Under fire!

-Touring Windies criticized by English media

LONDON, England, CMC – West Indies touched down here yesterday for their three-Test tour against the World’s number one side, with English newspapers already launching their usual assault on the tourists.

The inexperienced 15-man squad, led by captain Darren Sammy, has come under fire in recent days with the Daily Telegraph and the Daily Mail critical of the team composition and its chances in what will be testing weather conditions.

Writing in the Telegraph, noted cricket correspondent Scyld Berry said he expected precious little of the team especially with talismanic opener Chris Gayle missing, and described the young Windies players in the side as “waifs and strays.”

Kemar Roach
Adrian Barath

“Gayle has not represented West Indies for more than a year because of the most ludicrous spat over a public utterance,” Berry wrote.

“In Gayle’s absence, waifs and strays have been thrown in the deep end and, without anyone to learn from, drowned. A youngster plays a few decent shots in a first-class game: right, he is opening the Test batting.

“The senior member of West Indies’ top three against Australia, Adrian Barath, averages 23 in Tests; of the other two, one has scored one first-class century and the other two.”

He continued: “Starting off on the wrong foot, West Indies are fated to remain there in England. Top-order batsmen who do not know how to build an innings, which ball to leave and which to play, will be pitted against James Anderson and Stuart Broad in May. Put it this way: Shivnarine Chanderpaul should have plenty to salvage.”

Berry also ripped into Sammy, contending the all-rounder did not merit a place in the side and was therefore creating an imbalance in the bowling attack.

Ramnaresh Sarwan
Andre Russell

“[Sammy] is a fine man and brilliant fielder, always cheerful, even in defeat, and a useful hitter. But he not worth his place in their Test side,” Berry argued.

“West Indies would have a fine pace attack if it consisted of Kemar Roach, as quick as anyone in the world today; Fidel Edwards, quick too if not economical; and Andre Russell, who has serious pace and all-round potential. But Sammy keeps Russell out of the Test side.”

He continued: “In his 16 Tests as captain, Sammy has taken 37 wickets with medium-pace: fine for a fourth seamer, batting at No?6 and making the occasional century. As third seamer, he is not penetrative enough; and he has scored two fifties, one against Bangladesh. He has stopped West Indies getting worse, and he stops them getting better.”

In the Daily Mail, writer Lawrence Booth was equally critical, describing the side as “purporting to represent the best West Indies has to offer” and arguing that “had the Olympics gone to Paris, they would probably have been given only two Tests.”

Darren Sammy’s West Indies team pictured above has been roundly criticized by the English press on their arrival in London yesterday for the series which includes three test matches and three one-day internationals.

Booth pointed out that with Gayle, Ramnaresh Sarwan, Sunil Narine and Dwayne Bravo unavailable for the series because of Indian Premier League commitments, the squad was severely weakened.

He said their absence summed up the game in the Caribbean.
“These men provide their own reflection of the state of the game in the Caribbean: a world in which communication is poor, administrators are at each other’s throats, and funds are so scarce that talented cricketers are forced to place faceless franchises ahead of regional prestige,” Booth asserted.

He pointed out that if West Indies selectors performed an about turn and included the IPL-based players, the regional side would be “strong enough to give England at least a scare.”

“Instead, we will have to make do with a watered-down approximation of the real thing. And that is a source of regret – not just for the Caribbean, but for everyone who cares about cricket.”

West Indies bowl off their tour with a three-day match against Sussex at Hove starting Saturday.

Around the Web

Comments