Jury still out

Dear Editor,

The jury will still be out when it comes to deciding whether capital punishment should be taken off our statute books. In today’s SN we are informed about the commutation of the death sentence for two brothers who were on death row for over 18 years and despite appeals and requests by their attorney it was the UNHRC which concluded in 2004 that their trial had been unfair and recommended “an effective remedy, including commutation of their death sentence.”

Many years ago I had a different view with respect to the abolition of capital punishment compared to today. DNA evidence in the USA has helped to free persons convicted and sentenced to death. And besides the inhumaneness of execution, the possibility of sentencing an innocent person through a jury trial had always been a strong argument for its elimination. Further it is claimed that most murders are not premeditated.

The commutation of the death penalty has spared their lives, but they have a life sentence which some prisoners when released by pardon compare to a death sentence. The victims’ relatives and others may argue that the decision which was originally handed down was supposed to be punitive and was not carried out, but there may be a hidden one of ‘conscience’ which they will have to live with forever.

Yours faithfully,
V O Patrick

More in Letters

Comments

About these comments

The comments section is intended to provide a forum for reasoned and reasonable debate on the newspaper's content and is an extension of the newspaper and what it has become well known for over its history: accuracy, balance and fairness. We reserve the right to edit or delete comments which contain attacks on other users, slander, coarse language and profanity, and gratuitous and incendiary references to race and ethnicity.

Get the day's headlines from SN in your inbox every morning:

Most Read This Week

  1. Bibi O’Donovan

    UK-based woman dead, daughter in hospital

  2. Kelly Datt

    Bandits shoot dead one of their own during Edinburgh robbery

  3. Sueanna Walcott

    Mahaicony crash claims second victim

  4. Area where Akeem Grimmond’s body was found

    Boy, 14, found murdered in burial ground

  5. Nazim Jabhar and Angela Jabhar

    Woman critical, niece, 3, injured in Albion hit and run

  6. 20160818cape1

    Passion, dedication and sacrifice yield success for top CAPE students

  7. Malika Hamilton

    Prime suspect in murder of Ann’s Grove girl found hiding in barrel

  8. Jermain Holder

    11-year-old electrocuted


Recommended For You