Benefits of garbage transfer station unlikely to justify cost

Dear Editor,

In a Kaieteur News letter of Jan 14, the Mayor and City Council (M&CC) through its Public Relations Officer (PRO) continues to expound the case for a garbage transfer/sorting/recycling station to better manage, as claimed, the City’s solid waste before it is sent to a landfill facility.

However, although the M&CC was convinced of the advantages of such a facility it recognised that the cost to build and operate it was not within its financial and management capabilities and so in its wisdom it will allow others to do the heavy lifting. Accordingly, Cevons Waste Management Company (CWMC) was selected to set up such a facility and land and other incentives such as permission to tap a nearby old landfill to capture escaping methane gas for commercial use were provided. No information was given on the terms and conditions of the M&CC proposed lease/sale nor the costs to the citizenry if any for drop-offs of garbage to the transfer centre, matters which should become available transparently before any contract is entered into.

The benefits being propounded for a garbage transfer/sorting/recycling station are unlikely to justify its cost as the design and construction of such a station complying with generally accepted standards and facilities such as sealed indoor compartmentalized areas with air vents, FE loaders, specially fabricated compactors, scrubbers to get rid of harmful gases, particulates and odour from rotting material in a hot, humid environment would be a costly undertaking and M&CC must be satisfied that CWMC has the financial resources and technical capability to undertake and manage such a venture.

An environmental impact assessment will also be required to ensure that the project does not impact adversely on the health and welfare of people living in the area.

Politics aside, the M&CC should at its next statutory meeting ban the use of horse/donkey drawn carts in the City as they have outlived their usefulness to haul garbage and sundry in a modern metropolis whose streets are already crowded with motorized vehicles and wandering pedestrians. The PRO claimed that garbage trucks spend an average of 90 mins to travel from the City to the landfill at Eccles.

I travel this route regularly and in the worst of times it takes me no more than 40 mins. So a transfer station will not be that much of a time saver to get the garbage to Haags Bosch.

Finally, hauling the City’s garbage to the landfill in a timely manner is not the problem as with an efficiently managed outsourced system this could be achieved without much ado. The Haags Bosch Landfill is a State entity and I am confident that the City without Hammie at the negotiating table could make a case and work out with the Minister of Local Government the need for flexible dumping hours for its garbage without extra costs.  The M&CC should be aware however, that its solid waste disposal problem is not haulage but one of proper collection/sorting, bagging and adequate storage before haulage.

The City’s Bye-Laws should be enforced with stiff penalties to achieve these objectives if any progress is to be made with this longstanding problem which continues to fester in the community.

Yours faithfully,  
Charles Sohan   

More in Letters

default placeholder

The Venezuelans who appeared in court were economic refugees

Dear Editor, I refer to a report in yesterday’s SN. You reported that 14 Venezuelans appeared before Magistrate Ann McLennan who ruled that they would be fined $10,000 and then deported.

default placeholder

Leaning GTT sign has been removed

Dear Editor, We acknowledge a letter, as published in your paper, on behalf of Digital Technology, which called on us to remove “a GTT sign”, at their Diamond location (‘After two months GTT has not fixed dangerously leaning sign’ SN, July 22).

default placeholder

Our political leaders by example should show us how to achieve social cohesion

Dear Editor, I read a recent article by Samuel Goolsarran in Stabroek News titled ‘The social partnership option for national development-Guyana’.

default placeholder

Stopping the clock on an issue that isn’t quite an issue

Dear Editor, I leap in full-blooded support of Mr Lincoln Lewis’s missive ‘The Region Five Chairman has committed no infraction in relation to his official duties’ (SN, July 24) which addresses the present face-off between the Region 5 Chairman and his councillors – “a matter that has no place in the formal business of the council.” Are we really on the path of harmonizing our people after all the talk, big fuss and gala displayed for our 50th independence jubilee?

default placeholder

Flooding in Nigg and Belvedere South was a consequence of the Region’s inadequacy not the NDC’s failure to be proactive

Dear Editor, In an interview with LRTVS Channel 10 in Berbice, the Regional Vice-Chairman of Region Six, Mr Dennis De Roop accused the Kilcoy/Hampshire Neighbourhood Democratic Council (NDC) of not being ‘proactive’.

default placeholder

Poor drainage in Belladrum, Region Five

Dear Editor, I bring to the general public’s notice the bad drainage system in the residential areas of Belladrum, Region Five.


About these comments

The comments section is intended to provide a forum for reasoned and reasonable debate on the newspaper's content and is an extension of the newspaper and what it has become well known for over its history: accuracy, balance and fairness. We reserve the right to edit or delete comments which contain attacks on other users, slander, coarse language and profanity, and gratuitous and incendiary references to race and ethnicity.

Stay updated! Follow Stabroek News on Facebook or Twitter.

Get the day's headlines from SN in your inbox every morning: