Dear Editor,
The Public Procurement Commission (PPC) recently concluded its report on the summary of findings in relation to the award of a contract to the Tepui Group Inc. As expected, certain media houses have questioned why the PPC could not have revoked the contract since so many “breaches” were found. Although the summary of findings showed a number of inconsistencies in the evaluation process, there was no established breach, per se, of the Procurement Act. This is an important point to note that escaped the media. The PPC does not have the legal authority to rescind or revoke any contract. In the circumstances, the PPC is restricted to providing recommendations for remedial action (s), which it did. It should be noted, too, that the PPC is not a Court of Law, therefore it does not have the powers of a Court of law.
With respect to the question of taking action, which the complainant, former minister and current Member of Parliament, David Patterson, had requested, it is important to draw attention to a previous matter involving the said Minister, which was fundamentally dissimilar in nature. To that end, the PPC’s investigation into the infamous feasibility study for the new Demerara Harbour Bridge under former Minister Patterson is on the PPC’s website for reference. The findings showed that the former minister was found to be directly in breach of the Procurement Act. Multiple breaches of the Act were established, yet, to date, the former Minister has not been penalized or held accountable. It is for this very reason whereby the Procurement Act does not provide penalties for breaches.
Notwithstanding, in the case of Patterson, if under the Fiscal Management and Accountability Act (FMAA)―misappropriation of public funds is/was established, then, he can be prosecuted. It is important to note, as well, that there was no evidence supporting the notion that the evaluation process was skewed in favour of a preferred bidder, because whatever was done in the evaluation process was applied across the board.
Sincerely,
Joel Bhagwandin
Commissioner, PPC
