Senior Counsel appointments to be transparent -Chancellor

The appointment of Senior Counsel, after an 18 year gap, will be done in a transparent, fair and justifiable manner based on recommendations made, according to acting Chancellor of the Judiciary Carl Singh.

Justice Singh told Stabroek New that there will be a process, however, he did not go into the details of the methodology for selection and who will be participating in it.

The process of Senior Counsel elevations has long been an informal endeavour with no defined time frame between appointments. Stabroek News understands that the 18-year gap—the last appointments were done in 1996—was due to the fact that because it was the president who had made the recommendations for elevation to Senior Counsel.

Last week, a notice from the Office of the Chancellor invited eligible attorneys to submit written applications to be elevated to the position.

Previously, former magistrate Dawn Holder had raised the issue that there was a perception within Guyana that Senior Counsel appointments were a form of reward for political connections and not based solely on professional merit. She had been vocal about the need for a transparent process, saying, “It’s not a transparent process and there does not seem to be any criteria, or publicly stated criteria. In other professions, there is not this opaque process. For accountants, doctors, engineers, academics for promotion or specialist accreditation, there are exams or peer review or clear publicly stated criteria.  The legal profession alone recognises achievement in the legal profession, not from the Bar Association, but from government or with government involvement.”

Most recently attorney Jonas M F Coddett in a letter to Stabroek News called for the same, while questioning the lack of female representation at the Senior Counsel level. Holder had stated that since 2009, “No women were appointed nor were any appointed before….”

The notice outlined the criteria which are: over 15 years of service; expert up-to-date legal knowledge with a record of accurate and relevant application of such knowledge; a record of written and oral advocacy; a reputation for appropriate deportment, decorum and interpersonal relationships with professional colleagues befitting that of a member of the inner Bar; and a reputation for honesty and integrity particularly with respect to professional dealings with the court, with clients and all other parties. Applicants have up to May 30 to submit proposals to the Office of the Chancellor.

The notice has departed from the norm by requesting applications as opposed to having persons appointed through a recommendation process. Head of the Guyana Bar Association Ronald Burch-Smith addressed the departure from tradition, while noting that elevations to Senior Counsel have been long overdue.

Burch-Smith stated that the way in which the Office of the Chancellor chose to advertise was necessary although many may find advertising for applicants crass. He said that in the changing world this was how things were done and that he welcomed the notice in the newspapers inviting applicants.

Burch-Smith told Stabroek News that the appointment of Senior Counsel did not need to be done in an old fashioned way and that this may be how they need to be advertised in the future to ensure that the appointments occurred on a regular basis.

 

“It is a very important appointment and a mark of recognition for excellent work,” Burch-Smith stated, adding that based on skills there would have been a substantial amount of persons who would be deserving of the appointment since the last elevations in 1996, when former Speaker of the National Assembly Ralph Ramkarran, Richard Fields, former Attorney General Charles Ramson, acting Chief Justice Ian Chang, Moen McDoom and the late Samuel Brotherson were elevated.

Comments  

SVN student tops CAPE

Vamanadev Hiralall, of the privately-run Saraswati Vidya Niketan (SVN), is the country’s top performer at this year’s Caribbean Advanced Proficiency Examinations (CAPE) after achieving an accumulated 13 grade one and 3 grade two passes.

By ,

Top CSEC students say number of subjects increase options, test limits

Twenty-six students in the top one percent of the 12,684 who sat this year’s Caribbean Secondary Education Certification (CSEC) examinations earned 12 or more Grade I passes, with half of them, including the top performer, coming from Queen’s College (QC).

By ,

Hemraj Kissoon, others testify at CoI for return of lands

On the second day of the Commission of Inquiry (CoI) into African ancestral lands and other matters, four witnesses made cases for the return of lands they feel they are rightly entitled to, which were either taken by the state or occupied by private owners.

By ,

Wheelchair bound accused found dead in prison cell

Shelton George, the man charged with both murdering a waitress at a Chinese restaurant and the attempted murder of a magistrate, was found dead in his cell at the Lusignan Prison yesterday morning.

Triumph NDC orders halt to ground-shaking works

The Chairman of the Triumph Neighbourhood Democratic Council (NDC) yesterday instructed workers employed on a private site, reportedly intended to build a first-floor pool, to cease operations, just two days after residents called on authorities to halt its construction.

By ,

Your browser is out-of-date!

Update your browser to view this website correctly.

We built stabroeknews.com using new technology. This makes our website faster, more feature rich and easier to use for 95% of our readers.
Unfortunately, your browser does not support some of these technologies. Click the button below and choose a modern browser to receive our intended user experience.

Update my browser now

×