the High Court has pronounced on the legal and constitutional propriety of the association’s proposed action.

According to the CJ’s attorneys, the Constitution provides the exclusive avenue for such an enquiry under section 137 of the Constitution. The pre-action protocol letter further alleged the enquiry was tainted by apparent bias, because of the motion of no confidence motion which was moved against the CJ last year in the midst of allegations against him after the Marcia Ayres-Caesar fiasco. According to the argument, there was “a real possibility” the association’s insistence on conducting an investigation is “motivated by the Law Association’s pre-conceived disposition against” the CJ. The CJ’s attorneys claimed it is “accordingly unconstitutional and unfair” for the association to conduct the investigation.

However, Araujo said the committee intends to proceed with the course of action agreed upon by the council and will submit its brief to the external advisors as planned.

Senior attorneys on Thursday told the T&T Guardian the association tip-toed around the matter and gave the CJ a way out on his terms. They said there was no need for the association to set up its own investigation, but rather should have joined public calls for the CJ to answer publicly to the allegations against him. With the matter now tied up in court, the Prime Minister cannot act on the matter.


Battered with brick: Mayaro mom was 8-months pregnant

(Trinidad Express) The woman beaten to death with a brick in Mayaro on Monday night was eight months pregnant.

Maduro challenger promises U.S. dollar giveaway for Venezuelans

CARACAS, (Reuters) – Opposition presidential candidate Henri Falcon’s campaign vowed yesterday to implement a $25 monthly giveaway to Venezuelans, as part of plans to dollarize the crisis-hit economy and alleviate suffering should he win the May 20 vote.

U.S. gives $2.5 mln emergency aid for Venezuelans fleeing to Colombia

WASHINGTON, (Reuters) – The United States will provide $2.5 million in food and medical aid to Venezuelans fleeing their economically-crippled country to neighboring Colombia and is poised to help other countries if the situation worsens, U.S.

T&T swears in sixth President

Trinidad’s sixth President Paula-Mae Weekes was inaugurated yesterday at a ceremony at the Queens Park Savannah, Port of Spain.

U.S. Treasury places four Venezuelans on U.S. sanctions list

BUENOS AIRES,  (Reuters) – Colombia proposed yetserday that the International Monetary Fund provide assistance to help several hundred thousand Venezuelan refugees who have fled an economic and political crisis to neighboring countries, officials at the G20 summit said.


Not Ready to Subscribe ?

You can still join over other 15,000 subscribers and receive FREE breaking news alerts as they happen and the morning brief featuring top stories of the day. 

Your browser is out-of-date!

Update your browser to view this website correctly.

We built stabroeknews.com using new technology. This makes our website faster, more feature rich and easier to use for 95% of our readers.
Unfortunately, your browser does not support some of these technologies. Click the button below and choose a modern browser to receive our intended user experience.

Update my browser now