King challenges Sooba continuing as Town Clerk

-in appeal of Chief Justice’s ruling

Attorneys for City Hall Public Relations Officer Royston King have appealed parts of the Acting Chief Justice Ian Chang’s recent ruling which said, among other things, that Carol Sooba can continue performing the functions of Town Clerk as the de facto Town Clerk.

On April 10th, Justice Chang ruled that former Local Government Minister Ganga Persaud did not have the lawful authority to appoint anyone and that his decision to appoint Sooba as the Town Clerk was “ultra vires” since that responsibility was vested in the Local Government Commission, although it has never been set up.

“…It is the finding of the court that the Minister acted ultra vires the provisions of the Municipal and District Councils Act, Chapter 28:01, and his decision to appoint Carol Sooba as Town Clerk must be quashed,” Justice Chang said.

Royston King
Royston King

However, Justice Chang said that his decision did not prevent Sooba from continuing to perform the functions of Town Clerk as the “de facto” Town Clerk since a direct challenge was needed to bring her de facto tenure to an end.

In listing the grounds of appeal, Hughes argued that Justice Chang had erred in law when he found that the Town Clerk could perform and or continue to perform her functions as Town Clerk as the de facto Town Clerk.

He stated that Justice Chang also erred when he found that the court was being asked to “substitute its decision for that of the Minister.”

Further, Hughes said that “the learned trial judge misdirected himself when he found that the Minister could take into consideration criteria other than that which was made known to the applicants as the relevant criteria.”

As part of the relief sought, Hughes said that the decision should be varied and or amended to direct that Sooba could not perform the functions of Town Clerk de facto or in any other capacity and that it be varied and or amended to grant an order absolute on the ground that the applicant had a legitimate expectation that the candidate for Town Clerk would be considered on the basis of the criteria established by the Minister.

 Carol Sooba
Carol Sooba

On April 17, Attorney General Anil Nandlall on behalf of Local Government Minister Norman Whittaker filed an appeal against Justice Chang’s ruling that Sooba’s appointment was legally defective.

Last December, King filed a suit asking that the then minister, Persaud, show cause why his decision to appoint Sooba as Town Clerk should not be reversed.

King’s move came after Sooba was appointed despite widespread disapproval and also because an interview panel had voted her as the least qualified person for the job. King had charged that the decision was an abuse of power because Persaud had failed to apply the conditions he had originally requested when advertising for a Town Clerk.

King, Paul Clarke and Darren Khan were the other applicants who had applied for the position.

More in Local News

Logs placed across the road at Moblissa to prevent vehicles from accessing the Baishanlin site.

Baishanlin operations at standstill

Officials from Long Jiang Forest Industries Group are expected in Guyana next month for a ‘fact-finding mission’ as it seeks to fully take over the operations of logging firm Baishanlin whose operations have ground to a halt.

The windmill that once provided all of Huis T' Dieren with water is still standing tall.

Huis T’ Dieren

Photos by Joanna Khan   Just about 500 people live in Huis T’ Dieren, a bright and beautiful little village on the Esse-quibo Coast.

default placeholder

Economy was sluggish through first half of year

The economy was sluggish throughout the first of the year, according to Chairman of the Guyana Bank for Trade and Industry (GBTI) Robin Stoby.

The window the perpetrators broke to enter Doorasammy’s home

Bandits threaten to take off with toddler during robbery

A young couple who recently moved into their home at Lot 139 Gangaram Village, East Canje and took over a grocery shop, is now fearful after bandits early yesterday morning held a gun to their four-year-old daughter and threatened abduction, while robbing them.

default placeholder

Foreign mission heads to be changed every three years

No Guyanese envoy will remain head of the same mission for more than three years, according to President David Granger. “Rotation of diplomats is of paramount importance [since] if a diplomat is kept in his or her position for too long they lose their effectiveness,” Granger said, when asked during the recording of last week’s edition of The Public Interest interview programme whether his government will be rotating heads of missions, in light of criticism that they remained for the most part static under the previous administration.

default placeholder

GGMC not doing enough to monitor removal of sand, loam at Linden – Trotman

Following complaints by the residents of Linden that sand and loam were being removed illegally from the region, Minister of Natural Resources Raphael Trotman on Wednesday stated that the Guyana Geology and Mines Com-mission (GGMC) was not doing enough to monitor movement of the two materials as “people are literally trucking them away.” PPP/C Member of the Parliamentary Sectoral Committee on Natural Resources Pauline Sukhai raised the issue during a committee hearing on Wednesday, while stating that the concerns were raised during the committee’s recent outreach to the community.

Comments

About these comments

The comments section is intended to provide a forum for reasoned and reasonable debate on the newspaper's content and is an extension of the newspaper and what it has become well known for over its history: accuracy, balance and fairness. We reserve the right to edit or delete comments which contain attacks on other users, slander, coarse language and profanity, and gratuitous and incendiary references to race and ethnicity.

Stay updated! Follow Stabroek News on Facebook or Twitter.

Get the day's headlines from SN in your inbox every morning: