Ramkarran wins case at UK Privy Council

Ralph Ramkarran

Senior Counsel Ralph Ramkarran SC has successfully represented Trinidad High Commissioner to India, Dave Persad, in the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council (JCPC) in London, United Kingdom, in the case of Dave Persad (Appellant) v Anirude Singh (Respondent) which was heard on June 21.

The case pertained to a claim by Singh against Persad  in 2002 for arrears of rent, damages for breach of covenant  and mesne profits arising from a breach of a lease agreement under which Persad’s business premises were leased from Singh at Manzanilla Road, Mayaro, Trinidad.

The lease was between Singh and Chicken Hawaii (Trinidad) Ltd (“CHTL”), a company established by Persad after he had personally negotiated the terms of the lease. The first  time Singh became aware that the lessee was going to be CHTL and not Persad was when he received the lease agreement which Persad, a lawyer, had prepared. He nevertheless signed the lease, knowing that a company had a separate legal personality.

Singh issued proceedings against both CHTL and Persad, claiming that the latter had “at all material times acted on his own.” Justice Pemberton gave judgment for some TT$44,000 with interest and costs. The Judge found that Persad acted “in his personal capacity” in negotiating the lease and that it was evident that “this was a one man show in the hope that if all was not well he would not be held personally liable.” The Trinidad Court of Appeal upheld the decision on the ground that a “court may pierce the corporate veil when there is an abuse of the corporate personality to frustrate the legal consequences of one’s actions.” Both Pemberton J and the Court of Appeal found that this is what Persad did.

The JCPC, in considering whether Persad was liable, which was the main point in the appeal, rejected the reasoning of Justice Pemberton and the Court of Appeal. It referred to Salomon v Salomon, decided in 1897, which established and defined the corporate personality of companies and emphasized that companies are formed for the purpose of avoiding individual liability. It referred to two recently decided cases of VTB and Prest, which ruled that a person must have an existing legal obligation which the person seeks to avoid by establishing a company. The JCPC found that Persad had no legal obligation which he evaded by forming CHTL and was therefore not liable. The appeal was upheld in Persad’s favour with costs. Singh was represented by Anand Beharrylal, a British-Trinidadian Barrister.

The JCPC is Trinidad’s final court of appeal, Trinidad not having yet joined the Caribbean Court of Justice, which is seated in Trinidad.

Appeals from Guyana to the JCPC were abolished in 1970 when this country became a Republic. Its final court is now the Caribbean Court of Justice.





Maurice Arjoon’s lawyer in bid to levy on NBS

  The legal team for former New Building Society (NBS) manager, Maurice Arjoon, who was wrongfully dismissed, have levied on the bank’s assets in a bid to recoup the $59,033,000 pension owed to him by the financial institution.

Mahaicony farmer who drove car without permission dies in crash

An alleged inebriated farmer of 54 Strath Campbell Village, Mahaicony, ECD, died at about 3 pm  yesterday at Chance Village, Mahaicony, after a vehicle he was reportedly not given permission to drive, crashed into a utility pole.

Quarter-final curse fells Nadal again as Cilic advances

MELBOURNE,  (Reuters) – Rafa Nadal’s Australian Open quarter-final curse struck again on Tuesday, an injury forcing the top seed to retire in the fifth set against Croatia’s Marin Cilic.

Hundreds more sugar workers to be laid off

Several hundred more sugar workers are expected to be laid off from the Skeldon, Rose Hall, and East Demerara estates by next month and the Guyana Agricultural and General Workers Union (GAWU) yesterday urged that the decision be reviewed.

Order signed for setting up of telecoms agency

The commencement order establishing the Telecommunications Agency was signed last Friday, in anticipation of the liberalisation of the telecoms sector, Minister of Public Tele-communications Cathy Hughes announced yesterday.

Your browser is out-of-date!

Update your browser to view this website correctly.

We built stabroeknews.com using new technology. This makes our website faster, more feature rich and easier to use for 95% of our readers.
Unfortunately, your browser does not support some of these technologies. Click the button below and choose a modern browser to receive our intended user experience.

Update my browser now