Shared government will create gridlock

Dear Editor,

Writing in the SN of January15 under the title ‘Ramkarran did not acknowledge African feelings of disenfranchisement’ Dr David Hinds suggests:  “I make bold to say that just as the PPP’s behaviour in office  has been heavily influenced by the perception and reality of  its treatment at the hands of the PNC in office, that the PNC’s behaviour in office was also largely grounded  in similar fears, perceived and real, arising from the PPP’s 1957-64 tenure. Mr Ramkarran’s reference to the Indian Guyanese and PPP feeling of electoral disenfranchisement is spot on. But he omits the African Guyanese feelings of disenfranchisement. Whereas Indian Guyanese suffered from elections that were rigged against them, African Guyanese suffer from the fact that the electoral system is rigged against them. The PNC stole elections. The PPP has not stolen elections in the same barefaced way, but they have barefacedly stolen the executive government.”

In the ‘politics of revenge’ as Dr Hinds ‘simplistically’ termed it, he sees both the  PPP/C/PNCR as ethnic parties who fear each other. The Burnham PNC era and Jagan PPPC era must be faulted equally. The PPP/C hijacked the executive government as a minority and the PNC rigged elections as the minority, both to maintain their own hegemonic power over Guyana. Dr Hinds candidly describes the PNC’s 24 years (1968-92) as just securing their ethnic base, comparing it as similar to the seven years colonial PPP (1957-64) government. Dr Hinds ignores that same PPP record which endowed Guyana with the highest literacy rate and fed the Caribbean as its breadbasket bequeathing it to its successor.  Under the Burnham Constitution of 1980 where the PNC rigged elections, neutered parliament, bankrupted Guyana’s economy, caused a mass exodus of many talented Guyanese, destroyed press freedom, ensured the subjugation of the judiciary and paramountcy of the PNC with the 1974 Sophia Declaration, and allowed the complete destruction of the country’s infrastructure, Dr David Hinds still nevertheless insists on shared government with the PPP/C as its equal.

Nowhere does Dr  Hinds admit PNC atrocities or its massive failures under the Burnham, Hoyte, and Granger PNC(R). He fails to acknowledge or mention the current PPP/C government still governs democratically with the same overwhelmingly African bureaucracy, ethnically unbalanced armed forces and the same Burnham constitu-tion proudly put in place by the PNC.  Has there been no progress in Guyana with the PPP/C government since 1992? Apparently Dr Hinds does not see any.

Without any Indian parallel and in consistent Afrocentric advocacy, Dr Hinds continues agitating for the PPP/C to operate outside of the Guyana constitution  and share the executive government;  he hopes to achieve power by race and not by democratic elections.

Someone has to clean up the mess. The PPP/C has not done a bad job so why should Guyanese create more misery for themselves by a combination of the two on the top seat? Currently power sharing has not worked effectively in either Ireland or Zimbabwe. With the current stalemate in Guyana’s parliament it only promises to become worse in shared executive government. Dr Hinds therefore needs to get on board and give some other alternatives and concrete ideas better than Mr Ravi Dev’s federalism. Shared government is the worst compromise. It will only create legal gridlock and chaos. In a democracy someone has to guard the watchmen, hence the need for an opposition. In federalism everyone wins, especially Amerindians; it would ensure their ethnic security and survival.

Yours faithfully,
Vassan Ramracha

More in Letters

default placeholder

Bid Protest Committee ‘resignation’

Dear Editor, The Stabroek News article captioned ‘Chair of Bid Protest Committee resigns’ published in its July 27, 2016 edition is false.

default placeholder

Ministry of Public Infrastructure has budgeted for work on Leguan roads to begin in August

Dear Editor, Reference is made to the letter published in the Monday July 25, edition of the Stabroek News by Mr Hans M Buer, under the headline ‘Leguan roads are in a terrible state’.

default placeholder

Indigenous patient who broke bone on July 20 told by GPH to return August 8 for setting

Dear Editor, For years Indigenous people have struggled to cope with the health system which seems to have been designed without our people in mind.

default placeholder

Prof Persaud had a distinguished career in the Commonwealth Secretariat

Dear Editor, It was only last week in one of my pieces I mentioned that there are a few outstanding Guyanese in the diaspora.

default placeholder

Passengers treated with utter contempt at the Essequibo ferry stellings

Dear Editor, I don’t know why more people who travel on the Parika to Supenaam ferry service aren’t writing to defend the gentleman who was made to wait several hours, while other people who came after him were allowed to board the ferry.

default placeholder

Public expectation of politicians has hardened

Dear Editor, It is with surprise that one reads of reaction to the structure, functioning and legal basis of the anti-corruption unit SOCU, and of reservations about SARU.


About these comments

The comments section is intended to provide a forum for reasoned and reasonable debate on the newspaper's content and is an extension of the newspaper and what it has become well known for over its history: accuracy, balance and fairness. We reserve the right to edit or delete comments which contain attacks on other users, slander, coarse language and profanity, and gratuitous and incendiary references to race and ethnicity.

Stay updated! Follow Stabroek News on Facebook or Twitter.

Get the day's headlines from SN in your inbox every morning: