How did the Chinese come up with a credit of US$14M for building the Marriott Hotel?

Dear Editor,

No one knows for sure the true cost of this Marriott Hotel. Initially it was reported to cost US$64M with 160 rooms.

When questioned recently Mr Brassington of Nicil stated the cost to construct the hotel was US$65M with 197 rooms and was based on using Guyanese workers. However, a credit of US$14 M was offered by the Chinese construction company to use Chinese workers because they will more control them. I have done all sorts of mathematical computations and cannot come up with how the Chinese arrived at this credit of US$14M. According to Mr Brassington the Chinese contractor was the lowest of the bidders. There is no information on who prepared the documents for bidders to tender on and who the rest of the bidders are, and therefore it leaves room for allegations that there appears to be some hanky panky in this whole process.

The Marriott is no top-of-the-line hotel and could easily be constructed by Guyanese workers. Mr Brassington’s claim that Guyanese do not have the expertise to build the hotel is simply ridiculous. I feel the government should not be in the hotel business and should leave same to the private sector. The occupancy rate of hotels in Guyana is in the 20% range, and it will take years for the government to re-coup the cost for this hotel. Even at US$51M the cost of constructing the hotel is high.

Similarly, the new US$130M to US$150M airport will also be built exclusively by Chinese workers. Some time ago, when this airport was awarded to the Chinese contractor I wrote a letter stating that the Chinese would only use their own forces to construct it, but no one responded. I worked in Hong Kong as an engineer for a number of years and am familiar with their work ethics. Building a 7-gate airport when only 2 gates would be in use at any one time is simply a waste of money. Guyana is a third world country and upgrading the runway and modifications to the existing building are all that is necessary. Trinidad’s new airport has 8 gates and only about 2 are used at any one time.

I feel the money spent could be used in fixing the coastal infrastructure, which is in a disastrous state and has not been maintained for several years. It was recently reported that the Torani Canal is a poor state, the banks are slipping and the canal is silted up. Water from this canal is discharged into the Canje Creek for use by the sugar estates and by various D&I schemes including the cattle pasture, 52-74 areas, etc. I do not agree with Mr Bhim who recently stated in the press that the silted Torani is not a problem. The Torani Canal needs to be widened and the depth increased. Water from the Torani into the Canje keeps salt water from intruding up the Canje Creek. Similar problems also exist with the MMA Scheme where poor maintenance over the years has led to severe flooding along the main façade. The sea defences are also in very poor shape. The recent severe overtopping in the Georgetown and Kitty areas indicated the foreshore has eroded. The government is no longer monitoring the foreshore levels and no one knows what is going on.

In a few years the government could be faced with the dreaded R word − Re-alignment of the sea defences or abandonment of the area.

Yours faithfully,
M Alli

More in Letters

default placeholder

The Region Five Chairman has committed no infraction in relation to his official duties

Dear Editor, Last Thursday, July 21, the Region Five Regional Democratic Council (RDC) was once again prevented from conducting its statutory meeting.

default placeholder

Is the leader of the GPSU an employer because he sits on the Public Service Commission?

Dear Editor, I note the letter from Mr EB John – ‘GRA employees are not public servants’ – in SN of Saturday, July 23.

default placeholder

GRA employees are not public servants

Dear Editor, According to the media there appears to be a misconstruction of roles, respectively of the Chairman and Board of the Guyana Revenue Authority, and that of the President, GPSU; probably because in one instance the authors are uninformed of the Revenue Authority Act 13 of 1996, amended by 16 of 2003, Clause 2 (1) which reads as follows: “Functions of Governing Board (16 of 2003) “(1) The Governing Board shall be responsible for – “a)   subject to subsection (2) the approval and review of the policy of the Authority; “b)   the monitoring of the performance of the Authority in carrying out functions; and “(c)  the discipline and control of all members of staff of the Authority appointed under this Act.” In an apparent rush to personalise a difference of positions between the two parties much ado has been made of the quoted expressions of the Chairman, as distinct from the statutory authority of that office and the Board.

default placeholder

Fishermen from Guyana and Suriname are the ones most affected by piracy

Dear Editor, I write on behalf of the Caribbean Network of Fisherfolk Organisation, the Guyana National Fisherfolk Organisation and the Suriname Fisherfolk Organisation ‒ Visserscollectief.

default placeholder

SOCU and SARU wield a political hatchet but masquerade as law enforcement agencies

Dear Editor, Just last week, I examined the causal connection between taxation and fear and economic decline in the context of the Guyanese economy.

default placeholder

To hang or not to hang

Dear Editor, To hang or not to hang has been a topic in Guyana, the Caribbean and much of the free world for several decades.


About these comments

The comments section is intended to provide a forum for reasoned and reasonable debate on the newspaper's content and is an extension of the newspaper and what it has become well known for over its history: accuracy, balance and fairness. We reserve the right to edit or delete comments which contain attacks on other users, slander, coarse language and profanity, and gratuitous and incendiary references to race and ethnicity.

Stay updated! Follow Stabroek News on Facebook or Twitter.

Get the day's headlines from SN in your inbox every morning: