This week, on the ground in Guyana, I ended up in an online conversation with my friend George Jardim (East Coast businessman and erstwhile musician) that involved our various dialect pronunciations or creations across the Caribbean. As someone like George, who grew up familiar with that form in Guyana, I had, from those early years, an irritation with the people who would often correct me to say “you’re using bad English,” or “that’s not proper English” and here we are in 2018 and that attitude is still around.
Beyond that, as someone involved with the deliberate creation of Caribbean music going back now some 60 years, it is interesting that while the dialect is there in my songs, it comes largely as interjection or emphasis. Indeed, aside from Jamaica, dialect in Caribbean music generally is mostly in the form of folk music – Shetira Gal and Itanami, in Guyana – and not as a rule in the popular music of the day. My minimal use of a specific dialect owes to my decision to write pan-Caribbean music, hence the name Tradewinds, so that using all the various dialects would have been okay for some but confusing for others. The one exception is when I wrote two songs using French patois words (somewhat clumsily, as I don’t speak patois) but those songs were released only for the St. Lucia/Dominica market; they would be unintelligible elsewhere.
For me, however, in performance, my own dialect is largely in play in my exchanges with the audience and their reaction frequently demonstrates the value of that tool to making a point effectively. Overall, my contention is that while persons who denigrate the dialect make the case it is evidence of our “ignorance,” it is actually evidence of information seriously lacking in those making such charges. I remember vividly being in a linguistics class in Ryerson University, in Toronto, where the Professor dealt with the subject of Old English and he referred to the various constructions closing off with a lexicon of words commonly used in that form. Going through the list, there was the word “hoist” and I was stunned to see that in Old English it was pronounced “hise.” I immediately recognised that was the pronunciation in Guyana, something we had obviously picked up from the early colonial masters. The examples are rife. In Jamaica, the dropping of the “h” at the front of a word resulting in “-ouse” and “-im,” for example, is a copying of the Cockney pronunciation of the colonial rulers. In other words, it’s a Jamaican copycat, not a creator. Similarly, in Barbados, the dropping of the “t” at the end of a word, so familiar in the speech of Bajans, particularly in the countryside, is straight out of Glasgow. I didn’t make the connection originally, but living in Toronto and married to my first wife, Dorothy, born in Scotland but raised in Canada, I heard that dropping of the final “t” in the conversations of various Scots living there. It hit me like a shot, how that similar practice had been picked up by the Bajans, not from stupidity, as some would say, but simply from copying the early Scottish settlers in their island…..