Shame: The EU’s ‘conscience payments’ to sugar; throwing good money after bad

Before starting an assessment of the key performance indicators for the Guyana sugar industry, two issues need to be addressed. Firstly, the determination of income transfers (benefits and losses) under the Sugar Protocol (SP) regime; and, secondly, the arrangement through which the European Union (EU) compensates Guyana for its denunciation of the SP.


SP benefits/losses 

Several readers have asked me to explain the mechanism through which the SP had generated income transfers (benefits/losses) for its participants. The explanation is straightforward. Let us take the case of Guyana: a 20131215clivedirect benefit is conferred to Guyana on each tonne of sugar it exports to the EU that receives an SP price, which is greater than the price Guyana would otherwise obtain, if the sugar was sold elsewhere. The total benefit is the benefit per tonne, multiplied by the amount of SP sugar exported to the EU. This total benefit is deemed the income transfer from the EU to Guyana.

Readers should immediately note: 1) as described here, this benefit is a financial or accounting one. It is not an economic benefit simply because its full economic effects would depend on how effectively it is utilized in our economy. 2) On average, Guyana has in the latter decades of the SP, exported approximately 160,000 tonnes of raw sugar to the EU market.

Using similar reasoning, if the SP price is less than the price Guyana could otherwise obtain elsewhere for its export sugar, and yet Guyana continues to meet its export obligations to the EU under the SP, Guyana suffers a loss on each tonne of sugar it sells in this way. The total of this loss would of course be determined by the quantity of sugar it exports in this manner. This loss can alternately be expressed as an income transfer from Guyana to the EU!

In the latter years of the SP, several estimates of income transfers from the EU to Guyana have been made.  I however, prefer to rely on the IMF’s, because of its access to official data on quantities exported and prices received. Their estimates show that in the 1990s the income transfers to Guyana (total accounting benefit) was equal to about 8.5 per cent of its GDP. This declined to 6.5 per cent for the period 2000-05, and was further reduced to 2.75 per cent for the last two years (2008-09) of the staggered reduction in the SP price (36 per cent, during 2006 to 2009). Table 1 shows these data:


20140223index1Table 1

EU Assistance

Several readers seem to believe (mistakenly) that, after the EU’s denunciation of the SP, Guyana had reasonably opted to continue its traditional sugar industry, because at that time it was the cheapest producer of raw sugar in the region. The data, however, show otherwise. In the mid-2000s, Guyana’s cost of sugar production was estimated at 21 US cents/lb. This was 31 per cent above Belize (16 US cents/lb). It was, however, substantially below the others as can be seen in Table 2.







20140223index2Table 2

Conscience money


EU assistance has been provided as Accompanying Measures to support ACP raw sugar exporters to its market, as they adjusted to the four-year staggered decline in the price of sugar. All beneficiaries are required to develop (together with the EU) national strategies and bodies for the implementation of these Accompanying Measures. Guyana formed the Guyana National Action Programme (GNAP) for this purpose and multiannual programmes were put in place in 2006, the first of which covered 2007-10 and the second 2011-13. The third is presently in place.

Initially, support was provided to specific sugar projects jointly identified by Guyana and the EU. Presently the assistance is given as general budgetary support and therefore paid directly into the Consolidated Fund.


Previously, I had termed this assistance “conscience money”, which Caribbean mendicant governments have accepted in exchange for not legally challenging the EU’s denunciation of the SP. Readers should recall the EU had cynically denounced the SP when it no longer served its interests, although the SP was framed as a treaty of “indefinite duration”, which could not be unilaterally denounced. I stand by that judgment today. Indeed what further concerns me is that, despite abundant evidence, which shows GuySuCo cannot deliver the industry’s salvation, the EU has never championed calls for a National Task Force to consider sugar’s role over the very long run (to 2050); and arising from this, therefore, how its funding could best be directed towards assisting in alternative scenarios.  Instead it continues to throw good money after bad, in order to salve its conscience while ignoring the plight of the industry and country.

Up to mid-2013 as much as 91.5 million euros of assistance had been provided by the EU. Nominally, these funds are supposed to be disbursed on the basis of mutually agreed indicators, developed jointly by the EU Delegation to Guyana and the Steering Committee of GNAP. These include specific conditions related to industry investment, and performance areas. I shall assess this as the columns proceed.

In mid-2013, the government had proffered to the EU a Draft Strategic Plan (2013-17) as the firm expression of its commitment to performance improvements. It further promised to finalize the draft shortly. Regrettably, we are at the end of the second month of 2014, and to the best of my knowledge no public announcement has been made about this.

Next week I shall begin to examine the industry’s performance indicators. During that examination I will comment further on the Draft Strategic Plan and the EU’s Accompanying Measures.


Latest in Features, Sunday

LUCAS STOCK INDEXThe Lucas Stock Index (LSI) rose 0.54 per cent during the third period of trading in June 2016. The stocks of six companies were traded with 79,573 shares changing hands. There were three Climbers and one Tumbler. The stocks of Banks DIH (DIH) rose 1.98 per cent on the sale of 18,757 while the stocks of Demerara Distillers Limited (DDL) rose 5.26 per cent on the sale of 41,667 shares. In addition, the stocks of Demerara Tobacco Company (DTC) rose 1.51 per cent on the sale of 13,603 shares. In contrast, the stocks of Demerara Bank Limited (DBL) fell 5.26 per cent on the sale of 4,324 shares.  In the meanwhile, the stocks of Guyana Bank for Trade and Industry (BTI) and Republic Bank Limited (RBL) remained unchanged on the sale of 222 and 1,000 shares respectively.

Massy and Guyana (Part 1)

Steadfast Last year, this writer looked at the Massy Group of Companies formerly Neal and Massy to gain an understanding of the operations of this company which has been doing business in Guyana for the past 48 years. 


Value-added performance of the forest sub-sector: Erratic, weak, declining

Erratic Last week’s column highlighted what I consider to be a most distinctive feature of the extractive forest sub-sector’s performance in Guyana’s economy, during the past decade.

default placeholder

The UK bids Europe farewell

On June 23 by a small majority, the British people voted to remove themselves from the European Union (EU). The decision has consequences for the Caribbean.

default placeholder

What would life be without sport?

I wonder what it would be like to exclude sport completely from one’s life for, say, one year? No playing sport, no watching it, no reading it no discussing it no thinking about it even.

default placeholder

Brexit: Lessons for Caricom

The results of the referendum held in Britain to determine whether or not it should remain in or leave the European Union (EU), has been won by voters who supported the leave option.

Director of Sport Christopher Jones and President of the Guyana Chess Federation Irshad Mohammed (centre) stand with some members of the 2016 Guyana Olympiad chess team. The team travels to Baku, Azerbaijan, for participation at the Olympiad in September. A signature qualifying tournament was not held to determine the members of Guyana’s Olympiad chess team.

Federation picks chess Olympiad team without holding qualifier

The Guyana Chess Federation (GCF) has decided upon a 2016 Guyana Olympiad chess team without hosting a qualification competition to determine the competence of its participants.

Quamina Farrier

Heavy on historic significance, Journey to Freedom failed as a musical

Several Guyanese plays of historic significance were recently staged at the Theatre Guild and National Cultural Centre as part of a Jubilee festival.

Pawpaw Fruit Soup with Passion Fruit Photo by Cynthia Nelson

Fruit soup

If you’re looking for an easy dessert that uses mostly fruit, then you’ve hit the jackpot when you make a fruit soup.


About these comments

The comments section is intended to provide a forum for reasoned and reasonable debate on the newspaper's content and is an extension of the newspaper and what it has become well known for over its history: accuracy, balance and fairness. We reserve the right to edit or delete comments which contain attacks on other users, slander, coarse language and profanity, and gratuitous and incendiary references to race and ethnicity.

Stay updated! Follow Stabroek News on Facebook or Twitter.

Get the day's headlines from SN in your inbox every morning: