Instructive profiles should be published on respective selectees for silk

Dear Editor,

Out of familiar woodwork crawls another worm in unbelievable covering – silk.

This time however the worm crawls tentatively, apprehensively, sensing the impending legal fiasco involving an advertisement for applicants for appointment as Senior Counsel – one more reflection of the shams which befall a people whose constitution is no longer viable, and a country where the rule of law has been subverted.

The applications are to be sent to the Office of the Chancellor, but one eminent jurist of international renown has contended that there is no such legal position.

The reasoning in the first instance relies on Article 127(1) of the Constitution which provides that the Chancellor be appointed by the President, after obtaining the agreement of the Leader of the Opposition. It is public knowledge however that there is no such agreement.

Following is the constructive advice that Article 127(2) allows a judge to be appointed to perform the functions of chief justice if he is unable, but there is a substantive chief justice who is not unable.

Article 127(2) also allows the temporary appointment of a judge until a chancellor is appointed, but that person cannot be the chief justice because the constitution requires the chief justice who is not unable to be in place to perform his functions. It would therefore be appropriate for a justice of appeal to be appointed to perform the functions where the office of chancellor is vacant until a substantive chancellor is appointed. The argument emphasizes that Article 127 would not allow the manipulation which has taken place since the constitution simply does not allow an acting chief justice, when there is a substantive chief justice in place and able to perform.

More provocative perhaps is the contention that the chancellor is not the head of the Guyana judiciary, but the President of the Caribbean Court of Justice which my advisor insists is Guyana’s highest court.

Consequently he considers the impending fiasco as disallowing the Caribbean Court of Justice which has functioned as Guyana’s highest court since 2005 from having a say as to the persons who are qualified to be appointed as senior counsel. Importantly he has pointed to the fact that the CCJ in many judgments has commented adversely upon the competence and character of some judges and lawyers. Notwithstanding there clearly appears a plan to degrade the appointment of senior counsel by recruiting from material which can hardly match silk.

Consequently the aforementioned perspective anticipates that the public, already plundered by excessive charges, and aggrieved by professional misconduct, will be required to endure more of the same. The public has so far not been informed of the composition of the panel that will evaluate the credentials of the candidates. Indeed there is strong presumption of a fait accompli that will transgress any semblance of transparency. If so the fallout across the legal system would be ominously negative.

The fiasco could only provide more opportunities for clients to be exploited by underqualified practitioners.

This informed observer concludes with the following very trenchant comment:

There will inevitably be a revision of the judgments and publication in due course of observations made by the court on the successful candidates who have attempted to appear in the country’s highest court. The proceedings are on record in all cases. There will probably be appointees whose names have never been included in law reports to indicate that they made distinguished contributions to the development of the law and are persons of respectability. Those are essential criteria for determining who are appointed senior counsel in a civilised system of law.

It is not unreasonable to expect therefore that instructive profiles will be published in the interest of satisfying all stakeholders of the merits of the respective selectees.

‘In the meantime’ muttered the silkworm, ‘better return to the woodwork.’


Yours faithfully,
E B John

More in Letters

default placeholder

Bid Protest Committee ‘resignation’

Dear Editor, The Stabroek News article captioned ‘Chair of Bid Protest Committee resigns’ published in its July 27, 2016 edition is false.

default placeholder

Ministry of Public Infrastructure has budgeted for work on Leguan roads to begin in August

Dear Editor, Reference is made to the letter published in the Monday July 25, edition of the Stabroek News by Mr Hans M Buer, under the headline ‘Leguan roads are in a terrible state’.

default placeholder

Indigenous patient who broke bone on July 20 told by GPH to return August 8 for setting

Dear Editor, For years Indigenous people have struggled to cope with the health system which seems to have been designed without our people in mind.

default placeholder

Prof Persaud had a distinguished career in the Commonwealth Secretariat

Dear Editor, It was only last week in one of my pieces I mentioned that there are a few outstanding Guyanese in the diaspora.

default placeholder

Passengers treated with utter contempt at the Essequibo ferry stellings

Dear Editor, I don’t know why more people who travel on the Parika to Supenaam ferry service aren’t writing to defend the gentleman who was made to wait several hours, while other people who came after him were allowed to board the ferry.

default placeholder

Public expectation of politicians has hardened

Dear Editor, It is with surprise that one reads of reaction to the structure, functioning and legal basis of the anti-corruption unit SOCU, and of reservations about SARU.


About these comments

The comments section is intended to provide a forum for reasoned and reasonable debate on the newspaper's content and is an extension of the newspaper and what it has become well known for over its history: accuracy, balance and fairness. We reserve the right to edit or delete comments which contain attacks on other users, slander, coarse language and profanity, and gratuitous and incendiary references to race and ethnicity.

Stay updated! Follow Stabroek News on Facebook or Twitter.

Get the day's headlines from SN in your inbox every morning: