Williams challenges Rodney Inquiry over decision to allow hearsay evidence

PNCR Chairman Basil Williams has criticised the Commission of Inquiry (CoI) into the death of Dr Walter Rodney for allowing hearsay evidence during the ongoing public hearings, while warning against “a free-for-all” that could damage the reputations of both individuals and organisations.

Williams, an attorney who is part of the legal team representing the PNCR’s interest at the hearings, yesterday accused commissioners of suspending the laws by allowing evidence that would be inadmissible in a court of law but they denied the charge, while standing by their decision to relax the rules.

Williams’ objections came while the Commission was admitting into evidence two books from Reverend Reuben Gilbert, who had moments earlier testified that the then PNC administration, led by Prime Minister Forbes Burnham, had refused him employment and blacklisted him as a “security risk’ to the country.

Basil Williams
Basil Williams

Gilbert also stated that he had been harassed and beaten by members of the PNC’s youth arm, the Young Socialist Movement (YSM), during that time.

“The Commission has suspended Guyanese laws and so there is no filtering here. People can come in and say all kinds of things… basically is a free-for-all,” Williams told Commission Chairman Sir Richard Cheltenham, while arguing that the probe into Rodney’s death was a serious one and such evidence should not be allowed because it threatens to damage to the reputation of individuals and organisations.

Commissioner Seenath Jairam SC, however, objected to Williams’ outburst. “Mr. Williams, I think you haven’t thought through that statement. We have not suspended the laws. We are bound by the laws. You are making a very serious statement and it is reflecting very badly on us. I think you’re not being fair to us,” he said, noting that he was personally insulted by the statement.

But Williams fired back that while the Commission can make rules, those rules cannot eradicate the rights of Guyanese. Jairam, however, stated that CoI would “sift and determine the relevance” of all evidence presented in the trial.

Sir Richard also stated that the rules allowed for flexibility given the nature of the inquiry.

Williams then retorted that the commissioner must be aware of the “politically charged atmosphere” the CoI was being conducted in.

Commissioner Jacqueline Samuels-Browne, however, cautioned him to be specific about his objections. She stated that Guyana’s laws give the Commission the right to make its own rules. “You have said the rules of evidence can be relaxed and adjusted for the Commission of Inquiry and the rules may be relaxed… so while your caution is accepted, when you raise these objections you should be specific as to the matter you are referring and not give a wide-ranging objection,” she said.

Latest in Local News

default placeholder

Jason Holder breaks into one-day top 20

DUBAI, United Arab Emirates, CMC – Captain Jason Holder has broken into the top 20 of the One-Day International rankings for the first time in his career, following strong performances during the just concluded Tri-Nations Series.

image

EU hands over $2b, coastal engineering design manual

Minister of Public Infrastructure, David Patterson, today (right) received a final copy of the Coastal Engineering Design Manual for the Guyana Sea and River Defences from European Union (EU) Ambassador, Jernej Videtič.

default placeholder

Canal No.1 man shot in robbery

The police in ‘D’ Division say they are investigating a shooting incident during a robbery which occurred at 0100h. today committed on Shamiran Tebonie, 36 years, of Dudley Park, Canal No.

default placeholder

Guyana Goldfields in deal to expand production

Gold production at the Canadian-owned Guyana Goldfields Inc (GGI) for the first half of this year has been estimated at 75,000 ounces and the company has entered an agreement to expand the capacity of its Aurora mine in Cuyuni/Mazaruni.

default placeholder

Stealth flight plane grounded in Anguilla

One of two planes that left Guyana illegally under the cover of darkness on Saturday has been given clearance to leave Anguilla and the other was grounded in the British overseas territory, Minister of Public Infrastructure David Patterson has said.

The remains of the home Satesh Jagmohan was occupying when tragedy struck

De Willem teen burns to death in house fire

A 19-year-old labourer perished in a mysterious fire which destroyed a two-bedroom house in the De Willem, West Coast Demerara (WCD) squatting area on Saturday night.

default placeholder

ExxonMobil set to drill more oil wells

American oil firm ExxonMobil will be drilling more wells after an appraisal well confirmed the presence of a significant deposit of oil in the location close to where the first well was drilled.

default placeholder

Implement anti-discrimination laws quickly – outgoing US Embassy Deputy

It is important that Guyana move quickly to enact anti-discrimination laws as discrimination and homophobia “is a very real problem” for the Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender (LBGT) community here, outgoing Deputy Chief of Mission at the US Embassy here, Bryan Hunt has said.

Comments

About these comments

The comments section is intended to provide a forum for reasoned and reasonable debate on the newspaper's content and is an extension of the newspaper and what it has become well known for over its history: accuracy, balance and fairness. We reserve the right to edit or delete comments which contain attacks on other users, slander, coarse language and profanity, and gratuitous and incendiary references to race and ethnicity.

Stay updated! Follow Stabroek News on Facebook or Twitter.

Get the day's headlines from SN in your inbox every morning: