There is something wrong if the government and the sculptor alone select the site for the 1823 Monument

Dear Editor,

There is an old saying that where ignorance is bliss, it is folly to be wise. This was the  first thought  that rushed through my mind after reading a Demerara Waves’ news release titled; ‘Kitty Seawall road best site for 1823 slave rebellion monument –sculptor’ (January 3). My second thought was more emotional and thus unprintable. In the release, Mr Ivor Thom, the sculptor, pontificates at a news conference that, “the land space was there (speaking about the seawall site), place for parking and everything was there, and more than anything else, the viewing was good…” The good gentleman went on: “We thought  that that would have been the best place to put it, because it could be easily seen by persons traversing to and from East Coast Demerara from different directions.” Thom further went on to say that it was his opinion that the seawall site was the best of all the locations that were suggested.

Editor, something must be fundamentally wrong if we as a people and our government entrust the selection of the site of a monument of such great national significance to a sculptor. Ivor Thom may be a good sculptor, but Mr Thom does not speak for the African collective in this country. It is clear from his remarks that his focus was more in keeping with the visibility of his work, rather than the emotional and physical connection of the rebellion and its connection to the African people. Like Thom I too have an opinion, and I feel that the site of the 1823 monument must by necessity be at a location chosen by the descendants of that struggle. The area known as the Promenade Gardens and the Parade Ground was where the brutality and sadistic mentality of the colonial government was put on full display after the rebellion was put down. This is where a number of our African freedom fighters were hanged, ten of whom were later decapitated. This is where in African tradition and lore the spirits of our courageous ancestors still roam. What Mr Thom and Dr Anthony are about to do is not only unprecedented, but an affront to, and direct attack on, the historical accuracy of the African struggle for freedom in Guyana.

I am personally disappointed in the remarks made by Ivor Thom, remarks which clearly show that he is more interested in his design and showing it off, rather than with integrity and historical accuracy. We have several monuments in this and other countries that are not located on public thoroughfares; many lack adequate parking. Mr Thom once lived in Atlanta, Georgia and he knows that the Martin Luther King historical site is located on Auburn Avenue, a depressed section of the city with poor parking and limited land space, but the historical accuracy was maintained, because Dr King was born and lived on that street. The Babu John monument to President Cheddi Jagan was not built on the shoulder of the Corentyne Highway or the Georgetown Seawall; both sites would have given it more visibility. The Place of Heroes is in the Botanical Gardens at the area of the Seven Ponds, and the Monument to the Enmore martyrs is at Enmore. These sites were selected because of historical and emotional considerations, not commercial or popular appeal. Mr Thom and Dr Anthony must know that we distort our history when we make arbitrary decisions on important matters, without consulting the stakeholder, the direct descendants of the murdered slaves, and the historians.

It is clear once again that the Ramotar-led PPP/C government is a dictatorship, that sees consultation and negotiations with the people and their representatives as unnecessary. Why would the Government of Guyana build a monument to celebrate and remember the struggle of Africans at a place where the Africans have said they don’t want it? Why would a government administration (in a plural society) that garners its support primarily from Indians, feel it is has the right to decide where to put a monument to an African slave rebellion without consulting with the African people and their organizations and their leaders. Why would the PPP government proceed to build the 1823 monument at the seawall site, knowing full well that it will cause controversy and become another symbol of racial disunity?

Editor there is talk that the African organizations will build a monument to the 1823 Rebellion at the Parade Ground site. For it was at the Parade Ground that many brave slaves were executed for fighting for their freedom from the inhumane and unjust system of slavery. It is also clear that the PPP regime with Mr Thom’s blessing will go ahead with the building of this divisive monument. It is a pity that Thom, whom I know personally, and who does not live in Guyana allowed himself to be used by the PPP.

Yours faithfully,
Mark Archer

Latest in Letters

default placeholder

What is the Education Service coming to?

Dear Editor,   In SN of June 22 and KN of June 24, I note two versions of a letter by Mr Leon Suseran, “Graduate Senior Assistant Master, Vrymans Erven High School”. 

default placeholder

There should be a fund for the family in the tree accident

Dear Editor, The heart-wrenching story of the horrible tree-felling accident, where the little dying child calls for “Mama” must have stirred others in some way.

default placeholder

The city council needs to install parking meters to raise money

Dear Editor, We continue to be amazed by the many different stories which are being peddled in certain sections of the media and other places about the installation and operation of parking meters in the city.

default placeholder

It is time the Mayor, Town Clerk, Finance Committee Chairman stop the authoritarianism

Dear Editor, The Youth For Local Government (YFLG) is appalled by the actions and statements coming from the Georgetown municipality, mainly the utterances of the Mayor, Councillor Oscar Clarke and the Town Clerk on the parking meter fiasco.

default placeholder

Statistics do not support the view that abolition of the death penalty does not affect the murder rate

Dear Editor, In societies all over the world when the murder rate is deemed uncomfortably high citizens engage in fierce discourse on the merits and demerits of the death penalty; Guyana has been no different.

default placeholder

Jagan was prepared to offer vice-presidencies to Thomas and Tennassee

Dear Editor,   I noticed that there is debate about the offer of a ministerial position to distinguished Professor Dr Clive Thomas by Dr Jagan.

default placeholder

Is the talk of social cohesion just rhetoric?

Dear Editor, I have a serious question for Guyanese, especially the current Government of Guyana (the APNU+AFC). What exactly is social cohesion and what measurable criteria need to be met for this to be achieved?

default placeholder

The EU will not be the same without Britain

Dear Editor, The British people have voted to exit the European Union after 43 years of membership. This is indeed a historic development which can have far reaching consequences not only for the people of Britain, but for the whole of Europe.


About these comments

The comments section is intended to provide a forum for reasoned and reasonable debate on the newspaper's content and is an extension of the newspaper and what it has become well known for over its history: accuracy, balance and fairness. We reserve the right to edit or delete comments which contain attacks on other users, slander, coarse language and profanity, and gratuitous and incendiary references to race and ethnicity.

Stay updated! Follow Stabroek News on Facebook or Twitter.

Get the day's headlines from SN in your inbox every morning: